Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What the success of influencer marketing tells us about modern consumers

There’s a lot of talk about how advertising influences consumers, but it’s more interesting to consider how consumers influence advertising.

Young woman on her phone

[Images: insta_photos/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Dave Dickman

BY Dave Dickman

When I started my career, broadcast television was the gold standard of advertising. Then came the internet, social media, and mobile advertising. Now, we have influencer marketing.

The channels may have differed, but the pattern has always been the same. A new technology is introduced. Audiences flock to it. Businesses quickly follow suit for fear of being left behind, and marketing is left to figure out best practices and prove it is worth the investment.

It’s normal to see some resistance in a channel’s early days. No one wants to be the company that overinvests and goes belly-up because of it. Influencer marketing was no different. Yes, the channel had challenges gaining momentum, and its sheer size and scope of data make for complicated media execution. But we’ve hit the point in channel maturity where the management tools exist, and success has been demonstrated ten times over—and yet, there is some tentativeness over channel legitimacy.

So instead of adding to the plethora of Google results that tell you what influencer marketing can do for your ROI, I’d like to share what it does for consumers.

WHAT YOUR FAVORITE MARKETING CHANNEL SAYS ABOUT YOU

There’s a lot of talk about how advertising influences consumers, but it’s more interesting to consider things from the opposite perspective: how consumers influence advertising. To the seasoned marketer, adopting a new channel can provide a lot of insight into what consumers are looking for and how their expectations will evolve.

Just look at the communication milestones of the past century:

  • Radio introduced the concept of real-time news and entertainment. People could hear about what was happening then instead of days later.
  • Television brought pictures and sound together for immersive storytelling. Hearing about something wasn’t enough—now audiences wanted to see it too.
  • The internet shifted the balance of power into the hands of the consumer by giving them unfettered access to information. Consumers wanted value beyond a product or service—they wanted expertise and knowledge.
  • Social media and Web0 brought in elements of interaction and participation. Now people could interact with the brands they loved, and wanted to be seen and heard in response.

SO, WHAT DOES INFLUENCER MARKETING REVEAL ABOUT CONSUMERS?

Let’s take a closer look at the influencer space to find out.

It exists within social media, so we know that content is personalized to users’ tastes. This signals that the algorithm has identified a high probability of interest in any content it shows.

For the most part, influencers themselves act like ordinary people. Content is relatable and lacks the hyper-polished, unobtainable look of commercials and celebrity accounts, with creators often sharing their personal experiences and discussing their passions. Within the content itself, there is little to no branding or advertising. Sponsored content is interspersed between lots of organic posts.

Together, these elements create a user experience that is personalized, relatable, and largely free of outside influence, indicating that there is a strong consumer preference for trust and authenticity.

PEOPLE TRUST PEOPLE, NOT BRANDS

According to research from Gallup, consumer trust has sharply declined since 2018. It’s no secret that businesses were always incentivized to sell, but the rise of the internet and social media increased transparency and access to unbiased sources.

A common dissent from those who are anti-influencer marketing is that influencers are only driven by money, making them less reliable marketing partners. Every bunch has bad apples, but this view expresses a fundamental misunderstanding of how the influencer/follower dynamic works.

Without followers, influencers cannot make money. Therefore, followers are an influencer’s primary concern. The only way to attract and maintain followers is by posting your content. Through this exchange, influencers develop relationships with followers outside selling. When a follower does see a sponsored post, they are still willing to extend their trust to the influencer because of the existing relationship and the inherent knowledge that influencers need their numbers to keep their business operating.

THE CHALLENGES OF INFLUENCER MARKETING

Just because we are at a turning point in influencer marketing doesn’t mean it’s become easier. There are significant challenges to the channel, but they are different than you might believe. 

First, you can’t measure influencer campaigns because there isn’t enough data. The opposite is true here. As a digital medium, influencer marketing produces a ton of data. Defining the right data for an accurate impact makes it difficult to measure. Influencer marketing can be flexible and pursue many objectives, but you must know what data matters the most when starting a campaign.

Fortunately, as influencer marketing has grown, the industry has outgrown traditional “one-KPI-to-measure-success” thinking. What you’re trying to accomplish defines what you should measure. 

The measurement and flexibility of influencer marketing is a step away from the traditional marketing processes of set KPIs and targeting. It requires companies to think outside the box, take different perspectives, and do things differently. And different can be scary.

HOW TO GET STARTED

The influencer space is unique and full of new opportunities for businesses looking to engage with audiences, but marketers should keep in mind that it functions differently than traditional channels. Success is found through weaving messaging and branding into authentic content. 

You should partner with influencers whose audience and persona mesh with yours. Just because an influencer is popular with your demographic doesn’t mean they fit your brand. Think of it like match-making; the audience has to feel your chemistry or else they won’t buy into your partnership. 

Don’t stop at audience demographics; dig deeper to find out why audiences like an influencer. Is it their style or personality? Do they have in-depth knowledge of a particular subject? Look at their content with the highest engagement for reoccurring themes. Browse through comments to see how they interact with their followers.

And finally, find the right tools. You can learn a lot through casual research, but you need data to validate your findings. Look for solutions that provide insights not only at the profile level, but at the industry level as well.


Dave Dickman is the CEO of Tagger Media.