Consider a finance system that gets 99% of its results right. Across 100,000 transactions, that still leaves 1,000 errors, and in finance a single error can affect a customer’s balance, a supplier’s payment, a reported result, or a business decision made with confidence in the numbers.
The debate about AI in finance often focuses on whether it will replace entry-level accountants. A more urgent question is whether finance teams are preparing people to catch the errors, and whether those people will still get the chance to build the judgment to do it.
A polished result earns trust quickly, and that is the risk. An answer can be internally consistent and still miss the context that makes it unsafe to approve. The reviewer is the last human checkpoint before that result moves forward. That checkpoint only works when the person reviewing the output has the knowledge and authority to question it.
A payment may match an open invoice by amount and reference number while belonging to a different customer account, reflecting a changed contract or conflicting with how the business handled the same issue in a prior period. The system’s output may not show the difference. Recognizing it takes someone who understands the data, the process, and its history.
That is what makes human review a real control: the ability to connect a result to the operating context and recognize when something does not make sense.
Give reviewers what they need to judge
Review cannot be reduced to clicking “approve.”
A qualified reviewer needs access to source records, a clear explanation of the recommendation, and visibility into what changed from prior activity. They also need enough process knowledge to distinguish an ordinary variation from an exception that deserves attention. Software training alone does not prepare someone to do that well.
Reviewers need data fluency, accounting and process knowledge, and familiarity with how the organization works. They need to understand how a transaction affects customers, suppliers, reporting, and downstream activity. They also need clear authority to hold, question, or escalate an output without being seen as an obstacle to efficiency. If challenging an output slows a reviewer’s metrics, the control is already broken.
Match review depth to the consequences of an error. Sample routine, familiar tasks, with automated checks behind the sample to flag anything unusual, and review every exception. Require full sign-off on new transaction types, unusual adjustments, and any action with a direct external impact. The amount of review should reflect both the risk and the novelty of the work.
This approach keeps reviewers focused on evaluating evidence and deciding whether an output can proceed. It also makes human judgment part of the process, rather than a final click.
Preserve the path to expertise
Concerns about entry-level jobs are usually framed as a headcount problem. They are also a judgment problem. A 2026 field study of AI use in accounting found that greater AI use was associated with less time spent on routine data entry, while more experienced accountants were more likely to intervene when AI signaled uncertainty.
Reconciliations, journal preparation, and first-pass variance analysis include repetitive work. Those tasks also teach people how transactions move, where systems fail to agree, and what a reasonable result looks like. That experience builds the judgment needed to review more complex work. Automate that work without a plan, and the pipeline of future reviewers quietly dries up.
As automation takes on more of those tasks, organizations need new ways to develop that judgment. New finance professionals can examine AI-prepared work with experienced colleagues, trace recommendations to source records, investigate exceptions, and learn from a shared library of cases where a plausible result was wrong. Training should teach the reasoning behind accounting and process decisions, not just the steps in a tool.
Managers should build that learning into the workflow. Reviewers can talk through why they approved or challenged an output, how the decision affected a customer or supplier, and what evidence shaped the conclusion. Those conversations help people gain confidence in questioning results and give experienced staff a practical way to pass on what they know.
Learn from the errors reviewers catch
A reviewer’s challenge can reveal what the system missed. Was a source record incomplete? Had a business rule changed? Did the system miss relevant history or overlook a customer-specific detail?
Answers can point to problems in the data, process rules, training, or system behavior. Leaders can track the types of errors caught before they move downstream, how often reviewers intervene, and where exceptions keep recurring. Watch for the opposite signal, too: A reviewer who never challenges anything may be rubber-stamping, not confirming accuracy. Approval counts alone cannot tell the two apart.
Start here, then continue
Here’s where to begin your journey.
- Give reviewers source access, a clear explanation of each recommendation, and the authority to hold or escalate.
- Tier review by risk and novelty, and sample the routine, examine every exception, and require sign-off on anything new or external.
- Track interventions and recurring exceptions, not approvals alone.
As AI takes on more execution, review will concentrate on the cases where context matters most. That makes the reviewer’s judgment more consequential. Organizations should treat reviewer capability as part of their AI investment, with deliberate training, clear authority, and time to examine the work. Think of AI as a coworker whose work gets reviewed, not a system to be trusted on faith.
AI accuracy will continue to improve. But a result that looks right can still be wrong for a particular customer, transaction, or moment in the business. Leaders should measure system accuracy, but also ask who can recognize a mistake—and whether that person is prepared and empowered to stop it before it travels.
Darren Heffernan is CEO at Trintech.