The words “cancel culture” bring to mind outrageous stories, usually about the foibles of the rich and famous. You may think of damaged reputations that result in lost jobs, lost revenue, privacy issues and sometimes even threats to personal safety and lots of glaring headlines.
But the truth about this phenomenon is that regular citizens have the most to lose because they have limited resources to fight back. And because cancel culture is powered by the anonymity of the internet, it could happen to you or someone you know, leveraged by someone anonymous. When it comes to fighting back, the playing field is anything but level.
PUNISHMENT OR ACCOUNTABILITY
Calling out alleged transgressors online and then drumming up support from an online mob is becoming increasingly common. But what does canceling someone really mean and why is it happening?
Some view this practice as a way to hold people accountable for something they said or did, while others view the practice as censorship and a violation of free speech. But what happens when the claims that are circulated and repeatedly shared online are patently false, misleading or wildly exaggerated? How can the target fight back?
According to Pew Research Center, the “most common area of opposing arguments about calling out other people on social media arises from people’s differing perspectives on whether people who call out others are rushing to judge or instead trying to be helpful.”
A study by Pew found that those who see calling others out as a form of punishment, believe cancel culture reflects a trend of people silencing anyone they disagree with or forcing their views on others. Some people believe that others want to inflict harm on social media without having to face consequences.
Conversely, others believe no one should be censored and that doing so infringes on their right to free speech. They claim that offensive content is a matter of opinion, and that online mobs should not have the power to destroy someone for expressing something that is not embraced by the masses.
“By calling [offensive content] out, you make others aware that it is not acceptable. Silence on these subjects is the same as agreement. Calling it out brings awareness to others who might not know it is offensive,” one person told Pew Research.
Said another, “People seem to be actively looking for something to be offended by and to be outraged about. No one seems to consider whether a person intended to offend, or simply made an unfortunate choice of words out of ignorance.”
WHAT CONSTITUTES A CANCEL CULTURE ATTACK?
Cancel culture involves an “I’m right, you’re wrong” mentality coupled with a determination to shut down, or shame, anyone who does not feel the same way as the “canceler.” The result seeks to silence free speech in a manner that can be intimidating and punitive.
Author and psychologist Kimberley Wilson told Vogue that one of the biggest mental health risks from cancel culture is the “pile on,” or the fact that someone can be attacked online by thousands in just minutes.
“Social media has left a permanent trail of an indiscretion that otherwise would have been forgotten,” Wilson told Vogue.
THE POWER OF THE INTERNET
The power and influence of the internet cannot be overstated. The most insignificant person sitting at home can now weigh in on consequential topics on social media and in some cases, gain more attention than someone in government or the head of a large corporation.
WHY NO ONE IS EXEMPT FROM THE CANCEL CULTURE CURSE
People who before were powerless have now become powerful, moving from bystanders and observers to potential influencers, with their only credentials being access to a keyboard. The internet serves as the great equalizer, giving everyone equal access.
The danger comes when those ‘influencers’ move to silence, or ‘cancel,’ others with opposing views because they believe their position is the only acceptable stance. These online detractors become judges, juries, and executioners as they drum up support from detractors who share the same views. And although some say cancel culture is about holding others accountable, it is important to remember that justice in our nation has never been about mob rule or vigilantism.
Businesses would do well to steer clear of hot-button issues in order to avoid boycotts or becoming the victim of cancel culture because a polarized customer base disagrees with the company’s stance on some topic.
Cancel culture impacts the ability of individuals to express themselves, a right that is protected from government interference by the Constitution. It can also impact the competition of ideas in free, transparent, and public discourse. Cancel culture is fomenting a worrisome intolerance for opposing ideas, which is why businesses should avoid weighing in on controversial issues if they do not want to deal with potential fallout.
PLAN FOR THE WORST
Plan for the worst and hope for the best. Creating a plan to weather a cancel culture assault is similar to developing a detailed crisis communications plan. Both require thought, foresight, and preparation. Both can also save time and protect reputations from long-term damage if an assault on your character takes place.
Unfortunately, cancel culture attacks can materialize out of nowhere and wreak havoc fast. Knowing what to do and how to respond is essential to protecting your reputation, your livelihood and your good name. The quicker the response, the easier it is to limit damage and regain control of the narrative.
CONCLUSION
Farming justice out to online mobs that subject their targets to threats, financial ruin and permanently destroy their ability to function in society flies in the face of due process and free speech. Businesses that do not want to get caught up in any avoidable crossfire would be less likely to be targeted if they do not weigh in on touchy issues.
Those who frequent the virtual world of social media, which is filled with vicious would-be attackers who are ready to spring into action, must be prepared to fight back if their words or actions put them in the hot seat.
Evan Nierman is Founder and CEO of Red Banyan, a global crisis PR firm, and is author of The Cancel Culture Curse and Crisis Averted.