Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why you’re not ready to sell even if you think you are

Five questions to ask first.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Mark Valentino

President of Business Banking · Citizens

Most business owners don’t start planning for an exit until they think they’re close. By then, they’re already falling behind. Citizens’ research shows that just 15% of owners begin planning five or more years in advance of selling. Most wait until the one- to three-year mark.

That timing gap isn’t just academic. It often determines whether an owner runs a competitive process from a position of strength or not. These five questions can help you better prepare your exit strategy.

1. HOW DO I KNOW IF I’M PICKING THE RIGHT OPTION?

Readiness for exit may seem simple: The business is performing well, revenue is strong, and there’s interest from potential buyers. From there, the assumption is that the rest will come together during the process. A banker will determine valuation, identify the right buyer, and manage the transaction from start to end. By the time those conversations begin, many of the most important decisions have already been made, however, they may not have been made intentionally.

That’s because exit outcomes are shaped well before a business goes to market. When planning starts late, timelines become compressed, limiting the ability to address the issues that directly affect valuation and deal structure. Owners may realize too late that they haven’t positioned the business for the type of buyer they want, or that its performance depends too heavily on their own involvement. In other cases, there’s a clear plan to sell the business entity, but no clear plan for what happens next.

Business exits are like a choose-your-own-adventure book. A full sale, a partial sale, or a phased transition—each creates very different outcomes in terms of liquidity, control, and long-term involvement. The structure of the exit ultimately determines both the financial result and what comes next. Owners who understand those options early and plan accordingly are far more likely to run a process from a position of strength.

2. WHAT DRIVES THE VALUE OF MY BUSINESS?

Selling a business is not a one-time transaction—it marks a financial event and a leadership transition, however. This is the ultimate test of whether the company can endure change. Buyers do not just review current performance. They focus on what happens after the owner steps back. They ask whether results will hold up under new ownership, because strong revenue alone does not drive outcomes. Buyers look for consistency in earnings and confidence in future performance. They want revenue that repeats and does not rely on a small number of customers.

Let’s talk about management. A business that already runs without the owner’s day-to-day involvement carries less risk. Buyers place higher value on teams that can operate independently and make decisions without constant oversight from someone who’s about to exit the building and never return (with a few exceptions).

Companies are easier to transfer when they’re organized. Clear processes, documented systems, and reliable execution reduce disruption and signal the best chance at continuity during a transition.

Two businesses can report similar revenue and deliver very different results in a sale. The difference often comes down to predictability, structure and independence.

3. CAN THE BUSINESS RUN WITHOUT ME?

One of the most common questions buyers ask is whether the business can continue performing when the owner is no longer involved in day-to-day operations. When customer relationships, major decisions, or key knowledge sit with one person, the business becomes harder to transfer and more difficult to scale. Buyers view that concentration of responsibility as risk.

Strong management teams, documented processes, and self-starting employees set companies up for the most successful transitions. Retention incentives for key employees can also help provide continuity and preserve value after a sale.

For many business owners looking to sell, this is an issue that becomes apparent too late. Building independence takes time. It is far easier to do years (decades, even) before an exit than during a transaction process.

4. DO I HAVE THE RIGHT TEAM IN PLACE FOR THE EXIT PROCESS?

Building a business can sometimes feel lonely, but planning an exit is rarely a one-person exercise. Owners often focus on preparing the business itself, but putting the right team together to facilitate transition can be just as important to the outcome. Depending on the situation, that team may include a banker, mergers and acquisition advisor, certified public account, and legal or estate planning professionals to support them in navigating key decisions along the way.

Remember, this doesn’t just affect the business and your bank account. The proceeds from a sale can have a significant impact on an owner’s personal finances, family legacy, and lifestyle. Decisions about ownership, taxes, and wealth transfer are often intertwined with the transaction itself, making early planning essential.

5. HOW SHOULD I PREPARE FOR AN EXIT?

Most owners think they’re preparing for a sale when they’re really preparing for a lifestyle shift. The strongest outcomes develop from preparing both the business and yourself for what comes next. Readiness isn’t about timing the market. It’s about building a business that can thrive through transition while giving you, and the future owner, confidence in the path ahead.

Mark Valentino is head of business banking at Citizens.