Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your best employees are quietly building side businesses

Why you shouldn’t fight it.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of JD Barker

AuthorPublisher · Hampton Creek Press

I found out about my marketing director’s side business the way most business owners do—by accident. A mutual contact mentioned her newsletter, the one with several thousand subscribers that she had been running for two years without a word to me. My first reaction was exactly what you would expect from someone who signs the paychecks. I felt betrayed and a bit worried. Where was that energy going? Whose time was she building it on? How long until she quits?

Then I remembered something inconvenient. I wrote my first book while working for someone else. My research happened on weekends. I wrote the drafts at 5 a.m. The ambition and ideas behind it happened everywhere, all the time, including at my desk. My employer never knew until the book deal was announced. That project became my career, and I do not recall it making me a worse employee. If anything, I brought more to that job because I was becoming more.

Before you tighten your moonlighting policy, let me make the case that the side-hustle economy is not a threat to your company. But your reaction to it might be.

WHY THE SIDE HUSTLE IS HAPPENING

Start with the numbers you cannot change. Depending on which survey you trust, somewhere between 27% and 60% of workers now have some kind of income stream or project outside their job. Among your youngest and most capable people, that share is likely higher.

Side-project moonlighting is not a loyalty problem. It is a rational response to a world where a single employer no longer guarantees financial security, where the tools to start something cost almost nothing, and where a generation watched their parents get laid off after decades of devotion. The talented people you want to hire have internalized all of this. You are not choosing between employees with side projects and employees without them. You are choosing between knowing and not knowing.

Now consider what a side business signals. Someone who builds a product, finds customers, and keeps the thing alive on nights and weekends is demonstrating initiative, resourcefulness, and tolerance for risk. These are precisely the traits every job description claims to want. We spend fortunes on training programs to build an ownership mindset, then panic when an employee displays actual ownership of something. The contradiction would be funny if it were not so costly.

HOW TO MAKE IT WORK FOR YOU

Here is what changed for me after the newsletter discovery. I asked my marketing director to lunch and asked her to tell me about it. What I got was a masterclass in audience building that our own company badly needed. She understood email deliverability, subject-line testing, and community engagement at a depth many of the professionals on my payroll did not, because she had learned it with her own money on the line. Within a quarter, techniques from her side project were improving my company’s numbers. She was not stealing from the company. She was running a free research and development lab, and my book sales became the beneficiary.

That experience turned into policy. I now ask about side projects in interviews, not as a trap but with genuine curiosity. Candidates visibly relax when they realize I mean it.

To make it work, I have exactly three rules. No competing with my business. No using client relationships. And no working on it during hours I am paying for.

Beyond that, I treat it as their business, literally and figuratively. In exchange, I get something rare—honesty. People tell me what they are building. That transparency lets me spot conflicts early, plan around ambitions instead of being surprised by them, and occasionally invest in an idea before anyone else sees it.

THE RETENTION VIEW

The retention argument deserves a direct answer. I know what you are thinking: Won’t some of these people eventually leave to pursue their ventures full time? Yes. Some will. But be honest about the alternative. Ambitious people leave anyway. The only question is whether they leave as advocates, as strangers, or as something worse. My former employees who left to run their own companies have sent me clients, talent, and partnership deals worth far more than the cost of replacing them. A departure handled with grace is not a loss. It is an alumni network making its first deposit.

Meanwhile, the crackdown approach tends to fail. Ban side projects, and the projects do not stop. They go underground, which means you lose visibility while keeping all the risk. Worse, you filter your workforce over time. The entrepreneurial people leave or never join, and you are left with a team selected primarily for compliance. No owner I know would say out loud that they want less initiative in the building, yet that is exactly what a hostile moonlighting policy begets.

THE MORAL ARGUMENT

There is also a moral dimension owners often avoid discussing. Most of us built our companies while employed by someone else, or we know someone who did. The economy we operate in was largely constructed by moonlighters. Extending that same grace to our people is not generosity. It is consistency.

I will not pretend the anxiety over moonlighting disappears. Every so often I still feel the old flinch when I learn about a new personal venture from someone on my team. But I have learned to read that flinch correctly. It is not telling me the employee is a risk. It is telling me they have energy, ideas, and options. My job is to make my company a place where a person with options still chooses to stay. That is a higher bar than a policy manual. It is also the only bar that matters.

Your best people are already building their side hustles. The only decision you get to make is whether they build alongside you or despite you. Choose the version where you get to know about it.

J.D. Barker is owner of Hampton Creek Press.