Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why you don’t need a perfect plan

Executives who successfully marry agility with the minimum required accuracy will outperform—and even outlast—their peers in the coming years.

Business professional in a hurry

[Images: Adobe Stock/master1305]

Profile photo of Jay Muelhoefer

Inflation. Customer uncertainty. Your anxiety. Business disruption is now inevitable.

Everything from geopolitical turmoil to economic volatility can create issues for organizations across the globe. And this concern comes before accounting for black swan events such as pandemics and rapidly shifting consumer preferences, like requesting everything from prescriptions to king-sized mattresses be delivered to their doorsteps.

Given this new reality, enterprise and team resilience in decision-making are paramount. Resilience is what will enable companies—and you—to thrive amidst not only so much change going forward, but also the diversity and pace of those changes. Most executives already know this, but many have differing opinions on how to build the first plan and then manage through the inevitable changes.

Is a fast decision made with limited information better than a decision made later?

The best answer often lies somewhere in the middle. Executives who successfully marry agility with the minimum required accuracy will outperform—and even outlast—their peers in the coming years.

THE PROBLEM WITH BEING DRIVEN BY MAXIMIZING ACCURACY

Tension naturally exists between agility and accuracy, and many perceive agility and accuracy as opposite ends of a spectrum. This is a reasonable framework on the surface. It takes a lot of time and energy to consider every variable before making a decision, detracting from agility.

Still, leaders often choose this path for the sake of being better informed. One reason is that we have an overabundance of rich data at our disposal. Many management and data science teams believe we should be harnessing this data with the power of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) to capitalize on the technology and available information.

What we’ve realized, though, is that the costs of over-focusing on accuracy may not be worth the benefits, due to the pace of change in today’s world. If it takes a week to do an analysis but the pace of change is measured in days—or hours, or minutes—then all the assumptions that went into that analysis will have changed by the time it is completed. Organizations must match their rate of decision-making to the rate of market changes.

Some technologists point to the potential of AI and ML to address this paradox. While AI/ML has a lot of potential, the technologies are limited by needing to learn from past events to predict better outcomes. ML has had success automating mundane and robotic situations. The next frontier is augmenting human decision-making with insights and enabling humans to continue applying their judgment and knowledge to drive business outcomes. 

STRIKING THE BALANCE BETWEEN ACCURACY AND AGILITY

What we need more than extreme accuracy is higher agility supplemented by just enough precision. We can make good quick decisions with limited information—a perfect plan two weeks late is not as effective as a good plan implemented on time.

Consider how we approach travel today. Before going on a trip, we use applications that show us route options—some might include highways, others are all back roads, and others have a higher cost due to tolls. What is important is that the traveler gets to see the paths in seconds. What if it took 30 minutes to get the different options and you needed to start your trip immediately? You’d be hoping you guessed which was the best path, and that the path hadn’t been impacted by an unexpected event, like an accident.

In this case, it’s useful to think ahead and determine the optimal route. But traffic patterns, weather conditions, and technology failures can easily disrupt the optimal plan. What would be better is the ability to get the best path with as much available information at the outset, and then have the agility to adjust your path regularly as conditions change.

In business and analytics terms, this is the fusion of optimization and heuristics. Heuristics are a category of approaches, loosely based on trial and error that then comes as an algorithm, which can be used to solve a problem. Optimization and heuristics both have their places, but even better is if you can marry both of them together—agility and accuracy.

HOW SOME SUPPLY CHAIN EXECUTIVES ARE SUCCEEDING

One area in which we are seeing the value of agility on display is supply chain management. In recent years, supply chain executives have had to boost agility to overcome massive uncertainty and disruption. After the pandemic hit and sent supply chains into chaos, forecasting lost much of its power as both demand and supply whipsawed from scarcity to excess.

Rather than try to predict the future based on so much volatility, some supply chain teams decided to invest in capabilities and technology that enabled rapid, yet informed, decision-making. They adopted software that centralized crucial activities—like inventory management, planning, forecasting, and analytics—and extended those solutions to external partners.

These leaders know there is no perfect plan in a world in which change happens all the time. Recognizing they will continuously be impacted by imperfection, these innovative leaders are changing their planning philosophies and techniques to account for the disruptions that fundamentally exist in their markets, customers, suppliers, and within their companies. The new supply chain planning renaissance is being powered by a revolutionary concurrent planning technique that is making supply chain ecosystems become more open and collaborative. Multi-department and multi-enterprise teams can share information, fix complex problems, and move faster in response to external conditions. The digital transformation of supply chains broke down silos and unleashed new innovative possibilities.

Executives in other industries can follow in the footsteps of supply chain leaders and benefit from their experiences over the last several years. Those who embrace agility will be able to navigate this ever-changing world much more effectively and achieve business resilience. By fusing agility with accuracy, companies can outpace and stand apart from the competition moving forward.


Jay Muelhoefer is the Chief Marketing Officer at Kinaxis