The headlines are compelling. Billions of dollars in manufacturing investment commitments. New facilities across the American heartland. Political leaders touting the return of American manufacturing prowess. If you believe the press releases and policy speeches, we’re witnessing a wholesale transformation of the global manufacturing landscape.
From where I sit, working daily with electronics manufacturers across North America, the reality looks quite different. Reshoring is happening, but it’s not the revolution some anticipated. It’s an evolution that is measured, incremental, and fraught with challenges that don’t make for exciting sound bites.
THE ANNOUNCEMENT VERSUS REALITY GAP
Let’s start with a hard truth: not every announced manufacturing investment materializes as promised. We’ve all seen the splashy announcements, major OEMs committing to new U.S. facilities, promising thousands of jobs, and billions in capital expenditure. Some materialize. Many don’t, at least not at the scale originally announced.
I’ve watched companies announce ambitious reshoring plans, only to scale them back once they confront the practical realities. By the time the ribbon-cutting happens, if it happens, the project often looks considerably different from the initial commitment. Maybe it’s something less than originally promised, or the timeline stretched from 18 months to three years.
This isn’t necessarily because companies are disingenuous. It’s because reshoring is genuinely difficult, and the challenges only become fully apparent once you start executing.
THE SUPPLY CHAIN CONUNDRUM
Here’s what often gets overlooked in reshoring discussions: You’re not just moving manufacturing. You’re attempting to relocate an entire ecosystem.
When a company decides to build products in the U.S. rather than Asia, they’re not simply installing equipment in a new building. They need components, sub-assemblies, specialized materials, and entire supply chains that, in many cases, don’t exist domestically at the required scale or cost structure.
I’ve watched manufacturers successfully set up U.S. production lines, only to struggle because critical components still come from overseas. It mitigates some supply chain risk but hasn’t eliminated it. In some cases, it’s increased complexity by adding shipping steps and inventory requirements.
Building domestic supply chains takes years, not months. This reality constrains how quickly reshoring can occur at scale.
THE TALENT CHALLENGE NOBODY WANTS TO DISCUSS
Perhaps the most significant barrier to rapid reshoring is one that makes politicians uncomfortable: we don’t have enough people who want to work in factories.
During COVID, many Americans discovered they could earn income through home-based businesses, gig economy work, or remote employment. Even if factory work might pay more, the perceived lifestyle advantages of alternatives prove compelling for some workers.
For companies that need to hire a few new people to staff additional lines, recruitment is challenging but manageable. For facilities requiring 200 or 2,000 workers, the math becomes nearly impossible in many U.S. markets.
I’ve seen this play out in the semiconductor sector, where major Asian manufacturers establishing U.S. facilities resort to bringing workers from their home countries because they cannot find sufficient domestic talent.
The irony isn’t lost on me: political leaders tout domestic job creation while the companies they’re celebrating struggle to fill positions with American workers.
WHO’S ACTUALLY SUCCEEDING—AND HOW
Despite these challenges, reshoring is happening. Companies making real progress tend to share four characteristics.
1. They are often in sectors where reshoring makes compelling economic and strategic sense. This includes military/aerospace, medical devices, and high-value electronics, where proximity to engineering teams and customers justifies higher labor costs.
2. These companies typically have existing U.S. facilities with idle capacity. Setting up a new line in an existing building with an existing workforce is exponentially easier than building from scratch.
3. They’re investing heavily in automation. Companies can’t replicate Asian labor cost structures domestically, so they’re designing operations around fewer, more skilled workers supported by advanced equipment and software. This is where our industry plays a crucial role—providing the inspection, measurement, and process control systems that enable more automated, less labor-intensive operations.
4. They’re taking an incremental approach. Rather than attempting wholesale transfer of production, they’re moving specific products or production stages, learning from each step before expanding.
The 2027-2028 TIMELINE
When I talk with manufacturers about their reshoring plans, I’m seeing a timeline beginning to materialize. Some companies are bringing new facilities online in 2026. We’re working directly with manufacturers who’ve purchased existing buildings and are running small-scale startup and production qualification processes. For companies building new facilities, we’re seeing construction timelines targeting production in the second half of 2026.
Most announced projects still target 2027 for full-scale production, reflecting the realities I’ve outlined: facility construction or modification, equipment procurement and installation, supply chain development, and workforce recruitment and training. Done properly, this takes time.
But the fact that some early movers are already bringing capacity online demonstrates that reshoring isn’t just talk anymore—it’s starting to happen. The timeline is measured and deliberate, but it’s real.
EVOLUTION WORTH SUPPORTING
None of this should be interpreted as pessimism about reshoring’s future. The trend is real and will continue. The strategic logic is sound: reducing supply chain vulnerability, improving responsiveness to market changes, protecting intellectual property, and maintaining critical manufacturing capabilities domestically.
The data support this optimism. Growth forecasts for the EMS market in the Americas—spanning the United States, Canada, and Mexico—show positive trajectories for the next five years. This isn’t speculation; it’s backed by actual investment decisions and capacity planning from major manufacturers.
But we need realistic expectations. Reshoring is an evolutionary process that will unfold over years, perhaps decades. It will be uneven across sectors and geographies and will require continued policy support, sustained investment in workforce development, and technological innovation to offset cost disadvantages.
Most importantly, it requires patience from everyone involved—executives, investors, policymakers, and the public. The revolution makes better headlines, but evolution is what we’re getting.
And frankly, sustainable evolution is probably better than revolutionary disruption anyway.
Joel Scutchfield is the general manager of SMT and Semicon Business Operations at Koh Young America, Inc.