It wasn’t that long ago that investing in a company meant a person was consciously taking an ownership stake in the business, and by extension, a share of the responsibility for how it acted in the world.
The rise of mutual funds and index funds has largely obscured the direct link between investors and individual businesses. Most people on the street couldn’t tell you whether they hold shares in a specific company.
For some people, this disconnect has been disconcerting, giving rise to what is often broadly termed “values-based investing,” seeking to give participants better transparency and control over where their investment dollars go. But it’s a very broad space, often without clear definitions.
VALUES-BASED INVESTING GLOSSARY
To help clarify things, here are some of the terms and acronyms often used in this space, and my best attempt to define and contextualize them.
- Values-Based Investing: The broadest umbrella for the idea of aligning investments with personal beliefs—whatever they might be.
- SRI (Socially Responsible Investing): As one of the first acronyms to appear in the space, SRI offers a promise to consider the social impacts of businesses in a portfolio. It is often exclusionary, “screening out” companies that don’t meet certain standards.
- ESG (Environmental/Social/Governance): A more common term in the past decade, ESG seeks to define what specific areas on which to focus, either excluding or deliberately including certain firms. ESG guidelines seek to promote what it defines as environmentally-friendly businesses that offer benefits to society and have strong governance (referring to ethical business practices and representation).
- Green Investing: A subset of ESG, this refers to a singular focus on environmental matters, even to the exclusion of other factors.
- Faith-Based Investing: This refers to funds that use religious principles to guide investments. Since faiths are unique, there are specific subsets of this category, but a broad faith-based approach will generally seek to invest in companies that uphold (or don’t degrade) human dignity, may have a position on vice stocks, and may have a position on environmental matters.
- BRI (Biblically Responsible Investing): This is a subset of faith-based investing that uses biblical principles to set its standards.
- Religiously-Specific Investing: Yet another refinement of faith-based investing, these funds will often share many common attributes with broader faith-based funds but will be tailored to the beliefs of a specific faith—Catholic, Jewish, or Islamic.
- Impact Investing/Mission Investing: These terms usually refer to investments focused on one specific topic, such as clean water or fighting poverty in a specific part of the world. Funds using this term are usually more willing to forego or place less emphasis on returns.
How these are applied can also differ significantly. Some firms will say they are abiding by a set of guidelines if 51% of their holdings are aligned with the described values. Others are draconian, which significantly shrinks their potential investment universe.
ADDRESSING THE “BURDEN OF KNOWLEDGE”
Frontier Asset Management, my firm, has what we call “faith-based” strategies. We have principles around human dignity and ethical business practices, among other guidelines, but we have not traditionally been totally exclusionary of vice stocks (alcohol, tobacco, and gambling).
While we believe in the value of alternative energy, we don’t invest in many leading solar panel companies, because a number of these overseas firms use forced labor to make their products. Once you know about things like that, you must decide how to respond—what we call the burden of knowledge. Enslaved labor is a hard no for us, no matter the industry.
Likewise, we changed our policies on tobacco firms when we found that industry leaders were targeting children overseas in a way that couldn’t align with our goals of promoting human health. There are hundreds of choices and judgment calls we have made along similar lines, and the same is true of other firms offering values-based investing.
GETTING STARTED WITH VALUES-BASED INVESTING
If you are an investor and values-based investing seems like it might be a fit for you, here’s how you can get started.
1. Consider Your Values—Alone And With Others
What are the things that matter most in life to you? What are the red lines you wouldn’t want an investment to cross? Just as importantly, where is the grey area? While time with your own thoughts is valuable, be sure to include others, especially family, who might also be affected by changes in investments. Have an idea of your goals before you start. Otherwise, it can be overwhelming.
2. Do Some Research
There are a lot of products out there promising values alignment in investing. Don’t just buy shares in the first one you see. Spend time digging into what they promise and how they execute. Are they just exclusionary? How rigidly are rules applied? Identify those of interest and what you like about them.
3. Talk To Your Advisor Or Seek One Out
Some products like faith-based investments are not sold directly to individuals but are accessed through advisors. Not all advisors want to offer specialized investments like these. Those active in this space can help you refine your plan. Importantly, they can help you model how this will change your portfolio and offer recommendations. Are you all in, or want to try with just a portion of your portfolio? How specific can you get?
Understanding what is promised and how it is applied—or not applied—is the key to finding an investment that aligns with an investor’s values. And I think that’s a principle and a right that should be available to all investors, whatever their beliefs.
The information provided here is not investment, tax, or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation.
Robert E. Miller, CFA, is the CEO of Frontier Asset Management.