Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why your change initiatives keep stalling

Why most change efforts lose traction and how you can spark momentum.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of John Hall

Co-founder · Calendar

I remember when Barack Obama won a presidential election on a campaign centered on a single word: “change.” Fast forward 18 years (including a recession and a pandemic), and the word “change” can create more cringe than curiosity. Teams are exhausted by transformation initiatives, even as the tech world forces us to adapt at an ever-accelerating pace.

So why are so many organizational change efforts quietly losing momentum after the initial announcement? For an answer, I ask you to remember the full phrase Obama ran on: “Change we can believe in.”

Change, on its own, isn’t enough to inspire or create positive results. It needs to be focused. It needs to be sustainable. It needs to spark hope and buy-in.

If your change initiatives keep stalling, here are some thoughts on how you can reposition your ongoing organizational transformation on a sounder footing that encourages people to believe in each effort as the best path forward for your company, your team, and your professional career.

GET IN THE PSYCHOLOGIST’S CHAIR

Change is more than a shift in your standard operating procedures (SOPs). It often comes with a transformational element that challenges the status quo and upsets expectations.

That’s a good thing when those expectations aren’t getting the job done. But it isn’t an excuse to ignore the mental disruption. You need to consider how each form of change influences different groups within your company.

Another Fast Company Executive Board Member touched on this in their article about customization and flexibility in a multigenerational workforce. The same topic came up when I heard about a company called ChangeFusion while at a conference last year, so I did some further research to learn more about the key areas they were focusing on as an adaptive leadership and change strategy firm. One example they highlighted was how women leaders are redesigning the rules of leadership, not only by adopting new behaviors, but fundamentally challenging traditional ways of thinking (and bringing significant change in the process).

Change can be effective, but it always comes with a cognitive cost. Failing to address the psychological side of change can lead to excessive strain and unhappy team members, whether it’s catering to the expectations of a younger employee without compromising quality, integrating female-forward leadership policies with a more traditional workforce, or anything else.

If your change initiatives are stalling, start with the psychological angle. Consider how change is impacting each group within your team. If you can do this on an individual level, even better. Simply having this in your mind will naturally influence how you communicate and structure change moving forward.

CONSIDER THE MIDDLE TIER

The middle of your org chart isn’t flashy. It’s where the strivers are working their way up. It’s where careers may have stalled. It can be competitive, ruthless, and exhausting.

The middle is also one of the most important areas for effective change. If you lack mid-level buy-in, you’re going to struggle to get any change to stick—or even start, for that matter.

Why? Because middle-manager misalignment breaks the flow of communication across a company. It makes it hard for you to offer detailed instructions for your teams. It also blocks important feedback from reaching you.

The answer here is simple (although the degree of simplicity depends on how big your organization is). Go ahead and create company-wide change initiative announcements when they make sense. But always prioritize direct communication and involvement with middle management as a separate step in launching your initiative. Focus this leadership-oriented effort on a few things:

  • Education: Don’t shroud change in mystery. Give the why behind what’s happening.
  • Feedback: Let people challenge and ask questions. It’s better to surface these concerns early and address them before things start moving.
  • Empowerment: Equip your mid-level leaders with the understanding, tools, and roadmap required to execute your vision once they’re the “boots on the ground” group putting it into action daily.

REVIEW INCENTIVES AND STRUCTURES

Up to this point, I’ve focused on the more nuanced elements of transformation. Psychological elements and mid-level leadership buy-in are critical, but there are also practical things you can do to pave the way for better adoption once things are in motion.

One of those is reviewing the incentives and structures that are already in place. Ignoring the way existing incentives reinforce the status quo can lead to behaviors that contradict your intended change patterns.

For instance, when Microsoft reinvented its culture over a decade ago, it had a “stack-ranking” system in place. This forced ranking based on performance reviews had created a competitive pattern of behavior within the company. The leadership team had to remove this obstacle for its new cross-team collaborative approach to take root. In its place, new incentives were created around things like innovation and collective outcomes.

Where are your old incentives and cultural structures blocking your change initiatives? Don’t let your own system work against your desired transformation outcomes. Vet each incentive you offer and consider if it helps your goals. If not, get rid of it and create something new that aligns with your desired change.

MAKE CHANGE EXCITING AGAIN

Corporate change isn’t exhausted. It’s uninspired.

Don’t fall into the “change formula” trap. Always think through change initiatives and look for ways to tailor each to your current team and desired outcomes.

As you go along, consider the psychological impact. Get buy-in from middle management. Restructure incentives and systems to accelerate change adoption. If you can do that, you can create a spark that takes change from exhausting to exhilarating again.

John Hall is the cofounder of Calendar.