Artificial intelligence (AI) is nothing new, but I think we’ve come to a new crossroads in the AI revolution. ChatGPT talks like a mostly well-spoken online human being. SEO tools use AI to develop optimized content. AI algorithms help with things like performance marketing and hiring. While the rush to use AI in business is real, AI isn’t always effective.
Customer service is one area in which I’m finding that AI is receiving growing skepticism. For example, replacing phone lines and email communication with chatbots has become a way to ease employee workload and provide 24/7 service to website users—but the results aren’t as stellar as one might expect. In fact, the increasing dependency on chatbots is creating a laundry list of issues for many businesses.
Here are a few of the top reasons why—contrary to initial expectations—chatbots are definitely not all the rage, plus a few ideas for how you can combat their downfalls.
1. CHATBOTS HAVE LIMITS
Tech-first fanatics have peddled chatbots as a panacea for customer service for years now. The narrative thus far has been that innovative AI algorithms will solve the bulk of customer issues, leaving humans to mop up what’s left.
In theory, this makes sense. But in reality, it is quite different. In a survey conducted by Computer Generated Solutions, about half of all customers admitted that chatbots can be fast and convenient. However, they added that they have their limits. Specifically, respondents said that chatbots were unable to solve their issues, took a long time to help, or could not understand them. A small group reported that chatbots were even creepy and unfriendly, while 54% of those asked said chatbots should always clarify that they aren’t human.
Whatever way you slice it, chatbots are still viewed by a large number of consumers as overblown tools that are only useful for simple activities. If you choose to rely on chatbots, be sure to have a human team as a backup. While they may not need to answer basic questions, your team should be available to step in as soon as the chatbot is confused or the customer asks a complex question.
2. CHATBOTS LACK RESOURCEFULNESS AND EXPERIENCE
Even when chatbots function smoothly, they can have inherently limited functionality. These limitations can be the result of a couple of different things.
First, chatbots can only answer queries based on the information they have available. When they have limited information, it stunts the quality of their responses. Second, I think AI tends to be less capable than people think. With the success of ChatGPT, 2023 has been hailed as “the year of AI.” Everyone expects AI to be fully functional, as if we’re living in the Star Wars universe or an Asimov film.
With customer service, though, you need more than data. You need to assemble key pieces of information in creative and innovative ways to solve problems. Many companies have recognized this nuanced element of customer service and have rejected chatbots as a result. There are key customer service expertise requirements, such as experience and resourcefulness, that are difficult to replicate with AI.
By incorporating a chat function in place of chatbots, you can offer an easy way for customers to contact your team and avoid the times when chatbots struggle to genuinely meet the needs of confused and dissatisfied customers.
3. CHATBOTS SHED LIGHT ON A FUNDAMENTAL MISALIGNMENT
It’s true that chatbots provide around-the-clock service. It’s also true that some customers prefer a quiet, out-of-the-way, automated option to answer simple questions such as store hours or basic product queries.
After that, though, the benefits that a bot offers are primarily focused on employees and businesses. They cut down on costs and reduce workloads. They make it possible for smaller businesses to look like larger operations. These are beneficial to a company, but the emphasis on these benefits is fundamentally misaligned with what should be a company’s primary focus: the customer.
Chatbots are now making life easier for employees and cheaper for businesses at the potential expense of the customer. Target Corp. is just one brand that takes advantage of the cost cut without making the customer pay. Rather than investing in chatbots, they have outsourced their customer service lines.
Make no mistake: Chatbots play a part in the future of customer service. But the way we use them is very important. With the direction we are headed, they’re not the present solution that I and many others may have collectively been hoping for. Without human ingenuity, they come up short too often and have too many limitations to truly replace humans in the customer service sector. By letting chatbots answer the basic questions and having a human team as backup, or by taking a step back to refocus on the customer and offer chat functions manned by humans, we can determine the ways that chatbots can be used to our and our customers’ advantage.
The time of the chatbot may be coming, but without any changes to the current system, it doesn’t seem that it will work out well.
John Hall is an investor in Calendar, the adviser for the growth marketing agency Relevance, keynote speaker, and author of “Top of Mind.”