Servant leadership is all about making a positive impact. When I read about “toxic workplaces” and “toxic leadership,” I ask myself how we can turn the narrative around. How can we shift from the negative to the positive?
If something negative exists, so can its positive counterpart. We must “flip” the paradigm to benefit workers, the company culture, and the customer.
TOXIC WORKPLACES ARE NOT A MODERN-DAY PHENOMENON
Dysfunctional working environments are nothing new. If you look back in U.S. history, autocratic leadership could be considered the norm. In my dad’s day, the boss’s word was final—you either performed or were looking for another job. Of course, not all companies had a toxic culture in those days, but inflexible hierarchies, difficult working conditions, and harassment were often swept under the carpet in pursuit of the American dollar.
Perspectives on History editor Allison Miller published an interesting article about the back story of toxic work environments. She claims the word originated in reference to actual toxins in the working environment, such as exposure to hazardous chemicals in factories and laboratories. She believes the term’s original meaning was closely related to gender, specifically the exposure of pregnant women to toxins in the workplace.
THE ROLE OF THE MEDIA AND SOCIAL MEDIA
We are now in a different time from when researchers and writers began to shed light on toxic workplaces—although many of the issues still existing today are indeed connected to gender (harassment), excessive work, and exclusion.
The modern interpretation of the toxic workplace comes with different perspectives. The media has also taken the term and run with it, which is good because it’s essential to shed light on corporates and organizations where workers are being abused. However, it’s not a good thing when the term becomes “trendy.” In my view, that’s when an important term loses meaning and therefore potency to empower change.
WHAT IS A TOXIC WORKPLACE?
There are a few definitions for the modern-day “toxic workplace,” but I quite like how Jennifer Liu laid out the five biggest signs of a toxic workplace in her CNBC article earlier this year:
- non-inclusive
- lack of respect
- lack of ethics
- cutthroat behavior
- abusive management.
These top five points are an excellent place to start when examining whether your company may have the traits of a toxic workplace. Once you identify areas where you are falling short, it’s time to get everyone on board to tackle the problems and turn the company culture around into a positive one where everyone can thrive.
It’s also imperative to ensure that you create safe spaces for staff to talk about issues affecting them directly. HR departments need to be highly skilled to ensure that workers are heard and that every opinion is valuable.
THE NEW PARADIGM
Tackling the issues that create a toxic workplace is an urgent matter and should be given priority by the leadership team and across all departments.
In a recent article in the Wall Street Journal titled “Toxic Workplaces Are Bad For Physical And Mental Health,” U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy says, “People are asking themselves what they want from work. They’re also asking themselves what they’re willing to sacrifice for work, and the fundamental questions are reshaping people’s relationships with the workplace.”
The Surgeon General’s Framework for Workplace Mental Health and Well-Being lays out the essential factors to support workers centered around workers’ voices and equity. This is an excellent guideline for creating a new framework for any business that wants to ensure a positive workplace.
WHAT TO DO ABOUT TOXIC LEADERSHIP?
How many of us in positions of power are toxic leaders? If I look back on my leadership style over the years, there has certainly been a place for improvement. I would often be the boss who spoke over everyone at meetings. As a result, I didn’t always hear what my team was trying to say. I also set a bad example for my teams by overworking for many years—18 hours a day was the norm, followed by socializing and “networking” until all hours. I am very grateful that two hip operations and a lot of time in the hospital allowed me to look at my mistakes and redefine the kind of leader I wanted to be.
DEALING WITH THE TOXIC MANAGER
Do you have any toxic leaders as part of your management teams? People love power, and sometimes behavior toward subordinates can be problematic.
This is quite hard to identify, so it’s essential to have open communication channels. That way, if a leader or manager is out of line, this information is communicated along the proper channels. What might play out at management meetings with the boss could be different from the day-to-day running of the business. While it’s key to trust your leadership team, it’s also important to know how they treat others. Are they good servant leaders?
You must address the issues firmly and clearly if the answer is no. If someone is toxic, your HR department and senior management may need to make some critical choices.
CREATE A COLLABORATIVE VISION
It’s not a case of size when creating a positive, empowered company culture. Let everyone have a voice and input. Get everyone into a room and map the way forward together. It will be an empowering exercise for your workers to be involved in creating the vision for your organization. Make sure the checks and balances are all in place for the future. It’s easy to get carried away with what a good workplace feels and looks like, but check in with your teams frequently to ensure you’re on the right track to keeping an authentic yet positive workplace where people want to come and spend their time productive and contributing.
Gary C. Cooper is the Chairman of Palmetto Infusion | CEO & Founder of The Carolus Company | Investing in human and business potential.