Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your employees want more background checks

A new survey suggests employees want stronger verification than most processes deliver.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Houman Akhavan

Founder and CEO · GCheck

Many organizations can tell you exactly how fast they filled a role and how much it cost. Far fewer can tell you whether the person they hired turned out to be who and what the process said they were. LinkedIn’s 2025 Future of Recruiting report found that 89% of talent acquisition professionals now consider quality of hire increasingly important, yet only 25% feel confident their organization can actually measure it effectively.

That gap has an answer sitting inside every company right now, and almost no one asks for it. In my experience building screening programs, I have rarely seen an organization turn to its own employees and ask whether hiring feels rigorous. The tools measure process. The people measure outcome, and the space between the two is where risk actually lives.

Employees already have a verdict on this, and leadership rarely asks to hear it.

When you measure speed, not hire quality

In my experience, every industry leans on the same three numbers: time-to-fill, cost-per-hire, and sometimes a 90-day retention figure filling in for quality of hire. All three answer whether the machine ran. None of them answers what it produced.

A fast, cheap hiring process feels efficient even when it says nothing about whether the person hired matched the profile that got them through the door.

GCheck’s The Rise of the Shadow Workforce report, a survey of 1,500 employed U.S. adults, puts a figure on the gap. Only 14% believe their employer is doing enough to verify workers today. Fewer than one in four say they are very confident their employer would catch someone who significantly misrepresented their identity, skills, or experience.

I think that a confidence gap this wide, from the people closest to the outcome, is a warning sign. In practice, it usually starts small: a reference check skipped under deadline pressure, a credential taken at face value because the role needed filling fast. Nothing goes wrong that week, so the shortcut becomes the habit.

Nobody notices, because nothing broke, until a manager starts quietly routing the important work around a hire who should never have cleared the bar. That is the gap showing up, months after the shortcut that caused it.

Employees want more verification, not less

It would be easy to read those numbers as employees venting about their employer. That reading misses something important. Low confidence in a system and demand for a better one are separate findings, and the same survey captured both.

Our survey found that 78% of employees strongly support stronger skills and identity verification. Alongside the confidence numbers, that figure reads as appetite rather than resignation.

I suspect employees resist arbitrary or absent processes, not verification itself. A weak hiring process rarely shows up as a line item anywhere. It shows up as the teammate who quietly reworks a colleague’s numbers before a client sees them, or the one who stops handing off a task because the last time cost them a weekend fixing it.

A bigger danger is an unchecked process

The same research surfaced more dramatic findings, too, including coworkers who suspect they are not working alongside whom they think they are. Those findings draw attention for good reason, and they describe the rare, extreme end of the problem.

The confidence gap and the demand for stronger checks describe something far more common. LinkedIn’s own numbers point in the same direction: an overwhelming majority of talent leaders already treat quality of hire as a top priority, and three out of four still cannot measure it with any confidence. That split is the standard condition in many companies, and it can be fixed without drama.

What leaders can do next

If employees already have a view on whether hiring is rigorous, the fastest and cheapest diagnostic is to ask them directly, rather than waiting for the next engagement survey cycle to surface the same thing months later.

Three approaches worth considering:

  1. Ask a direct question instead of a proxy. Most engagement surveys lean on indirect measures. Gallup’s own research explains that one of its most recognized engagement items, whether an employee has a best friend at work, functions as a proxy for trust rather than a direct question about it. Hiring confidence deserves the same honesty in reverse: Ask plainly whether employees believe new hires were verified as rigorously as they were.
  2. Separate the confidence question from the policy question. An organization can run a fully compliant screening program and still employ a workforce that does not trust it. Those are distinct problems with distinct fixes, and I have watched leaders spend months solving the policy problem while the confidence problem sits untouched.
  3. Treat the answer as a leading indicator rather than a lagging one. A confidence gap tends to surface in how people talk about their teams months before it surfaces in turnover data or a costly bad hire.

None of this requires new software or an outside consultant. It requires asking a question most organizations have never thought to ask.

The best audit of a hiring process rarely comes from a new one. It comes from the workforce that already lived through it and has been waiting to be asked what it saw.

Houman Akhavan is the founder and CEO at GCheck.