Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why being emotional is a good thing as a manager

Instead of assuming that you’ll just never be able to understand the latent needs and insights of your team, think again.

Excited woman on her laptop

[Images: Katcha / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Duncan Wardle

Founder · iD8 & innov8

Artificial intelligence (AI) may be able to do many things, but one thing’s clear: You won’t find empathy in any AI tools. It might be able to recognize patterns and make predictions, but AI can’t reflect on subjective emotional responses. It can’t blend humanity into the mix. (This isn’t just my opinion; a peer who’s heading up Google’s DeepMind project agrees that empathy is the last human trait that can be programmed.)

However, to underscore the importance of empathy, let’s talk about one very special robot called WALL-E. During the opening scenes of the eponymously titled Pixar movie, WALL-E is watching a television show. He sees two people holding hands. Instantly, his eyes reveal how much he wants to feel that kind of love.

As audiences, we empathize. We get it. All of a sudden, our right and left brain sides merge. Intuition morphs with logical reasoning, and we move beyond thinking into a realm of feeling, creativity, imagination, and compassion. It’s a place where gut instinct aligns with facts. And it fosters a sense of real connectivity between us and the world at large.

This place is what managers should look to cultivate during working hours. Young professionals are seeking a unique occupational experience that transcends raw productivity rates and moves into purposeful, meaningful individual and group efforts.

This belies the bigger question: How do you get to the point where you can masterfully think past the given data and understand the nuances of human behavior based on intuition rather than just logical reasoning? I recommend you start by making some changes in the way you approach your dealings with direct reports.

1. BE A GARDENER INSTEAD OF A JUDGE

As noted in a thesis from the University of North Florida, Gen Z’s distinctive lived experiences have shaped the generational cohort’s desire for empathy. However, storytelling has to be a two-way street. You have to give stories as well as seek them out. You’ll find that spreadsheets and KPI reports have new meaning when you do that. You might even be able to give some great advice and become a worker’s best advocate and mentor.

Just as importantly, let your workers share with you. When someone comes at you with a new idea, practice empathetic ideation. Rather than shutting down the idea, listen and help nurture it. Doing so opens up a space for empathy and fosters a sense of unity. Usually, the idea will either be a weed or a seed. You won’t know which until you water it a bit and proceed with empathy for the creator.

2. TAKE THE EXTRA STEP TO GET THE FULL PICTURE

When you let others express themselves completely, you can uncover valuable insights about them. These insights can help you develop more empathy toward them. The process can get you nearer to the truth, too. When you’re a manager, you need to have the same desire to understand your employees as if they were customers (in a sense, they are). You can’t expect them to mold and conform, even if that’s what you did when you were starting out.

I experienced this phenomenon regularly at Disney. If we asked 5,000 people to fill out surveys about why they vacationed at Disney, most would say they liked the new attractions. Fair enough. We needed to invest in more rides, events, and sizzle, right? Not necessarily.

When we would bring smaller groups into a room and ask them the same question in a more intimate setting, we got far different answers. We listened intently as they explained that, no, it wasn’t really the new attractions. It was the feeling of nostalgia they got because Disney reminded them of fond, fun childhood memories. If we hadn’t listened, we would have blown millions of dollars on the answer that was easy to give in a survey but hard to truly express without human interaction.

3. BUILD CREATIVITY INTO CONNECTIONS

Best-selling author and social science journalist Daniel H. Pink explained the importance of empathy well: “Empathy is about standing in someone else’s shoes, feeling with his or her heart, seeing with his or her eyes. Not only is empathy hard to outsource and automate, but it makes the world a better place.” This isn’t a new idea, of course, but it’s one to remember.

Don’t worry: You don’t have to bunk up with each of your employees to empathize with their situations and immerse yourself in their world. But you should be willing to think outside the box to meet them where they are.

Once, I was asked to help a pharmaceutical company brainstorm as part of the development of a new arthritis medicine. Not one person in the brainstorming session had arthritis. Therefore, I asked them all to tape a penny to each knuckle on their fingers and go through their daily tasks. They couldn’t manage a zipper or use a pen. After the experiment, they felt a rush of empathy for people living with arthritis and were able to create a better product.

Instead of assuming you’ll just never be able to understand the latent needs and insights of your team, think again. You can tap into your native emotional intelligence more easily than you might assume. When you do, you can fuel connections that will help everyone on your team find more joy and purpose at work.


Duncan Wardle, former Head of Innovation & Creativity @ Disney. Founded iD8 & innov8 to help organizations embed a culture of innovation.