Last year, I was working with the chief technology officer of a Fortune 50 company. In the middle of an intense working session, I caught him staring off into the distance. He exhaled and said: “If anyone could just take 20% of their time and properly think through what is happening right now, they would dominate in this chaos.”
What my client articulated wasn’t unique to this moment, but rather an infuriating pattern in business: the marginalization of rigorous understanding.
By understanding, I’m not talking about the data, analysis, or answers businesses are designed to seek. Nor am I talking about the “shortcuts” businesses use to make understanding more defensible, such as management theories, consulting frameworks, credentialed processes, or analytical tools. None of these shortcuts are wrong in and of themselves, but they are packaged as substitutes for an understanding increasingly deprioritized.
Instead, understanding is the synthesis that sits above the data, the analysis, and the answers. It is the uniquely human ability to sense what is meaningful to the challenge at hand, interrogate it, imagine what could be, discern the right path, and act on it with conviction. It’s a comprehension that doesn’t reduce to a repeatable process, a specific skill, or a tangible tool. A shortcut hands you a what you can defend; understanding gives you the why to act no matter what the future brings.
Marginalizing this understanding in business has never been more frustrating than today, as businesses ready themselves for the AI age.
In a race to infuse AI into their organizations, businesses again prioritize shortcuts over strengthening understanding. They roll out AI literacy boot camps to teach prompt engineering and the like, intent on building AI skills in niche domains such as marketing and finance. All while purposelessly incentivizing AI use with tokenmaxxing leaderboards.
What I find particularly infuriating is the irony surrounding it. AI’s philosophical questions lead everyone from Harvard Business Review to World Economic Forum to AI creators to highlight the importance of human capabilities that deliver understanding. Yet, even with an alternative intelligence—capable of nearly everything except understanding—directly juxtaposed to human intelligence, no one is investing in what differentiates.
If human capabilities are as valuable as we say and, in my opinion, the half-life of technical skills can be expected to soon fall below two years, why do we continually bypass the durable ability to understand for the perishable tool-skill du jour?
Deep, genuine understanding is king. Not only in a general, philosophical context, but in the ruthless, dollars-and-cents business context as well.
Why understanding is king
In my opinion, the HBR article “Strategy in an Era of Abundant Expertise“unintentionally describes why understanding should be prioritized in business. The article’s premise is simple—if a business is “a differentiated bundle of expertise organized to accomplish specific tasks,” it will outsource expertise unrelated to its core business once that expertise’s cost decreases. The past several decades of technological innovation exemplify exactly this narrowing of in-house expertise.
For example, because cloud providers now offer infrastructure-as-a-service, a retail business no longer needs an in-house team managing its cloud infrastructure. The team is free to focus on the expertise that drives business differentiation.
Enter AI, lowering the cost of broad, superhuman expertise. As businesses outsource work to the technology, they must build the expertise that differentiates their business, as in the past. Only now, they must build the expertise that sits above AI-commodified information, analysis, and answers. That expertise is understanding.
While understanding is particularly differentiating in this moment, juxtaposed with widespread AI adoption, its durability makes it king.
Management theories, tools, processes, and skills’ usefulness come and go because they are products of a moment in time. When the conditions change, their usefulness expires. It’s why Porter’s business theory of sustainable competitive advantage no longer applies, in my opinion, and why no one is listing Visual Basic 6 on their résumé. All useful at a moment in time. All have since perished.
While the shortcuts are the fragile “what,” understanding is the durable “why.”
Understanding is what produced the theories, tools, processes, and skills in the first place. It was rigorous effort to understand that birthed new theories of the moment and established the abilities that became new skill sets. After Porter’s theory, there was Blue Ocean Strategy, and after the programming language Visual Basic 6, there was Python (for coding simpletons like me anyway).
When the moment changes, and the shortcuts’ usefulness expires, the understanding underneath adapts. The ability to understand survives any change. This is why understanding is the expertise that trumps them all.
How to advocate for understanding
If there was ever a moment for businesses to embrace understanding, it is now.
Uniquely human capabilities, such as those that promote understanding, have been forced into the business domain due to the questions surrounding AI. However, most of the discussion surrounding human capabilities is as a refuge. They are “how you save your job,” highlighted independently from AI.
Human capabilities are not a refuge—they’re what make AI worth having at all.
Understanding is what amplifies AI. AI is a rocket ship that has no idea where to go, what to explore, what to support, or what to make real. AI without understanding produces workslop, trendslop, and 10 other “slops” that have yet to be coined.
Organizations that realize AI transformation is less about their technology and more about their people will reap the compounding benefits.
Said another way, taking the time to think is exactly how you dominate in this chaos.
Julian Mancia is an independent strategic advisor.