Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What local papers got right: Five lessons that can improve digital news—and your leadership

Here are five lessons both executives and everyday citizens can take from local newspapers.

Newspaper

[Images: Zerbor/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Kerstin Recker Alexandre

Americans who grew up in earlier generations grew up with local newspapers. Many remember the paper landing on their doorstep every morning. They also remember their parents reading the paper before they headed to work or when they returned in the evenings. If you read your local newspaper, you could keep up with your community. This practice led to better-informed voters, more engaged communities, and ultimately more human connections.

The way we share and consume news and information has changed wholesale since the days of local papers. The loss of local newspapers—an additional 360 papers closed during the pandemic—has been called a crisis for democracy. Instead of a newspaper landing on a stoop, more than half of Americans get their news on social media—at least sometimes, according to Pew Research Center.

Mis- and disinformation is rampant on social media, where it’s hard to know what is and isn’t reliable news. Despite this, people quickly share information and accelerate the “infodemic,” which has a major impact on individuals, communities, and human connections. 

While some local newspapers are still focused on upholding quality journalism, we must learn to work with technology and the changed news-gathering and -sharing methods. There are, however, many lessons we can learn from local newspapers to help us steer technology and lead to better-informed citizens, less misinformation, and ultimately grounded civil participation.

These lessons are even more important if you are a business leader or executive. When you have a visible position, the decisions you make must be grounded with a well-rounded worldview and the understanding that what companies do directly affects communities and citizens, whether that is shuttering an office or holding a career fair. Historically, the best executives have been people who are well-read with a thirst for both news and the truth.

Here are five lessons both executives and everyday citizens can take from local newspapers.

1. A BUBBLE DOESN’T CREATE WELL-INFORMED CITIZENS 

The Internet allows people to create echo chambers. A local newspaper did the opposite: it offered numerous perspectives and voices.

Local papers looked at “the universe in your backyard” with stories like local planning zone developments, school board news, sports stories, and gardening columns. If you read a local paper daily, you learned about many things happening in your community.

If you consume a steady diet of digital news, you might know nothing about where you live. A bubble is even more dangerous for business executives who need to have a full picture—the good and bad—before they make a move. You can set up your feed to see nothing beyond celebrity news or political opinions from a certain perspective.

Search is part of this problem. A handful of big tech companies have a stronghold on search and incredible control of what stories we see when we enter a search; they can even spread misinformation.

Let’s broaden the news people receive. Fixing search is one part of this. The better the search functions, the more citizens will be able to receive quality, unbiased information first. 

2. ANONYMITY DOESN’T BUILD COMMUNITY 

Trolls are rampant on the Internet, particularly in comment sections for stories about hot-button issues. Many people enter conversations just to derail them.

In the days of local newspapers, letters to the editor needed to be vetted and verified with phone calls. You couldn’t enter the court of public opinion without ownership and accountability. Digital and media companies must find ways to make it harder for trolls to derail stories. Some sites require verified accounts or links to active social media profiles to contribute. We can’t build an informed community without accountability. 

3. WHAT HAPPENS IN THE BACKYARD MATTERS 

One of the amazing things about the Internet is how it connects us to the world. The downside is that many digital companies have surrendered their commitment to the community.

Plenty of community news is now shared via Facebook pages and group chats, but is often unreliable. Ultimately, there needs to be some sort of commitment to communities. 

Business leaders also need to know their communities and concerns intimately—and do what they can to help communities through means like event sponsorships, internships for students, and more.

4. INSIGHT INTO GOVERNMENT IS CRUCIAL

Many Americans don’t know how their government works or what’s in the Constitution. This ultimately leads to disconnection and even an embrace of conspiracy theories.

Local newspapers showcased how each voter mattered in a community and chronicled the steps needed for change in a community, whether it was opening a new school or approving a building project. Having insight into how our system works is empowering because it lets people know their voice matters and that they are not faceless automatons with no say over the political process. This also helps voters and citizens hold their local leaders accountable.

Understanding the legislative process is paramount if you lead a company as laws govern everything from permits for new buildings to how you treat employees. 

5. BEING WELL-ROUNDED PAYS OFF

The current model of digital newsgathering and search does not foster personal or intellectual growth.

A newspaper would always give readers stories from outside their comfort zone or interests. This piqued curiosity and ultimately led to a community of lifelong learners. While it’s good to be able to explore passions or interests in detail via groups, podcasts, and niche websites, we should also provide people with the tools to develop new passions or interests.

A well-rounded executive with a strong grasp of the news and what matters makes better, more informed choices for their company and community. 

The march of digital news will not stop. However, as we work to get the most out of the incredible potential of digital tools, we should remember a few lessons from their news-gathering forebears. The more we can design and guide these tools so they not only help us connect globally but act locally, the more we’ll create thriving and well-informed communities.  


Chief Strategy Officer at Seekr