Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why you should hire people who can write

Five ways I screen for the skill that matters.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of JD Barker

AuthorPublisher · Hampton Creek Press

A few months ago, I read two cover letters back-to-back for the same role. Both were polished, and opened by telling me the candidate was passionate. Both promised to drive impact and add value from day one.

Yet, if you swapped the names at the top, I wouldn’t have noticed. That is what hiring looks like now. With AI, anyone can produce a clean paragraph in seconds. Very few people can produce a clear one.

Those are different skills, and I find my best hires in the gap between them.

To write is to think

I’ve written books for a living and have run a company for years, and I believe the same thing about both jobs. Writing is how you discover what you think.

When someone sits down to explain a decision in plain language, they run into every soft spot in their reasoning. Good writers learn to notice the sentence that won’t come together, because it’s usually an unfinished idea. They push through it. Weak writers cover up the unfinished idea with jargon and hope nobody asks about it.

That’s why I care so much about writing skills with my hires, especially in leadership. A manager who can write a clear one-page memo can usually think clearly about the problem in it. A manager who hands me three pages of bullet points and buzzwords is often telling me, without meaning to, that they haven’t figured it out yet.

The AI flood made the skill rare

Generative AI has made average writing free. Emails, reports, proposals, and performance reviews now arrive fully formed, grammatically perfect, and strangely empty of meaning. My inbox has never been more articulate or less useful.

Most leaders miss that when everyone has access to the same fluent prose, fluency stops signaling anything. The tools can’t supply a person who knows what they actually mean and can say it in a way that makes someone else act.

Clear writing now stands out the way a handwritten note stands out in a stack of junk mail. It’s a gift when I receive a short email that gets to the point, describes a decision, and tells me what the writer needs from me. I notice who sends those. So does everyone else in the company.

The alternative has a cost, too. Every vague message creates more work downstream. Someone has to ask a follow-up question or schedule a clarifying meeting. Unfortunately, ambiguous instructions can even lead to someone making the wrong call.

Multiply that across a team and a year, and unclear writing becomes one of the most expensive habits a business can tolerate.

What I mean by good writing

I’m not looking for novelists. I don’t need anyone to write beautifully. I need them to write usefully.

To me, good writing means three things: the writer knows whom they are talking to. The main point shows up early, not buried in the fourth paragraph. And the piece is as short as it can be while still doing its job.

That last one is the hardest. Anyone can add words. Cutting them requires you to decide what matters.

5 ways to screen for good writing

Resumes and cover letters no longer tell me much, so I’ve changed how I evaluate candidates. It works whether someone uses AI in their daily work or not.

1. Request a short writing exercise during the interview

This takes about 20 minutes in the room or on a call. The prompt is something real from our business, like explaining a tradeoff to a client or summarizing a messy situation for a busy executive. I’m looking at whether they understood the problem and whether I understood their writing.

2. Ask the interviewee to cut

I first ask the interviewee to edit down what they’ve written. After they finish, I tell them the reader only has time for half of what they’ve written. Watching what someone keeps and what they sacrifice tells me more about their judgment than almost any interview question.

3. I read everything they sent during the interview process

This includes the scheduling email, thank-you note, and reply to my follow-up question. Unguarded messages often reveal more than anything a candidate prepares. People who write clearly when the stakes are lower also tend to write clearly when the stakes are high.

4. I ask the interviewee to explain something

Specifically, something they know well, to someone who doesn’t understand that something well. It can be their last project, a concept from their field, anything. Then I ask them to write the same explanation in a few sentences. The ability to translate expertise for an outsider is one of the rarest and most valuable skills a leader can have.

5. I ask the interviewee’s references a specific question

I ask the references the interviewee provided the following question: When this person sent you a written work update, did you ever have to reread it? The answer is usually immediate, and it is usually honest. The answer I’m seeking is a no.

The skill that compounds

I understand some feel none of this matters anymore. If the machines can write, why pay a premium for people who can?

Because the tools amplify whatever you bring to them. Give a clear thinker a powerful writing assistant, and you get clearer thinking, faster. Give a muddled thinker the same tool, and you get more confident nonsense, at greater scale.

The people who can write will direct tools like AI. The people who can’t will be directed by them.

So when I look at a stack of candidates now, I ask who is the easiest to understand. That person is almost always the one I want in the room when things get hard.

JD Barker is the owner of Hampton Creek Press.