Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

When your company has ideas but lacks urgency

Go beyond efficiency to find something bigger.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Todd Thomas

CEO · Woodchuck

Most companies do not have an innovation problem. They have an execution problem.

Walk into almost any large organization, and you will find smart people with ideas about how to improve a product, streamline an operation, enter a new market, or solve a customer problem.

There are innovation teams, strategy meetings, pilots, and presentations devoted to what comes next. Yet surprisingly few of those ideas become meaningful businesses. The problem is not a shortage of creativity. It is that organizations have become remarkably good at starving innovation while believing they are supporting it.

Innovation is often treated as an event. Leaders announce an initiative, assemble a team, and expect something transformative to emerge on a predictable corporate timeline. Meaningful innovation rarely works that way.

History demonstrates how innovation usually comes from curiosity, experimentation, failure, iteration, and persistence. The light bulb, for example, was not the result of one brilliant moment. It emerged from decades of work by multiple inventors, followed by thousands of experiments to find a commercially practical solution.

That distinction matters for executives because companies often say they want innovation while building management systems designed to prevent the very conditions that produce it.

Efficiency and innovation are not the same thing

Large organizations are built to make existing businesses run efficiently. Leaders establish processes, budgets, reporting structures and performance measures because consistency matters at scale. Those systems are valuable until we assume they are equally effective at creating something new.

An established business can estimate demand, forecast expenses, and calculate margins using years of information. An emerging idea has very little of that certainty. Customers may not understand it yet, but the business model may change, and the technology may need several iterations before it works as expected.

Requiring an early-stage innovation to behave like a mature business can kill it before executives learn whether it has potential. This does not mean companies should abandon financial discipline. It means leaders should measure early innovation differently.

Instead of asking only how much revenue an idea generated this quarter, ask what the team learned, what assumptions were disproven, whether customers demonstrated real interest, and whether the economics are becoming clearer. Progress is not always revenue at the beginning. Sometimes progress is discovering quickly and inexpensively that your original idea was wrong.

Innovation needs urgency

Executives frequently underestimate another problem. A good idea is not necessarily an urgent idea. Companies encounter interesting technologies constantly, but unless adopting one solves a problem someone needs solved now, it can remain trapped indefinitely in demonstrations, pilots, and internal conversations.

That is especially true inside large organizations, where adopting something new can require changes across technology, procurement, operations, legal, marketing, and finance. A promising innovation must compete with dozens of existing priorities for attention and capital.

Executives evaluating innovation should therefore ask a harder question than, “Is this a good idea?” They should ask, “Why does this matter now?” If nobody can answer that clearly, the organization may be looking at an interesting technology rather than a compelling business opportunity.

The same test applies internally. If leadership says innovation is strategically important, but nobody has authority to move quickly, access capital or challenge existing processes, employees will understand the real message. Innovation is welcome as long as it does not inconvenience the existing organization.

Don’t demand the perfect breakthrough

Business culture has romanticized the breakthrough. We celebrate the entrepreneur who supposedly saw something nobody else could see and changed an industry overnight. That makes for a good story, but it is rarely how progress happens.

Some of the most valuable innovations are surprisingly simple. They combine existing technologies differently, remove friction from an inefficient process, or find value in something everyone else has overlooked. Innovation does not always require inventing a new technology. Sometimes it requires looking at familiar resources and asking a better question about how to use them.

Your next growth opportunity may already exist somewhere inside your company. It may be hiding in operational data nobody studies, a recurring customer complaint everyone accepts, an underused asset or an employee workaround that developed because the official process doesn’t work well. The executive challenge is creating an organization curious enough to notice those opportunities.

Follow the economics

There is one final test innovation leaders should apply relentlessly: Who benefits? A technically superior idea can still fail if adopting it requires too many stakeholders to lose money, authority or strategic advantage. Organizations do not operate in a vacuum. Customers, employees, suppliers, investors and industry partners all respond to incentives. Innovation moves faster when incentives align, especially when new technologies can work within existing systems while delivering clear economic benefits.

Executives should think about this earlier in the innovation process. Do not wait until a product is finished to determine whether customers have a financial reason to adopt it. Build the economics into the innovation itself.

That requires a different mindset about what innovation leadership actually means. It is less about generating ideas and more about creating the conditions in which promising ideas can survive long enough to prove themselves. Give teams room to experiment, measure learning as well as financial outcomes, identify the urgent problem, and understand who must benefit for adoption to happen.

Companies do not starve innovation because they lack intelligent people. They starve it when their systems make doing something new more difficult than continuing to do what they have always done. For executives, that may be the most important innovation question of all: Does your organization actually make it possible for a good idea to survive?

Todd Thomas is founder and CEO at Woodchuck.