Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why great ideas die young—and how leaders can save them

Companies that stifle creativity risk missing the next big idea.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Duncan Wardle

Founder · iD8 & innov8

In one of my first innovation workshops at Disney, a senior executive shut down an idea within seconds: “We already tried that.” The room went quiet. The session—intended to spark fresh thinking—never recovered. The idea in question wasn’t revolutionary, but it might’ve led somewhere interesting. We’ll never know. What we do know is that early judgment killed the momentum before it began.

This is a daily occurrence at companies worldwide. It happens every day in companies around the world. Not because people don’t want innovation, but because they’ve never been taught how to protect it. Ideas, especially in their early stages, need protection.

A survey from DecisionWise found that 34% of employees hold back ideas at work for fear of retribution. In today’s climate of disruption, that kind of creative hesitation is something no company can afford.

STOP KILLING IDEAS IN THE SEEDLING STAGE

Most ideas die not because they’re terrible, but because they’re immature. Teams tend to default to reductive responses like:

  • That’s not how we do things.
  • We tried that once and it failed.
  • There’s no budget for this.

These knee-jerk reactions aren’t born out of malice. They’re reflexes of a culture trained to judge first and explore later. But early judgment is the enemy of creativity.

Innovation is messy. Great ideas often arrive disguised as bad ones. In the early 2000s, Netflix leaders pitched a partnership to Blockbuster, suggesting they run the online side while Blockbuster focused on retail. Blockbuster laughed Netflix out of the room. That “bad” idea now dominates global streaming. If your organization isn’t set up to let fragile ideas breathe, you’re likely tossing future Netflixes in the trash.

SHIFT FROM ‘KILL MODE’ TO ‘CULTIVATE MODE’

To shift this mindset, I use a simple but powerful tool: The S.U.N. Framework—Suspend Judgment, Understand, and Nurture. Here’s how it works:

  • Suspend judgment: Pause reactions. Let the idea live a little before dissecting it.
  • Understand: Ask questions. Where did the idea stem from? What problem is it trying to solve?
  • Nurture: Encourage exploration, expansion, and iteration, even if it feels awkward.

Psychological safety is like sunlight; without it, frameworks won’t succeed. When people feel safe sharing half-formed ideas, innovation increases in quantity and quality.

SIGNAL THE SHIFT: EXPANSIVE VS. REDUCTIVE THINKING

One of the most overlooked but essential tools for idea nurturing is what I call “Indicate Behavior.” It’s the act of clearly signaling whether a brainstorming session or meeting is meant for expansive thinking (idea generation) or reductive thinking (evaluation and refinement).

Trying to brainstorm and critique simultaneously is like mixing oil and water. People either freeze up or default to safe, surface-level ideas.

At Disney, we physically separated spaces: The “iD8 Room” was where ideas were born, and everyone knew judgment stayed outside. In one organization I worked with, a team used a gorilla mask to indicate it was time for playful, imaginative thinking. It worked because it was intentional.

Other creative tools that help signal and protect expansive thinking include tactile or visual cues such as:

  • Red and yellow cards: Handing out red and yellow cards, soccer-style, during brainstorming meetings. Yellow means “watch your tone,” and red means “stop shutting things down.”
  • Physical props or rituals: Certain props can signal the switch to playful ideation mode, where no idea is too wild. Even a simple physical object, like a “talking stick,” or ringing a bell to start meetings, can remind the group that the floor belongs to the idea-sharer, not the critic.

These cues break critical thinking patterns and invite curiosity, fostering psychological safety by telling the brain, “It’s OK to imagine here.”

THE BENEFITS OF DESIGNING ENVIRONMENTS WHERE RISK FEELS SAFE

Ideas don’t grow in fear. They grow in environments where risk-taking feels shared. A 2024 study showed that group-based play increases psychological safety by shifting the perceived risk of speaking up from the individual to the group. When people engage in playful, low-stakes interactions, they’re more willing to take creative risks and support each other’s thinking.

Samantha Warren, a professor at the University of Portsmouth in the U.K., has found that playfulness at work boosts morale and leads to reduced absenteeism, stronger commitment, and better team building. It forms the human glue that makes creative thinking stick.

Organizations are quickly recognizing the importance of cultivating creativity. According to the World Economic Forum’s 2025 Future of Jobs Report, 57% of employers now consider creative thinking a core skill, ranking it fourth overall.

LET IDEAS SOAK IN THE SUNLIGHT

The next time your team presents a messy, half-baked idea, don’t dismiss it. Ask:

  • Have we created the right environment for this idea to grow?
  • Are we in expansive or reductive mode?
  • What signals can I use to create clarity and safety?

It’s easy to be the critic. It takes real leadership to be the cultivator.

Let’s stop killing seedlings before they sprout. Let’s build idea greenhouses, suspend judgment, and give creativity the sun it needs to rise.

Duncan Wardle, former vice president at The Walt Disney Company, runs creative consulting company iD8 and innov8 to embed innovative cultures.