Non-fungible tokens—more commonly referred to as NFTs—revolutionized the internet by making it possible to authenticate ownership and originality of digital images, videos, and music. Before the invention of NFTs, which are minted digitally on immutable ledgers called blockchains, it was impossible to assign any kind of real value to digital art. That’s because before the invention of blockchain technology, any JPEG could simply be copied ad infinitum with zero distinction between the original creation and all of the copies that came after it.
However, the advent of NFTs has changed the game: They’ve made it possible for artists to create a single digital image that’s distinguishable from all the rest. Now, anyone who purchases the pieces of digital art can identify the “Van Gogh” from all the fakes. The Merge, an NFT by digital artist Pak, sold for $91.8M in 2021 to become the most expensive NFT ever sold.
It’s also important to note many other major innovations that NFTs brought to the table: namely, the ability for creators to benefit from resales of NFTs in the form of royalties. These royalties are usually between 3% and 10% of the total cost that the NFT is sold for, and they make it possible for the original creator of the work to earn a percentage of sales in perpetuity—something that does not occur on the traditional art market.
However, the benefit of creator royalties is currently under fire by many of the major NFT marketplaces and platforms, including OpenSea, Magic Eden, and LooksRare. If Web3 wants to live up to the way it was originally advertised to artists and creators, I believe these marketplaces and the industry at large need to make good on the promise to creators by prioritizing royalties. A failure to do so could lead creators to stop participating—something that would lead to a loss that would be felt by the entire ecosystem.
WHERE CREATOR ROYALTIES STAND TODAY
Since the creation of NFTs, creator royalties were seemingly part and parcel to Web3. They supported the industry’s ethos of decentralization, ensuring that artists were paid in perpetuity for their contributions to the ecosystem as a whole, and eliminated the need for third-party art brokers. However, due to pressures created by the bear market in the fall of 2022, automated market makers grew in popularity, and NFT traders quickly saw the benefits of trading NFTs with 0% royalties.
In order to stay competitive, major marketplaces like Magic Eden pivoted to a royalty-optional model, and new platforms like Blur were initially launched with zero-royalty enforcement (while now the company enforces a minimum royalty of 0.5%). In response to Blur’s rising popularity, OpenSea—the platform that originally built a tool to enforce creator royalties—decided to pivot its business model by dropping fees and cutting this creator royalty enforcement tool.
While there are platforms like SuperRare that have made promises to uphold creator royalties, the reality of the matter is that the overall shift in the NFT market landscape is looking increasingly bleak for creators. If artists can’t see benefits in perpetuity for their work—something that sets Web3 apart—then they will have no reason to keep building in the industry, and the industry will lose out on key visionaries and contributors.
THE POTENTIAL FOR ROYALTIES TO CHANGE THE GAME FOR ARTISTS
Royalties have the ability to completely disrupt the creator economy as we know it: To date, there is no concrete tool that helps artists across visual art, music, and film ensure that they see repeated financial gains for their work. On top of that, artists in almost every industry have to rely on middlemen to ensure that they receive monetary benefits for their work and that they are paid fairly. Royalties remove the need for agents and brokers, and help artists significantly when it comes to increasing their own agency over their careers and gaining passive income that can be make-or-break.
By enforcing royalties, NFT marketplaces have the opportunity to completely turn the creator economy on its head and offer opportunities to artists that they can’t get in any other industry. As a result, this has the potential to lead to a massive renaissance of the arts. Individuals who have forgone the pursuit of their artistic passions for more stable incomes could actually start earning meaningful income from their artistic pursuits—meaning that they have the ability to dedicate their lives to their art and potentially offer cultural contributions that could help push society forward unlike ever before.
Additionally, the marketplaces where these NFTs are traded depend on creator participation. There is a lot at stake should creators decide to stay out of Web3 due to the lack of sufficient incentives. As part of this, I believe these platforms also need to find other ways to retain and generate value for users—those buying NFTs—so they stop competing based on which platform charges secondary fees.
CREATOR ROYALTIES CAN BENEFIT EVERYONE
There are many other parties and individuals that stand to reap major benefits from creators who are supported by fair royalty enforcement systems. This includes brands that partner with creators, as well as collectors and users who purchase NFT-related art or interact with NFTs on a regular basis.
When artists flocked to Web3 and saw economic benefits for their contributions, they were able to offer innovations that truly put Web3 on the map. The crypto bull run did not get mainstream attention as a result of Bitcoin’s all-time highs alone—the public was fascinated by NFTs and the newfound ability for digital artists to be paid for their work.
The bottom line is that if creator royalties are eliminated, it’s not only artists who suffer—it’s everyone. If creators are not incentivized to create, then the ecosystem’s growth will dampen, and Web3—particularly NFT marketplaces—will need to come up with new value propositions to keep creators involved.
Yonathan Lapchik is CEO of Suku.