Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why you should decouple your website platform from your website redesign

While a website redesign keeps plenty of web designers busy, it can be disruptive to business, be expensive, and is often less-than-optimal for the customer. 

Woman working on a laptop

[Images: Adobe Stock/WavebreakMediaMicro]

Profile photo of Greg Kihlstrom

BY Greg Kihlstrom

The website redesign: It is an all-consuming, oft-repeated, difficult-to-measure process that seems to be a requirement for any brand wanting to stay on top of their customer expectations and competitive pressures. But what if I told you that the “required” website redesign process is an out-of-date way of thinking? While it keeps plenty of web designers busy, it can be disruptive to business, be expensive, and is often less-than-optimal for the customer. 

I’m going to talk about why you should decouple the design and interface of your site from the platform that runs it by discussing three things to consider when redesigning your enterprise website.

1. IT’S BAD FOR THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

Don’t you hate it when you can’t find what you’re looking for? What if you just saw it yesterday and many days before in one spot, and then today all of a sudden it is in a completely different place? This is what a website redesign is like for your customers, even if you are providing them with an enhanced design and new features. 

Remember that different isn’t necessarily better. As sick as you may be of your homepage, remember that customers often have a very pragmatic reason for using your website. They value functionality over aesthetics, and consistency over change for change’s sake.

Consider the impact a sudden change can have on that experience. In some cases, the improvement is so big that it will be regarded well, but if it is more a matter of the same things essentially being in different places, you might want to reconsider some of your choices. 

2. IT’S DISRUPTIVE TO BUSINESS

Let’s face it: As excited as you may be to get a new website, there is a price to be paid beyond the cost of licensing software and paying web developers to write code. 

For instance, from the teams at your company’s perspective, a website redesign can often be something that happens in addition to the normal workload. And even with dedicated teams for portions of the project, some roles will still need to be involved. 

Additionally, sales and customer service teams are affected by a sudden change in the design of a website from customers who may suddenly not be able to find something they have relied on accessing in a specific way. This takes time away from those teams and their normal day-to-day work.

Total cost of ownership

There are many costs to consider when undertaking a website redesign, and in addition to the one-time cost of the project itself (albeit one that can take months or years to complete), it is important to think of your investment over time. 

Here are some things to consider when looking at the total cost of ownership of your website in terms of proceeding with a complete overhaul:

Replatforming: Changing digital experience platforms or content management systems has its own set of costs associated with it, including licensing, different hosting requirements, and more. Other, more hidden costs include onboarding and educating your teams on how to use the new platform when many have spent many hours learning and honing their expertise with the previous one.

A switch of platforms also inherently results in a large amount of code being rewritten that is redundant and simply needed because the new platform doesn’t run on the same code as the old one. This can be incredibly wasteful, particularly in cases where there is a high degree of custom functionality that sites have on top of a core DXP or CMS.

Switching agencies: Unless you perform all of the work for your website redesign internally, you will likely be relying on one or more outside agencies to assist. Because many firms specialize in one or only a handful of platforms, if you are switching your DXP, you may need to find a new agency to assist. In many cases, a website redesign is a good excuse to take another look at existing vendor relationships in the first place. 

While this can be a positive in some ways, there is a cost involved in switching agencies, and if the reason for the switch is solely because your current one doesn’t work in the platform you are moving to, there is unknown risk as well. To replatform and completely redesign your site every few years, you could be paying a pretty steep cost. 

3. IT’S BAD FOR MEASUREMENTS AND LEARNING

Additionally, a complete website overhaul presents some major challenges for measurement and for learning what works and what doesn’t as an organization. A good experiment takes a good hypothesis, a control, and a narrow scope to measure. 

So how do you test everything on the old site versus everything on the new one? The short answer is that you can’t. At best, you can test how various portions perform and convert on the new site compared to the old site,  but that is missing a high degree of fidelity because of the massive changes.

Also, what are you really learning to apply to new initiatives and campaigns if everything changes? If these answers are unclear, how does the organization improve and get better with new iterations to the site? For those concerned with truly understanding the performance of a website, a redesign is very disruptive. 

To get started, there are a few things you can do. First, try to identify where the biggest pain points are, and if they are related to the platform or content. Then, think about your approach from the perspective of the customer: What will be most impactful and least disruptive to them? Finally, prioritize from a business standpoint the areas that will have the most benefit to the organization, customer, all while minimizing disruption to business as usual. With this approach, you can create a win-win for all.

As you can see, there are some good reasons to think about decoupling the platform that runs your site and the interface and content sitting on top of that code.


Greg Kihlström is a marketing technology and CX consultant at GK5A, speaker, author, and host of The Agile Brand with Greg Kihlström.