Most small business owners didn’t sign up to be cybersecurity experts. Yet that’s exactly what the current threat landscape demands, and the gap between what attackers can do and what SMBs have in place to stop them has never been wider.
Artificial intelligence is widening that gap from both sides. AI shopping agents from Google, Microsoft, and others now guide customers from product discovery through checkout in a single conversation, so transactions increasingly reach an SMB’s payment system without the customer ever visiting the business’s website. At the same time, those same AI capabilities are giving attackers faster, more adaptive tools to target the payment infrastructure on which those businesses depend.
For SMB owners, this is the new reality: The systems that power everyday commerce are becoming more powerful and more exposed.
Operational risk for SMBs once centered on inventory and staffing. Now, cybersecurity concerns have overtaken economic pressures as the top operational threat facing SMBs. Unlike inflation or workforce shortages that gradually chip away at a business, cyber incidents strike suddenly.
A single attack can halt payment processing overnight, and the consequences can be severe. According to our research, 40% of SMB owners say a cyberattack causing $100,000 in losses (or less) could force them out of business.
For SMBs, payment security is no longer an IT concern. It’s a business survival issue.
The payment path changed
During the 2025 holiday season, traffic to retail sites from AI-powered sources increased nearly 700% compared to the previous year. That number reflects a fundamental restructuring of how customers discover, evaluate, and purchase products, with direct implications for the management of payment risk.
A customer now often begins their checkout process via AI search engines, large language models (LLMs), or AI shopping assistants. The path is longer, more distributed, and harder to monitor. Each additional handoff between discovery and payment provides an opportunity for something to go wrong.
That risk is already materializing. In the past year, our research found that 40% of SMBs experienced fraudulent card activity, and 42% say AI-powered attack speeds make it difficult to keep up. Each fraudulent charge triggers investigations and operational strain for businesses lacking the dedicated resources to absorb either.
New payment systems bring new risks
The payment experience itself is changing. Traditional credit card numbers are gradually being replaced by newer forms of verification, tap-to-pay systems like Apple Pay, QR code checkout at restaurants, and tokenized credentials passed through AI shopping agents. These convenient technologies introduce new layers of complexity into an already layered system.
SMBs are beginning to recognize the security implications, with 40% of those we surveyed saying that removing the traditional 16-digit primary account number (PAN) from credit and debit cards significantly affects the security of their business transactions.
That concern is well-founded. Accepting tap-to-pay or QR code checkout means connecting new software to existing point-of-sale systems, payment processors, and third-party providers, each connection adding another dependency, another potential point of failure.
The data reflects this operational fragility, with about half of SMBs reporting point-of-sale downtime, and 55% affected by outages at third-party service providers that support their payment systems. Complexity is a vulnerability, and right now, SMBs are inheriting more of it with every new payment method they accept.
Security must follow business risk
For SMBs, security doesn’t happen in a dedicated security operations center. It happens from opening the store to managing staff, handling customer issues, and closing out the day’s transactions. Around 8 out of 10 SMB business owners say they self-manage their cybersecurity. It’s the reality of lean operations.
So the traditional model of security—static controls, compliance checklists and reacting to alerts—simply doesn’t work for this segment. SMBs need security that’s built around how they actually operate.
The foundation of risk-directed security prioritizes defenses based on real-world business risk. Rather than treating every alert equally, risk-directed security uses AI and human expertise to continuously assess where new payment technology creates the greatest threat, focusing limited time, budget, and response on the areas that matter most.
3 steps for better SMB security
1. Cybersecurity cannot remain a solo responsibility
Cyber risk has outpaced even the most diligent SMB owners’ capacity. Shared accountability, supported by external expertise and 24/7 coverage from managed security service providers (MSSPs), reduces burnout and improves consistency in maintaining payment systems.
2. Limited resources must be directed at what matters most
Not every alert carries the same risk. Continuous, asset-level risk scoring helps SMBs prioritize the exposures most likely to disrupt their ability to collect customer payments, ensuring limited budgets are spent where they have the highest impact.
3. AI must be part of the defense
Static rules and manual responses cannot keep pace with modern attacks. AI helps surface meaningful patterns and attack paths early, enabling faster, more confident human-led responses before damage occurs.
The businesses that will thrive in this environment are those that adopt new payment technology with the right defenses in place. AI is reshaping commerce on Main Street. The question is whether SMBs are reshaping their defenses to match.
Mark Brady is CEO at VikingCloud.