Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What most leaders get wrong about executive presence

If you’re struggling with mastering a cookie-cutter approach to executive presence, don’t worry. You’re not the problem. The models are.

Man thinking

[Images: Reese/peopleimages.com/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of David Wright

Right now, in every corner of the country, leaders are being coached on how to present themselves. They’re attending workshops, combing through books and podcasts, or engaging in corporate learning programs to improve their ability to command a room, often at the encouragement of a manager. 

These programs are well-intentioned—aimed at helping high-achieving professionals hone their nascent leadership skills to better inspire confidence from their teams. 

But these endeavors may be for naught if they fail to uncover what actually makes someone uniquely influential. Sadly, the majority of the programs out there do. 

Here’s what most leaders get wrong about executive presence:

1. AUTHENTICITY

Early in my career, I had a gig where I managed the backend data for a large, global organization. I have always been obsessed with data, so I loved this job; but I also aspired to take on a larger role at the company and make a bigger impact. 

The position I had my eyes on was a role in which I’d get to lead a customer-facing product portfolio. Despite already leading a high-functioning team, one piece of feedback I’d constantly get as I advocated for the new role was that I needed to work on my executive presence.

So I did. I read through dozens of resources and spent hours trying to learn from “the best.” But, no matter how much I worked at it, I never seemed to be as good as the models my managers held up. 

That’s when I had an epiphany: Most concepts of executive presence are based on a few highly prescriptive and tired leadership models. But earning the respect of a team isn’t about a specific kind of posture or tone of voice. It’s all about being the best version of your authentic self.

So, when we started Pattern, I decided that I would do just that. I’d be myself. And, to my surprise, that’s worked out better than the younger me could have imagined. 

Bottom line: If you’re struggling with mastering a cookie-cutter approach to executive presence, don’t worry. You’re not the problem. The models are.

2. SUBSTANCE OVER STYLE

Credibility is often listed as a key component of executive presence. In my experience, this is 100% true—but not for the reasons outlined by the experts.

Many executive coaches will tell you that credibility is established through highly specific methods by which you communicate messages to others. This, however, misses the mark, especially in the modern work environment. Credibility is bestowed when true substance meets authenticity, and it starts by developing an undeniable understanding of who you are.

Do you tend to be understated with a quiet confidence that keeps everyone in a room grounded? Does your natural energy organically light up a team? Are you someone with incredible wit and a knack for timing that helps people feel at ease? Or, do you tend to be a bit quirky with a unique way of connecting dots that inspires a team to think deeply? 

Though some might tell you otherwise, all of these personality traits can lend themselves to powerful leadership styles—ones that can win over a team and drive them to achieve, but only if you are able to recognize those traits in yourself.

Ask yourself: What makes you unique, and are you letting that shine through in your leadership style?

3. JUST BE YOURSELF

In the early days of Pattern, I’d often go with one of our sales team members (I’ll call him Ron to protect the innocent) to meet with potential clients. 

Ron was absolutely incredible in those meetings. Within minutes, potential clients were shocked to find that Ron knew their needs better than anyone they had ever met and that he was not someone who would push them into a deal. He genuinely only cared about the success of their business, and they could tell. Often instantly.

It was such a winning combination that I tried to mimic his approach … and failed miserably. Why? Because I was trying to be Ron. But only Ron could be Ron. 

If I was going to be an asset in those meetings, I had to be me: a nerd with a deep understanding of how to use data to help brands accelerate their sales. Once I remembered that, things became a breeze. I was way more at ease in meetings because I was just being myself. What’s more, potential clients could tell that I was working from my area of strength, and that made the combination of me and Ron a force to be reckoned with.

STOP COACHING PEOPLE ON “THE HOW”

There seems to be no shortage of experts eager to coach you on your leadership journey. While many have a lot to offer, don’t lose sight of the fact that you are often the only one who can uncover the authentic part of yourself that will help you develop an incredible executive presence. 

Rather than picking up a book or starting a program, do some self-discovery. Start paying attention to the unique parts of you that help your team succeed. If needed, enlist the help of a trusted colleague who can help serve as your mirror. Soon, you’ll discover the aspects of your style that inspire confidence in others, and that will be the start of developing a true executive presence.


David Wright is co-founder and CEO of global ecommerce accelerator Pattern.