We’ve all experienced what I call “responsive non-communication.” It happens when we attempt to communicate with someone or with a business and receive a prompt response that offers no new information and, worse yet, fails to respond to our questions or offer any solutions to our problems.
Consider the following scenario: For nearly a year, I’ve been attempting to track a product I ordered that has yet to arrive. Every time I reach out to the company, I receive an immediate response. This company scores a perfect 10 in responsiveness. Based on the messages I’ve received, I also suspect a human, not a bot, is responding. The problem is that despite employing a team of human customer service representatives, the company’s response to my queries failed to answer a single question or do anything to ease my frustrations. These messages are a classic example of responsive non-communication—a prompt response that likely does more to exasperate than resolve an existing problem.
Many leaders don’t appreciate that while responsive non-communication may help ensure a fast response time so as to alleviate lingering customer or client complaints, they are still sending a negative message that reveals a great deal about a business’s workplace culture and leadership.
WHAT YOUR BUSINESS’S RESPONSIVE NON-COMMUNICATION MIGHT BE SAYING
Responding to messages in a prompt matter is important. However, if the message says nothing, over time it may be doing more damage to your brand than not responding at all. The reason is simple: responsive non-communication is a symptom of other, more pervasive organizational problems.
Disempowered Staff
Responsive non-communication is nearly always a sign that an organization’s frontline employees have little or no ability to make decisions or solve problems. Put simply, it points to a workforce suffering from a lack of ownership and low self-efficacy.
Poor Workplace Culture
Where there is a disempowered workforce, there is nearly always a poor workplace culture. With little or no authorization to solve problems or show their value on the job, employees have little impetus to be fully engaged at work. Over time, one’s workplace culture invariably suffers.
Bad Leadership
Poor workplace culture almost always points to a leadership deficit. Great leaders care about their workplace culture because culture drives creativity, innovation, productivity, and impact. Leaders who neglect their workplace culture are nearly always failing to cultivate the very values that will help their businesses grow.
THE UNDERLYING PROBLEM
Patrick Lencioni’s 2007 book, Three Signs of a Miserable Job, outlines the three core factors that underpin workplace dissatisfaction: anonymity, irrelevance, and a lack of measurement. He argues that people struggle to feel fulfilled at work unless they feel (1) that who they are matters (e.g., known by their managers), (2) that the work they are engaged in is meaningful to the company’s mission, and (3) that they can see (i.e., able to measure) their progress or impact.
When you receive responsive non-communication, there’s a strong likelihood that you’re likely engaging with someone in a miserable job. After all, when people are known, engaged in their work, and able and encouraged to measure their impact, they rarely send messages just to check off a box indicating that they have responded.
Leaders often have little or no line of sight on how frontline employees interact with customers or clients online, on the phone, or sometimes on the store floor. This points to the need for a company value that promotes communication and accountability. Leaders need to know that when their employees are responsive yet unhelpful, they may be saying little and still convey a great deal about a company’s internal problems.
The best step a leader can take to alleviate responsive non-communication is to put themselves into the shoes of a customer and client. This way, they can understand the messages and solutions that need to be communicated when a customer engages with frontline staff, and that staff member can be empowered to tackle the problem and find a satisfactory solution.
Dr. Camille Preston is a business psychologist, leadership expert, and the founder and CEO of AIM Leadership.