Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your marketing growth problem starts with organizational design

Marketing falters when you have a gap between strategy and execution.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Jason Greenwood

Chief Marketing & Strategy Officer · Delta Dental of Arizona

When a founder or growth-stage CEO tells me their marketing feels too tactical—or that spend keeps climbing while growth becomes unpredictable—they usually assume they’re looking at a marketing problem.

They’re often looking at something else entirely.

What feels like marketing failure is often an organizational design problem. There is a gap between what leaders ask the marketing team to do and what they expect it to achieve.

Somewhere in the scaling journey, marketing becomes the function responsible for promoting decisions instead of helping shape them. Executives unintentionally seat the function at the kids’ table, then wonder why it never becomes the strategic growth partner they hoped for.

EVOLUTION OF THE DOWNSTREAM TRAP

This structural mismatch is rarely intentional. Most CEOs genuinely value marketing and want it to succeed. The gap occurs because companies build organizations for the stage of growth they just survived, rather than the one they’re trying to enter. While every company eventually outgrows its org chart, few recognize when yesterday’s seating arrangement begins limiting tomorrow’s growth.

In the earliest days of a business, this downstream model is a sound instinct. Operations, finance, product, and sales naturally dominate the conversation because survival depends on swift execution. In that environment, marketing functions effectively as a megaphone, communicating decisions that have already been made so the company can move quickly.

The challenge is that many organizations never redesign that model as they grow, when competitive advantage increasingly depends on making better strategic choices. As a company scales, upstream decisions become more complex—and more consequential. This next level of growth requires a different type of thinking that asks questions like:

  • Which customers should we pursue?
  • What products should we build next?
  • How should we price them?
  • What experience will differentiate us?

Few functions are closer to the intersection of customer behavior, market dynamics, and commercial outcomes than a well-designed marketing team. That’s precisely why marketing’s voice matters upstream and not after the fact.

If marketing remains isolated from those choices, it becomes the team brought in late to package decisions that were already made. The result is that companies unintentionally give marketing the influence of a communications team while holding it accountable like a growth engine. That’s a structural mismatch no CMO can outwork.

WHEN YOU MISTAKE ACTIVITY FOR VALUE

Founders and growth-stage CEOs are, by nature, action-oriented idea machines. That’s one of the reasons they’ve been so successful—they see opportunities everywhere and possess an extraordinary bias toward execution. Thank God for these people.

The problem is that when marketing has been designed primarily as a delivery function, every new idea becomes another assignment. Launch this. Promote that. It becomes the tactical end of the business instead of a strategic advisor. Over time, it optimizes for execution because that’s what the organization has repeatedly asked it to do.

Tactical creativity isn’t inherently bad. But without a coherent strategy to govern, it becomes disconnected busywork rather than work that compounds value over time. Resources become fragmented, competing priorities emerge, teams lose focus, and marketing becomes hyperactive without becoming any more strategic.

Activity is easy to observe. Value creation is much harder.

Great marketing leadership channels entrepreneurial energy. It introduces discipline without extinguishing creativity and decisiveness. It asks questions like:

  • What problem are we solving?
  • What customer behavior are we trying to change?
  • How does this fit our strategy?
  • What are we choosing not to do?

An effective strategy is measured by how consistently leadership chooses the few initiatives that matter most and how those initiatives define success.

DIAGNOSE THE SYSTEM BEFORE THE TURNSTILE

When growth becomes unpredictable, it’s completely natural for a CEO to question the person in the chair and ask, “Do I have the right marketing leader?” While talent mismatches happen, looking at the person before the system risks creating a dysfunctional and expensive cycle—a CMO turnstile that repeatedly swaps leaders into a seat that was never engineered to succeed in the first place.

Before you replace the leader, cut investment, or micromanage execution, step back and audit the structural seat you have built. Ask yourself four simple questions.

  1. Role: Was marketing expected to help shape the growth strategy—or simply communicate it?
  2. Participation: Was marketing included when the business’s most important growth decisions were made?
  3. Authority: Was marketing given meaningful influence over the outcomes it was expected to deliver?
  4. Measurement: Was marketing measured using metrics that connected to enterprise value?

If the answers to these questions are consistently no, you’re probably facing an expectations problem rather than a talent problem. To fix it, leadership should redesign the seat before it evaluates the person sitting in it. Otherwise, organizations risk hiring increasingly talented CMOs into the same role and wondering why each one eventually misses the mark.

BETTER DECISIONS, NOT BETTER MARKETING

When companies finally redesign the seat, the entire business shifts. Marketing doesn’t simply produce better campaigns—it also helps the business make better decisions.

Customer insight shapes products before they’re launched, pricing reflects the value proposition and competitive differentiation, and customer experience becomes more intentional. Sales, operations, finance, and marketing begin solving the same growth problems instead of optimizing each function.

The result is something every CEO can feel because the strategy becomes coherent, investment decisions become clearer, and growth becomes more systematic. The goal was never to elevate marketing, just the quality of decisions that create growth.

You don’t get the marketing function you wish you had—you get the one you design for.

Jason Greenwood is the chief marketing and strategy officer at Delta Dental of Arizona.