In March of 2020, I thought my real estate startup was finished. Stay-at-home orders during the COVID-19 outbreak meant no one could tour houses. No home sales meant no real estate agents buying our services. We were staring at a cliff, and I had no idea how we were going to survive.
We had two options: We could do layoffs and cut deep enough to preserve cash until things recovered, or we could try something different.
We chose salary cuts across the entire company. Unlike most organizations, we didn’t do equally distributed cuts where everyone takes the same percentage hit. Instead, we implemented more strategically structured cuts, with those who earned the most taking the largest reductions. Looking back, that decision defined our culture more than I could have known.
Our salary reduction structure
We deliberately chose not to do across-the-board percentage cuts. Flat-rate cuts aren’t really fair when you consider the realities of employee financial situations. Equal percentage cuts across the board would’ve been devastating for our lowest-paid employees and barely noticeable for executives.
Someone making $50,000 a year can’t absorb a 20% pay cut the same way someone making $200,000 can. Taking $10,000 from someone barely covering rent and groceries is fundamentally different from taking $40,000 from an executive with significant savings.
So, we structured it based on the ability to handle the impact:
- Under $60,000 annual salary: No pay cuts
- Between $60,000 and $100,000 annual salary: 10% pay cut
- Between $100,000 and $150,000: 20% pay cut
- Executives making $150,000 and up: 35% cut
The decision-makers—my leadership team and I—took the biggest hit. We weren’t comfortable asking people to sacrifice while we stayed comfortable. To ask the company to share the pain, we needed to take on the most pain ourselves.
Why we didn’t do layoffs
Truthfully, the standard layoffs would have been cleaner and faster. During a crisis, cutting headcount preserves cash and rides out the storm.
We seriously considered it. The math was straightforward, and our investors would have understood, but something about it felt wrong for what we were trying to build. We’d spent years building a team, hiring people who believed in what we were doing and had taken a bet on joining a startup. Cutting those people during a global crisis, when they had limited options for finding new work, didn’t sit right.
More importantly, we didn’t know how long the COVID-19 outbreak would last or what the recovery would look like. If we laid people off and then needed to rehire quickly when things bounced back, we’d be starting from scratch with new people who didn’t know the business. We’d lose all the institutional knowledge and momentum we’d built.
Salary cuts let us keep the team intact. Everyone who knew the business stayed, and when things recovered, we could move fast without needing to rebuild.
How the team responded
Of course, I was nervous about how people would react. A pay cut is a pay cut, and nobody likes taking one. Thankfully, the response surprised me, and the whole company rallied around our choice.
People could see leadership wasn’t asking them to do something we weren’t willing to do ourselves. The executives took the biggest cuts. We were all in it together, and the structure made it clear that we were trying to be fair based on who could handle cuts the best.
There was no resentment or sense that some people were being protected while others got hurt. People understood why we did it the way we did, and they trusted that we’d reverse it as soon as we could.
What happened next
The COVID-19 stay-home orders passed faster than we expected, at least for our business. Real estate went crazy as people moved during lockdowns and took advantage of low interest rates.
We reversed the cuts a few months later when it became clear we were going to be okay. And after our next funding round, we paid everyone back every dollar we’d cut.
People remembered that. They remembered that we took care of them during the hardest time, that leadership took the biggest hit, and that we made them whole when we said we would.
What we learned
Hard times have a way of showing what you actually stand for. You can put values on the wall and talk about culture in all-hands meetings, but when a crisis hits, your actions define who you are. We said we cared about our people. When it mattered most, we had to prove it. The salary cut structure was how we did that.
If you’re leading a company and you’re facing a similar decision, think carefully about what message you’re sending. Are you asking people to sacrifice while leadership stays comfortable? Or are you demonstrating that the people making the decisions are willing to take on the most pain?
Your team will remember which one you chose, and it will shape your culture for years to come.
Malte Kramer is the founder and CEO of Luxury Presence.