Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your company doesn’t need more feedback

It needs better ways to hear it.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Paul L Gunn Jr

Founder & Strategic Advisor · Signal & Anomaly

Organizations have created multiple ways for employees to provide feedback, from surveys and meetings to town halls and open-door policies. Yet more opportunities to speak does not necessarily mean those who need to hear it are doing so. Information can lose its context or urgency between someone making an observation and someone else reaching a decision. Are organizations designed to hear what its people want to share?

The mismatch becomes more difficult as companies grow. Growth leads to more information while also creating greater distance between where observations and where someone has the authority to act on them. Departments become specialized and siloed, while information fragments across functions. Executives assemble pieces that may appear unrelated. Procurement may notice a supplier behaving differently while operations sees performance changes. Elsewhere, a customer conversation or financial pattern is changing too. Individual observations may not warrant action, but together they can reveal something.

THE NEED FOR HUMAN SYSTEMS

This is why I believe strong human systems matter alongside strong information systems. Companies are increasingly capable of collecting data and raising visibility around what can be measured, while the earliest indications of change remain embedded in human behavior. They appear in the hesitation before an answer or a question that does not fit the prevailing view. The person close to the work recognizes that something feels different but there is not enough evidence to prove why.

Whether those observations travel to the decision-makers can depend on how people communicate. Some develop their thinking through conversation, while others need time to process what they have heard before they know what they want to say. The person who immediately challenges an assumption in a room of executives may be no more perceptive than the person who recognizes the same concern later and expresses it more clearly in writing or in a smaller conversation. When organizations rely too heavily on one way of communicating, they can unintentionally confuse the channel with their ability to hear through it.

THE RESPONSE TO CHALLENGES

The deeper issue is what repeated experience teaches them about doing so. Leaders cannot and should not act on every suggestion; disagreement by itself does not make an organization stronger. Some concerns will prove meaningful while others will not, and even a valuable observation may come with the wrong recommendation. What matters is whether people believe the next observation is worth sharing. When challenges to ideas repeatedly disappear without consideration, silence can gradually replace participation. That silence can look remarkably similar to alignment.

I think of an organization’s ability to prevent unexamined “alignment” as challenge capacity. This is less about encouraging disagreement and more about whether contradictory information can surface, move across boundaries, reach those capable of evaluating it, and be considered without diminishing others’ willingness to challenge what they see next. As organizations become larger, that capacity becomes more important because every organizational boundary creates another place where information can be softened, separated from its context, or stopped altogether.

There is an inherent tension in this because the people with the authority to make consequential decisions often have the broadest view of the organization, while those without that authority may be closest to where conditions are changing. A healthy human system has to connect those perspectives. Yet even accomplishing that does not solve the problem because hearing something and knowing what to do about it are different capabilities.

An organization can hear a concern, understand it, and even believe it while remaining hesitant about what should happen next. The information may challenge a strategy that already has momentum, carry financial or operational consequences, cross boundaries where ownership is unclear, or simply arrive before leaders have enough information to determine the appropriate action. In those moments, the danger is that the organization has learned something consequential without yet developing the judgment to respond wisely.

FROM LISTENING TO JUDGMENT

This is where listening has to become judgment. Being heard should never mean that every recommendation is executed, because sometimes the wiser response is to investigate further, watch what develops, alter the decision timing, or consciously continue on the existing path. The distinction is whether the information has influenced judgment or simply arrived and become organizationally inert. Not every signal requires action, but consequential signals should rarely require nothing.

Designing for this may mean giving people more than one way to contribute. Observations should be allowed to continue after the meeting has ended, and paths should be created for information to move across functions before each piece isolates inside its own department. The purpose is to strengthen the quality of decisions, particularly during periods of growth or transformation, when speed can make agreement feel like progress.

Yet agreement deserves its own scrutiny. When disagreement disappears faster than uncertainty, what appears to be alignment may be something else. A room full of agreement can mean assumptions have been tested and concerns considered, but it can also mean the people who see things differently have learned that saying so changes very little.

The strongest organizations may therefore be those where challenges can travel far enough to matter. When that ability weakens, the organization slowly loses access to what its people collectively know. The supplier concern remains in procurement, the operational change remains on the floor, and the hesitation in one part of the company never connects with the anomaly appearing somewhere else.

Eventually, consequence connects those signals for everyone. By then, the organization may not be discovering something new but rather what someone already knew.

Paul L. Gunn Jr. is founder and strategic advisor at Signal & Anomaly.