Every company I have ever worked with has a surplus of ideas and a shortage of clarity. Walk into any strategy offsite, and you will find whiteboards covered in initiatives, frameworks stacked on frameworks, and a roadmap that reads like a wish list written by a committee. Which, of course, it is.
The instinct in business, when things feel stuck, is to add. Add a consultant. Add a new priority. Add a strategist who will bring “fresh thinking,” which usually means a fresh layer of complexity on top of the old one. I understand the impulse. Adding feels like progress. It produces artifacts: decks, plans, org charts. It gives everyone something to point to.
But after years of running a business and writing books, I have come to believe the opposite. Most companies do not need another strategist. They need an editor.
WHAT EDITORS ACTUALLY DO
When people outside publishing hear the word editor, they picture someone fixing commas. That is a copyeditor, and it is honorable work, but it is not what I mean. A great editor does something far more valuable and far more brutal. They read 400 pages of a manuscript you love and tell you which 200 deserve to exist.
My editor has never once suggested I add a chapter. Every meaningful intervention has been subtraction or clarification. Cut this subplot; it goes nowhere. This chapter is really two ideas fighting each other; pick one. You buried your best sentence in the middle of paragraph six; move it to the top.
Notice what is happening in each of those notes. The editor is not generating new material. They are protecting the reader from everything that gets in the reader’s way. Their entire job is to ask one question relentlessly: What is this actually about, and does this piece serve it?
Now ask yourself when anyone in your company last asked that question about your product line. Your meeting calendar. Your website. Your strategy itself.
ADDITION IS CHEAP, SUBTRACTION IS EXPENSIVE
There is a structural reason companies drift toward bloat. Adding something is a low-friction act. A new feature, a new initiative, a new metric on the dashboard rarely requires anyone to lose anything. Cutting something is the opposite. Every project has an owner, every feature has a customer somewhere, every recurring meeting has a founder who remembers why it started. Subtraction creates losers, and organizations are engineered to avoid creating losers.
So the work of cutting almost never happens on its own. Behavioral researchers have found that when people are asked to improve something, they overwhelmingly reach for additions and systematically overlook subtractions, even when removing something is the better fix. Companies are just this bias, with a payroll.
That is why editing has to be someone’s actual job, or at minimum an explicit, protected function. Left to natural incentives, everyone adds and no one cuts, and the whole system slowly silts up.
THE EDITOR TEST FOR YOUR NEXT HIRE
Here is a practical way to think about it. When you evaluate senior candidates, most interview processes reward generative energy. Tell us your ideas. What would you build here? What is your 90-day plan? Candidates arrive with proposals, because proposals are how you demonstrate value in an interview.
Try flipping one interview. Hand the candidate your current strategy document, your product roadmap, or your homepage, and ask a single question: What would you remove, and why? You will learn more in 20 minutes than in three rounds of vision talk.
The great ones do three things. First, they cut, and they can defend the cut in terms of the customer or the mission rather than personal taste. Second, they clarify. They can take your tangled paragraph of positioning and return it as one sentence a new employee could repeat. Third, they simplify without dumbing down, which is the hardest skill of all, because it requires understanding the thing deeply enough to know which complexity is essential and which is decoration.
WHAT EDITING LOOKS LIKE INSIDE A COMPANY
An editorial function inside a business is not a person with a red pen. It is a set of habits enforced by someone with the standing to enforce them.
It is the product leader who insists that every new feature proposal name the feature it will replace or the maintenance it will retire. It is the executive who caps the strategy at three priorities and treats the fourth as a threat to the first three. It is the operations head who audits recurring meetings twice a year and kills the ones that no longer have a reader, so to speak. It is the leader who takes the all-hands deck from 40 slides to nine, not because nine is a magic number, but because the other 31 were hiding the point.
None of this is glamorous. Editors rarely get credit, in publishing or anywhere else, because their best work is invisible. Nobody thanks you for the confusing initiative that never launched. But readers feel the difference between an edited book and an unedited one on every page, and customers feel the difference between an edited company and an unedited one in every interaction.
THE DISCIPLINE OF LESS
Strategy, at its best, is already editing. It is the decision about what you will not do. Somewhere along the way we let the word come to mean the opposite: an ever-expanding portfolio of ambitions, and we started hiring for expansion when what we needed was compression.
So before you open the next strategist requisition, look around your company and ask the editor’s question. What is this actually about? Then find someone whose talent, and whose temperament, is to cut everything that is not the answer.
Your customers, like readers everywhere, will never see what you removed. They will only feel how clear everything suddenly became.
J.D. Barker is owner of Hampton Creek Press.