Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Measuring brand identity in a cookieless future: Three questions every CMO should be asking

The winners of the future—brand marketers, agency pros, and data partners alike—all should continue revamping and testing strategies for a privacy-centric world.

Measuring brand identity in a cookieless future: Three questions every CMO should be asking

[Image Credits: peopleimages.com/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Patti Boyle

Chief Marketing Officer · Dstillery, Inc.

As marketers everywhere heard the news that Google was again delaying its sunsetting of third-party cookies until late 2024, you may have asked yourself, “How will we measure brand awareness and our market position in a cookieless future?” Even though Google has kicked the can down the road yet again, marketing leaders should still answer this question sooner rather than later. 

Historically, brand value has been tough to track. The advent of third-party cookies and opt-in panels finally gave the industry a quantifiable method to measure message impact and track brand progress across channels. Cookies have allowed marketers to personalize user experiences, recommend products, and increase sales, but increasing global policy impacts on privacy and security are leading to more questions for brands than answers. In light of this uncertainty, here are three questions every CMO should be asking.

QUESTION ONE: REPUTATION

Post-cookie, how do CMOs responsible for brand identity assess their brands’ reputations over time? 

Brand reputation is the perception customers, employees, partners, investors, and others have of a brand. In my experience, the stronger a brand’s reputation is, the more likely the brand engenders trust, preference, confidence, and advocacy. Unlike most measures of a brand’s strength, reputation is often influenced by external factors, including the media, current and emerging competitors, and those in the broader industry ecosystem. And therein lies the challenge. Unlike simply reaching out to customers, prospects, and other close-in members of a brand’s community, reputation is being built and shaped by so many aspects that no amount of data gets the job done.   

Beyond the obvious challenges for marketers in the quest to reach those online audiences, how do marketing leaders measure results for the brand reputations for which they’re responsible?  

Google’s decision to double down on user privacy is being met with everything from denial and apathy to frustration and panic across ad tech. The continuous delays may seem like a reprieve and an excuse to put off the search for a privacy-safe solution. But the writing is already on the wall—Google’s timeline no longer defines us. Marketers should employ a new strategy now.

Tech giants like Apple and Facebook (or Meta) are already strengthening the walls around their user data. This offers marketers a true glimpse into a very private future internet landscape. Meta even provides a specific look into its privacy progress report in a constantly updated platform.

Welcome to the age of Reality Reputation Reports. Just like reality TV, the answer lies in the starring roles of real people. Tech stacks today need a new set of armor in their toolbelts. As a CMO, check out platforms like G2 and Comparably and solutions such as Net Promoter and Ask Nicely. You can obtain fully consented, firsthand feedback in customers’ very own words.

QUESTION TWO: POSITION

How can I track brand positioning in a cookieless future?

As Al Ries and Jack Trout’s classic marketing text Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind explains, brand positioning is the place it occupies in the prospect’s mind. This presumes that a marketer can confidently identify who its customers and loyalists are; otherwise, how do they know they’re measuring what (and who) really matters for their brands? With the retirement of cookies, it begs the question: Did we ever need all of this data to tell us who our customers are? Is it sufficient and even more authentic to simply know how to reach audiences with specific characteristics and behaviors?

For years, marketers have relied on third-party cookie data to help them reach their best audiences—from ages and occupations to interests and locations. Gone are the days of focus groups, one-on-one interviews, and benchmark studies—at least the traditional types. Welcome to the age of consent, opt-in, and protected identity. 

How can you “listen” to your customers, “hear” your brand’s mentions, and stay ahead of increasing competition? Customer data is everywhere, even in the cookieless future, and even (especially) if you, as a marketer, don’t need to identify names, ranks, and serial numbers.  

QUESTION THREE: EQUITY

What’s the future of measuring brand equity in a more private world? 

Brand equity is the value an organization derives from its brand name awareness and recognition among its target market members and relevant influencers. Combining customer perception of a brand with a measurement of competitive superiority, brand equity impacts valuation, pricing, sales volume, and profitability. I believe assessing rather than guessing where your brand stands and where it’s headed is a vital, though seldom discussed, requirement of CMOs.

Looking to a cookieless future, experts encourage a shift to “a wider range of data sources and technology to discover consumer interests” and maintain cost-effectiveness, according to Marketing Week.

As marketing leaders are challenged over the next few years to shift digital advertising tools and marketing models, KPIs and brand measurement standards will also need a reboot. The winners of the future—brand marketers, agency pros, and data partners alike—all should continue revamping and testing strategies for a privacy-centric world.


Patti Boyle is the Chief Marketing Officer of Dstillery.