It’s become an element of business orthodoxy: Data and analytics should be part of your strategy. That’s unsurprising given that data and analytics are pervasive in our lives and, of course, in our business lives.
There is no shortage of examples of organizations that use data and analysis in support of strategy. Google’s initiative to set ad prices based on an analytical feedback loop is just one case in point.
But what about using data and analytics to directly derive your strategy?
When it comes to making critical decisions—those that have a direct bearing on the organization’s strategy and perhaps even its future—too many leaders lean too much on their experience and business intuition at a time when the power to explore scenarios through analytics is exploding.
Leaders seem to understand that when it comes to decision-making in critical situations, something is missing. Primary research with 400 senior leaders conducted by my firm, L.E.K. Consulting, reported an average success rate of less than 50% when it comes to making the most consequential decisions. Despite an abundance of data and having clear decision-making processes in place, many organizations fall well short of using their information effectively.
When data drives strategy, clarity and better execution tend to follow. There are success stories, of course—situations where heavy enlistment of data helped formulate the strategy, instead of just simply vetting and validating it.
- Hewlett Packard’s Strategic Split: Under then-CEO Meg Whitman, the decision to split HP into HP Inc. and Hewlett Packard Enterprise was based on a clear understanding of the company’s sprawling operations and its need for agility to stay competitive in the rapidly changing tech landscape. This move, supported by detailed analysis and forecasting across myriad scenarios, showcases how data-informed, decisive leadership can turn around the fortunes of a struggling giant. The success of this strategic decision—resulting in a significant recovery for HP—underscores the importance of leadership courage and vision, supported by solid data.
- Spotify’s Subscription Model Decision: Spotify’s pivot to a subscription-based streaming service was a strategic decision shaped by deep analysis of user behavior and market trends. This move not only capitalized on the growing consumer preference for streaming access over ownership, but also revolutionized the music industry, demonstrating the power of data to drive significant shifts in business models and industry standards.
- Starbucks’ Location Strategy: Starbucks’ ongoing decisions about where to position stores employ advanced analytics and geographic information systems to determine optimal locations for new stores. This data-driven approach considers local demographics, traffic patterns, and existing store performance, ensuring that each new location is positioned to succeed. Starbucks’ methodical use of data to guide expansion decisions underscores the role of analytics in enhancing operational success and improving market positioning.
DATA-DRIVEN DECISIONS ARE BETTER
Leaders that take this approach vouch for it. Our research highlights that organizations that adopt this style have a significant advantage, particularly in critical or transformational decisions. Of the companies that felt they were best-in-class in making critical decisions, the highest percentage of leaders—31%—had a data-rational style, outstripping all other methods. By contrast, only 18% favored a consensus-driven approach.
NAVIGATING BARRIERS TO DATA-DRIVEN DECISIONS
If the advantages of data-rational decision-making are so clear, why isn’t this style more widely embraced? What keeps more leaders from adopting this style when the stakes are highest?
Cumbersome approval processes represent a significant barrier; some leaders feel that introducing too much data invites greater interrogation. However, according to the leaders we surveyed, a more significant barrier to effective decision-making is simple decision overload. More than half (54%) reported that they spend too much time on tactical decision-making, which means they don’t have the bandwidth to apply sufficient analysis of data and scenarios, even for the most critical decisions where strategy or survival are at stake.
External factors, macroeconomic challenges, and the general pace of change in the world tend to aggravate the situation—65% of leaders reported that greater uncertainty has made effective decision-making more difficult.
TWO STEPS TOWARD BETTER DECISION-MAKING
To overcome these barriers, consider two key steps:
- Invest In Analytic Systems And Talent: Three out of five leaders plan to enhance their decision-making skills by investing in analytics and data science talent over the next three years. Strategic investments like these are essential for building a solid foundation for data-rational decision-making.
- Prioritize Versatility: While data-rational decision-making should be the default, versatility in decision styles remains essential. It’s not about choosing between data-rational and other approaches but rather knowing how and when to integrate them.
For instance, ethically sensitive decisions may benefit from a consensus-driven approach that incorporates many perspectives. The result will be a richer set of insights. Versatility complements rather than competes with a data-rational foundation, allowing leaders to adapt their decision-making style according to the specifics of the situation.
A CULTURAL SHIFT
Data-rational decision-making should be the default in most organizations, particularly when they reach critical moments in their lifecycles. Achieving this requires a deliberate shift in culture and strategy. By investing in analytics capabilities, fostering a culture that values data-driven insights, and embracing versatility, your organization will be better positioned to navigate the complexities of the modern business landscape. As the pace of change accelerates, the ability to adapt, informed by solid data and flexible decision-making styles, will distinguish successful leaders and ensure on-target decisions in an increasingly uncertain world.