When I talk to investors about the need for community broadband, they usually live in big cities like New York City, where their only experience is with large companies—Verizon, Comcast, or AT&T—and residents are 100% served. But the country is larger than those organizations can cover, and much of it is still unserved without access or underserved without competitive speeds.
The digital divide needs to be closed for society to grow, but without the high demand to ensure a return on investment, many smaller, less fortunate communities risk falling behind in a widening gap. The longer larger companies wait to prioritize these regions, the further isolated the people who live there may become from the rapidly digitizing future.
Who will take ownership to bring those communities across the digital divide? With community broadband, the residents themselves can take the initiative to carry their communities across the digital divide and give themselves a fighting chance to keep up.
WHO NEEDS COMMUNITY BROADBAND?
In the funding initiatives available today, I often hear people discuss “rural broadband,” but rural communities only tell half the story.
On the one hand, that talk is correct: Rural communities need speeds to match the rest of society and stay competitive, and bringing broadband to rural areas is often easier said than done. Deploying the infrastructure is expensive and sparse populations are less likely to get enough of a return on that investment for large companies to try. In 2021, over 30% of households in 287 of the country’s most rural counties had no high-speed internet access, and four of the five counties with the lowest broadband access were located in its most rural areas.
But solving rural broadband is only a part of closing the digital divide. Large companies providing services in urban communities often leave areas with higher rates of poverty or less access to digital communication underserved. With less of a guaranteed return on the investment, they may put off upgrading these communities to newer internet systems right away. Meanwhile, digital opportunities open new doors for more people in education, work, and health care, but people in underserved areas are falling behind.
This is why I believe “community broadband” is a better vernacular for this approach to closing the digital divide. Community broadband encompasses not only those in rural areas that need service but also people in poor neighborhoods in big cities. If you only look at “rural broadband,” the latter communities get left out.
MANY COMMUNITIES HAVE ALREADY PIONEERED THE WAY
A decade ago, the products on the market were designed for high-density deployments, but high-density doesn’t work for rural or community broadband. We at Clearfield saw this need and introduced a series of products and an entire architecture designed for lower population densities. We grew by upgrading our services to fiber as more revenue came in with subscribers over time. When COVID hit and widespread access to high-speed broadband became more urgent, fiber deployment accelerated. Over the last 18 months, our level of growth has skyrocketed as we enable these communities to continue to build faster. Like us, this is how the first pioneers in community broadband started.
Community broadband pioneers were already making major headway before COVID hit, but now roughly 1,000 small communities have taken charge of building out their networks. Companies like Paul Bunyan Telephone, Consolidated Communications, and Cincinnati Bell built their telecommunications services over decades, first with telephone and cable service and now the internet. The local telephone provider where I grew up has grown over 115 years to become a public company with fiber initiatives serving southern Minnesota.
Even big cities are banding together for their underserved communities. In February, Mesa, Arizona, opened up an invitation for service providers to install and operate an open-access fiber network connecting 264,000 city premises and 2,470 street miles with the fastest internet speeds. While 75% of Mesa residents had access to some landline broadband, a 2021 survey found that 17% of participants didn’t have internet at all, most citing affordability. Already, at least five partners have joined Mesa’s network, including AT&T, because the people of Mesa demanded it.
WHAT MIGHT COMMUNITY BROADBAND LOOK LIKE?
Depending on the needs of each community, community broadband will look different. Here are four ways community and business leaders can build out the best model:
1. Assess community needs. Get a clear picture of the services available, barriers to access or speeds, the devices people use most, and where they use them. With this understanding, broadband business leaders and entrepreneurs can create the best programs to address those community needs.
2. Upgrade rural electrical co-ops. Local electric cooperatives may already have the necessary resources, infrastructure, and personnel needed through their existing operations that can be modernized to incorporate fiber and bring high-speed broadband to community homes and businesses.
3. Look into partnerships. City-owned or investor-owned utilities may allow local providers to use their existing infrastructure as the middle-mile network: This connects main data routes to the last mile, bringing service to homes and businesses. Multiple towns or municipal entities might also partner to form regional utility districts, combining the populations of multiple regions and raising the aggregate demand.
4. Get local voices involved. Encourage community leaders to determine where to allocate money for buildouts, the rate and type of deployment, whether to take on a partner, or where it would be better to focus on affordability. Let each group of affected citizens give their input into making decisions that are best for their communities.
Bringing the country to the widespread broadband connectivity we envision will take time—maybe seven to 10 years. But even as these pioneers continue to build their networks, they can also serve as guidance in new spaces where communities are looking to start their initiatives. We have $65 billion to spend on broadband: Community leaders can use it to take ownership of bringing themselves across the digital divide sooner and ensure they get there on time.
Cheri Beranek is the President and CEO of Clearfield, providing optical-fiber management and connectivity solutions across North America.