Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What can The Real Housewives teach us about consumer behavior? To understand reality, suspend it

The next time you’re thinking about predicting trends, product launches, or social content, flashback to any Housewives reunion special you’ve watched.

Woman shopping on her mobile phone

[Images: Adobe Stock/Wayhome Studio]

Profile photo of Lorne Lucree

The Real Housewives have provided the world with a lot over the years: Theresa’s table flip, Lisa’s stuffed bunny, Dorit’s accent, NeNe and Kim, The Real Housewives of Miami (was I the only one who enjoyed seasons 1-3?), and Dorinda making it nice.

The show of course brings the drama, and whether manufactured or not, it keeps it exciting and can be hard to keep up with (just ask my husband). From one season to the next, there are different alliances and some housewives fall in and out of favor, situations get more and more ridiculous (Heather’s black eye, anyone?), and viewers are expected to keep up.

How? By suspending their understanding of reality and getting used to these paradoxes.

“Wait, I thought Bethany and Carol were best friends?” Nope—well, at least not this season.

Interestingly, this ability to suspend reality is also something consumer marketers should develop as a skill set. Your intuition, logic, and reason sometimes should now be set aside to truly understand how consumer behavior is evolving—needs, wants, and trends are no longer so simple to predict, and increasingly they are only making sense in hindsight.

For example, who would have predicted that fragrance would be the “unexpected star” of the pandemic, according to Business of Fashion, with sales growing year over year while all other categories suffered? Or that brands helmed by influencers with followers in the millions would be pulled from Sephora shelves based on poor performance?

A study by Accenture perfectly summed up this somewhat confusing state of the world, articulating it as the new “human paradox.” There is a lot of push and pull and multi-faceted dynamics happening that are shaping consumer behavior in all-new and often unexpected ways.

This often results in business impacts that don’t necessarily make sense at first glance, but once you dig deeper, make all the sense in the world:

“I care about the planet, but I’m not willing to spend $2 more on a product with sustainable packaging and ingredients.”

“It’s important to me that brands be inclusive, but not inclusive to those with political views different from mind.”

Behaving inconsistently is becoming the new normal, and Accenture found “69% of consumers globally think that paradoxical behaviors are both human and acceptable.”

As marketers, innovators, and product developers, this doesn’t make life any easier, as it’s no longer enough to trust your intuition or even to take consumer surveys or research at face value. The reality is, a more nuanced approach is now necessary.

So beyond suspending your belief in reality (which Andy Cohen has been so helpful in training us to do), what will it take to make sense of this new consumer paradox?

LIFE-CENTRIC DATA

Accenture notes the importance of shifting one’s mindset from purely consumer-centric to life-centric, or “one that takes into consideration the humanity of the consumer, their shifting modes and the unpredictable life forces that come into play along the way.”

What’s the easiest way to do this? In my opinion, it’s not looking at sales data or macro trends, but instead looking at conversations happening on social media. This is where the paradox is playing out in real time. Beauty products can literally sell out overnight based on a recommendation, or an influencer could be canceled overnight based on a single piece of news or one post. The conversation is happening in real time and is reflective of real consumer sentiment and values.

STRIKING A BALANCE BETWEEN FOUNDER AND COMMUNITY

Having a popular influencer heading a brand is not enough to guarantee success. But having a founder that is complex, transparent, and has a point of view can bring these paradoxes to life in a way that resonates with their community. It’s so simple to say, but it makes them more “human.”

Take Selena Gomez and her line, Rare Beauty, which is built on messaging around struggles with mental health. As one of the most-followed celebrities on social, Selena could portray a very consumer-centric persona, checking all the boxes you think she would. But instead, her brand is about authenticity, honesty, and not being perfect. And that’s life.

So the next time you’re thinking about predicting trends, product launches, or social content, flashback to any Housewives reunion special you’ve watched. Remember that every fight, drama, and ridiculous event that happened that season might have become totally irrelevant, alliances might have changed, and it just might be possible that Lisa and Erika Jayne are friends with everyone again.

Maybe.


Lorne Lucree is Chief Innovation Officer at Voyant Beauty, the largest beauty contract manufacturer in North America.