From world wars and the Gulf wars to 9/11 and the COVID-19 pandemic, people consume more news during crises. Aside from having compassion for the victims of so many upheavals, audiences want to know how world events will impact their lives. It has been no different during the Russia-Ukraine war and, more recently, during the war between Hamas and Israel.
The fear persists, however, that advertising alongside war-related content—or any content during a negative news cycle—associates the brand with that negative sentiment. But is this true?
To debunk the idea that consumers simplistically connect troubling news with adjacent advertising, simply consider how people sought reliable information from trusted news sources during the pandemic. Companies pulled back from advertising due to what Verizon Media called the “irrational” fear of appearing alongside COVID-related stories. However, its research found that 91% of consumers actually wanted to hear from brands they trusted, considering the level of uncertainty unfolding.
This points to brands reaching a bigger market during periods of peak news consumption—with a discerning approach. After a decade of diminishing news media advertising, there is no need to treat this topic as taboo. All of this can be achieved while maintaining brand safety.
MORE SELECTIVE BLOCKING
Not all news is equal. Some stories from war zones are too graphic or extreme to be advertised against—but this is only an argument to better categorize news so the right content can be blocked. It’s in the interests of publishers and advertisers to develop an alternative to the naive keyword-blocking, ad-targeting, and safe-listing tools to maintain brand safety during challenging news cycles.
Companies should reject the old assumption that bad news gets more attention but doesn’t sell. Consumers today are savvier than ever and do not directly associate a brand with the negative, difficult, or controversial content it’s advertised beside. According to the science of negativity bias, people are drawn to negative news more than positive as part of an evolutionary adaptation. Of course, we don’t want to cynically exploit this tendency; it’s an opportunity to balance out bad news with good advertising.
Verizon suggests emphasizing brand building and positive experiences rather than a direct selling approach or stopping advertising with news publishers altogether—as has happened during the Russia-Ukraine conflict. However, there is no rule book on advertising during a war. Brands should constantly reevaluate their messaging and strategy as news shifts to avoid being tone-deaf. In the meantime, we must be careful not to let caution override common sense.
THE SHORTCOMINGS OF BRAND SAFETY
Brand safety is a primary concern for advertisers, especially since many boycotted Google’s ad network six years ago. The revelation that Google and YouTube ads had been appearing alongside extremist content coincided with the explosion of misinformation around the 2016 US election campaign, prompting many advertisers to pull back. However, risk-averse brands may have gone too far.
The UK industry body, the Internet Advertising Bureau, analyzed advertising on both sides of the Atlantic and warned that overzealous keyword blocking, even years after tragic events, compromised brands’ reach and the efficacy of their ad spends. It also noted that this indiscriminate approach does not recognize that good journalism attracts an engaged audience because it reports controversial or difficult news factually.
Although elections represent a different challenge, advertisers have taken the same all-or-nothing approach in the past, blocking entire publications on grounds of political bias. One can argue this is hypocritical, as brands still want the readers of those same publications to buy their products.
The irony is that brands still allow social media platform algorithms to make those advertising decisions for them. There are potential solutions to these dilemmas, but they will require the right tools and a willingness to work together.
BETTER TOOLS FOR STRATEGIC BRAND POSITIONING
Keyword blocking, as it stands, is a blunt instrument that can defeat its own purpose. If brands block a keyword associated with a core topic, it can also block loosely related content elsewhere. It is also more likely to penalize text-heavy environments, such as quality news sites, and in doing so, direct ad budgets to unregulated sites. With the emergence of Chat GPT, however, the technology to build tools that will enable a more effective solution is already here.
This is where brands must drive demand. With a mechanism to better identify misaligned news through processing volumes of data instead of single keywords, brands would not need to block entire sites, news sections, or IAB categories. Equally, no company wants to advertise barbeque coals during a wildfire or place a sugary soda ad alongside an article about childhood obesity. Intelligent tools would be more accurate in how they exclude content.
Advertisers can further help themselves by being transparent with publishers about what’s guiding their advertising decisions. Developing strong relationships with trusted publishers would also allow advertisers to better tailor marketing to their target audiences. If brands and agencies work with publishers and not against them, we can collectively mitigate the risk of advertising during difficult news cycles and leverage the advantages of actually deepening—not losing—consumer trust.
ADVERTISING RESPONSIBLY
There is no need to hide from advertising during a war or a presidential election year, but it does require planning and consideration. Brands may find themselves in rare company—crafting the right message is harder than saying nothing at all.
The pandemic offers a relatively recent reference point, with research that surveyed 25,000 consumers in 30 markets in 2020 finding just 8% of consumers expected companies to cease advertising. However, the majority wanted advertisers to create ads that positively contributed to society, such as describing how the brand was helping during the “new normal” of everyday life and offering a reassuring tone.
With the likely advent of AI tools to help brands be more selective in how they advertise during events like wars, we will be better positioned than ever before to advertise responsibly and with greater impact. Those who take stock in these opportunities will have a strong share of voice and likely benefit from a healthy ROI.
Tom is the Co-Founder and CEO of EX.CO.