Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What made strategy consulting valuable now makes it obsolete

Consultancies continue to focus on modernizing the wrong things.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Julian Mancia

Founding Partner · Agency

As the AI craze captivated the business world, many predicted doom for strategy consulting. But while many of today’s critiques rightly point to the pressures AI poses to strategy consulting’s business model, few are digging into why its core value is threatened. If they did, they would see that client strategy needs changed long ago, and the industry has not evolved to meet them.

The biggest strategic challenge facing clients is delivering results today while, simultaneously, adapting for tomorrow. Traditional strategy extrapolated from the past; today’s must anticipate the future to keep pace with change. Traditional strategy assumed stable business conventions; today’s must consider new models enabled by new technologies. And while strategy always required evidence to survive the scrutiny of leadership and boards, today’s must defend unprecedented approaches for a less predictable environment.

Even though foresight, criticality, and experimentation have been long understood, businesses are still challenged—culturally and structurally—in developing transformational strategies. Misaligned incentives, organizational silos, pressure to utilize established infrastructure, and general conservatism to protect a scaled core business keep leaders trapped in “tyrannies of today.” However, external partners aren’t under these constraints, positioning them to provide strategic value their clients require.

Yet, they are failing to deliver.

THE FAILURE OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTING

In The World’s Newest Profession, Christopher McKenna chronicles the history of management consulting. McKenna describes management consultants’ core value as providing “economies of knowledge,” or in a word, expertise. While their brokered knowledge changed over time, management consultancies still stress expertise, touting industry and functional specialization and utilizing case studies as proof points. For this reason, new waves of information democratization—whether the “big data” push of the 2010s or the AI craze of today—stir up discussions of consulting’s decline.

But clients needing help developing a strategy in today’s environment don’t need knowledge brokering. Today’s strategies require understanding the future, not the past. They require the critical thinking to break orthodoxies, not adhere to them. And they require constant experimentation to learn in the latest version of the world, not rely on expertise formed under previous circumstances.

Businesses grappling with AI are the perfect example. Last year, a newly hired executive from a major media conglomerate approached my consultancy’s strategy division. With a fresh perspective, he realized the company was using AI to modernize within the current business structure—limiting the technology’s potential to drive transformation. When presented with this challenge, our traditional strategists pitched deep media expertise and proposed using a new AI tool developed to evaluate the business against the traditional media value chain. Privately, the executive expressed his disappointment to me. The proposed solution relied on people and tools steeped in the very media orthodoxies he needed help breaking. 

For traditional strategy consultancies, changing a century-old value proposition won’t be easy. McKenna explains that since its inception in the 1930s, the industry worked to legitimize itself by adopting measures taken by professions of perceived authority. They created professional organizations, hired from elite universities, employed a ruthless “up or out” system of career progression, and even discouraged individuality of appearance in favor of collective professional conformity. These measures formed an extremely homogeneous cultural backbone for the profession—one that exists to this day.

Today’s strategy requires a culture that encourages individuals to depart from the norm and challenge long-held industry beliefs, and a structure enabling consultants to understand the broader picture to make disparate connections while experimenting with new ideas at speed. With a legacy of conformity, embedded hierarchies, organizing by specialization, and structural blockers to doing things in new ways, strategy consultancies have not evolved.

Creative agencies should be well positioned to lead where traditional strategy consultancies have failed. Creative agencies have, in fact, gained significant ground in helping clients with strategic questions once posed only to strategy consultancies. Evidence of this includes the growth of “innovation consulting” firms in recent decades, and the subsequent acquisition of these firms by strategy consultancies themselves throughout the 2010s.

However, creative agencies have their own struggles in delivering today’s strategy. They can lack criticality if they blindly follow their design process steps, needlessly ideate, or break things simply for the purpose of breaking things. The ambiguity of creativity can, in part, explain the inconsistency across creative agencies in delivering clients’ current strategic needs. Agencies leaning too heavily on a vague notion of creativity may not understand why some aspects are valuable for developing strategy, therefore failing to apply it correctly to client needs. These agencies often facilitate what is negatively described as “innovation theater,” or creativity for creativity’s sake.

A NEW VALUE FOR STRATEGY CONSULTING

While AI has forced an overdue reexamination of strategy consulting, my fear is that most are missing the point. Instead of reevaluating their offer for what clients need, they focus on “AI-ifying” what already exists: faster deck building; automated searches of proprietary knowledge bases; productizing processes for as-a-service offerings; and moving from pyramid-shaped teams to obelisk-shaped teams. These actions are warranted only if you assume a century-old value proposition—one actively challenged by democratizing specialist knowledge—should stay the same.

So then, what should strategy consulting’s new value proposition be?

Ironically, large consultancies have the same problems their clients have. Pursuing the relatively massive revenue opportunities afforded by economies of knowledge—in areas where it is admittedly still valuable, such as technology implementations—is more attractive than transforming themselves to excel in the smaller strategy market. But as clients continue to take issue with strategy work that is not visionary enough from traditional consultancies, or applied enough from creative agencies, new propositions will emerge to fill the gap.

Naturally, I have my hunches around these new propositions—but that’s a longer conversation.

Julian Mancia is an independent strategic advisor and former managing director and futures practice lead at ?What If! Innovation, part of Accenture.