Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why businesses win or lose work before it begins

The client experience influences the sales process before a proposal is even sent.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Eric Schurke

CEO of North America · Moneypenny

Most businesses believe they win or lose a project or a client based on the quality of their work. In reality, that decision is often made much earlier.

It happens in the first interaction: the first call, the first message, the first moment someone reaches out. They form an impression of how your business operates, whether they do so consciously or not. Customers decide whether they trust you enough to move forward long before a proposal is signed or a service is delivered.

In many organizations, that moment is still treated as administrative; something to be processed, logged, or passed along, rather than something to be designed.

FIRST CONTACT IS WHERE TRUST BEGINS

Over the years, I’ve seen that the first contact is rarely neutral; it either builds confidence or introduces doubt.

A prompt, thoughtful response signals professionalism and care, while a slow or unclear one can quietly suggest the opposite. And even if customers may not always be able to articulate those impressions, they still instinctively act on them.

At Moneypenny, we often see this when clients first come to us, having experienced missed calls, delayed responses, or fragmented interactions that have cost them opportunities. This is not because the business lacked capability, but because the experience failed to reflect that capability at the moment it mattered most.

That’s why first contact should not be thought of as a task, but as a strategic touchpoint, one that shapes everything that follows.

THE HIDDEN COST OF INCONSISTENCY

One of the biggest challenges companies have is inconsistency. Inquiries come in through multiple channels, information is captured in different ways, and ownership isn’t always clear, so what should feel seamless can quickly become disjointed.  From the outside, that can create a disconnected experience, and internally, it can lead to inefficiency and missed opportunities.

The most effective organizations bring structure to this moment. They define what information needs to be captured, how it’s recorded, and how it moves through the business. But importantly, they do so without losing the human element.

The structure creates clarity. The people create connection. And you need both to be successful.

SPEED MATTERS (BUT SO DOES HOW YOU RESPOND)

There’s often a strong focus on responding faster. And that’s important; customers today expect responsiveness, and rightly so. But speed on its own isn’t enough.

A rushed response that misses context can be just as damaging as a slow one. Equally, overly scripted or automated replies can feel impersonal, particularly when someone is dealing with something complex or time-sensitive.

What matters is balance. In practice, that means using technology to ensure speed and consistency, while giving people the space to apply judgment, ask the right questions, and build rapport. When that balance is right, the experience feels effortless, and that’s when trust starts to build.

SMALL MOMENTS THAT SHAPE BIG DECISIONS

What’s often overlooked is just how much these early interactions influence everything that follows.

When information is captured clearly at the start, teams can respond more effectively. When customers feel understood early on, they’re more likely to engage and stay engaged. When expectations are set properly, relationships tend to be stronger and more productive.

We’ve seen firsthand how small improvements at this stage can significantly impact conversion rates, pipeline quality, and long-term relationships. And the reverse is just as true; small gaps early on tend to compound over time.

LEADERSHIP STARTS EARLIER THAN YOU THINK

It’s easy to think of leadership as something that shows up in big decisions about strategy, growth, and transformation, but in practice, it reveals itself in the details.

It’s reflected in what you prioritize, what you design intentionally, and in what you refuse to treat as just operational.  That first interaction is one of those moments.

When leaders invest in structuring the first contact properly and supporting the people responsible for delivering it, the impact is tangible, not just in efficiency, but in trust, relationships, and ultimately performance.

The businesses that consistently close deals and bring on new clients not only deliver value, they demonstrate it from the very first moment. By the time the work begins, the decision has often already been made.

Eric Schurke is the CEO of North America at Moneypenny.