I’m fortunate to have had the opportunity to build teams from scratch four times now. Through trial and error, I evolved my leadership style to directly impact business results through my teams’ efforts. And the critical common denominator across those teams is that they consist of high performers.
“High performer” is largely a relative concept. But I think there are three core elements to recognizing these individuals: autonomy—they operate independently, with minimal direction in pursuit of a solution or goal; innovation—they don’t just think outside the box, but sometimes design an entirely new box because it suits the situation better; and critical thinking—they look beyond the immediate task to understand what came before, what’s next, and how it fits into the larger puzzle of your organization’s goals.
I believe someone embodying these characteristics is an invaluable addition to any team. But to best serve those employees who are doing their best work to serve the business, it may mean a shift in how you lead, manage, and operate.
DOS AND DON’TS
A team of high performers doesn’t think or perform the way I do. Their diversity of background and inclination is important to me. It’s also important to know where I can add value in guiding team performance and where I can add value by getting out of the way.
The first “don’t” for leading a high-performing team? Micromanagement. Don’t be overwrought in your request or subsequent direction. Avoid pedantic work by recognizing the value of independent thinking that can often lead to innovation.
The second “don’t” is under-resourcing. Secure the tools and develop processes that support a high-performing team and enable them to outperform. Recognize it’s a matter of scale depending on the organization’s size/maturity and adjust accordingly.
A third “don’t” is intolerance. If someone asks questions for context, they’re gathering data to solve your problem. Remember it’s about the bigger picture and not about challenging you, your thinking, or your authority.
LET GO IN ORDER TO GO FURTHER
To my mind, fear is the enemy of good management, causing you to operate in a way opposite to your intentions. Effectively leading high performers means laying a foundation and, as I’ve mentioned before, stepping aside to let others take the reins. This frees you to pursue other priorities and reinforces your team’s stake in a successful outcome.
There are three key principles to successfully delegating to your high performers:
1. Acceptance. Focus on the outcome. There’s the adage about the importance of the journey, but with work, it’s about the destination. Understand and trust that a different way of doing things can also be a better way of doing things.
2. Context. If you only provide 10% of the context, you’re only going to get 10% of the desired result. Provide all the information someone needs to come up with the best solution, not just the quickest or most obvious one.
3. Communication. Be open to questions and points of view that reflect a different understanding and provide constructive feedback on your observations. Communication is a two-way street that’s about demonstrating respect as much as it’s about providing clarity.
KNOW WHAT YOU DON’T KNOW
For my first CMO role, I transitioned from agency to client-side. The shift in the nature of the work was one thing. Moving from a senior role to a top role with all the responsibility for marketing, communications, and editorial was quite another.
At the time, I thought I was effectively leveraging my incredible staff. I wasn’t. I had my hand in everything. With six levels of people between me and the Twitter copywriter, I still poured over those tweets because that was my reaction to the weight sitting on my shoulders.
Then someone I’d hired asked if I was open to her feedback. She had more experience than me, and in that moment, it was about choosing to listen and accept I didn’t have all the answers. Our three-hour discussion highlighted the lack of value in how I was operating and what I was missing in what my team could bring to the table.
The following week I acknowledged my mistakes in a meeting and asked my colleagues to hold me accountable. That kind of open, two-way culture is one I’ve tried to cultivate in every role since.
MAKE STRATEGIC INVESTMENTS
Another thing I’ve worked to cultivate is talent. Though it may seem prudent to develop teams from the ground up, I’ve learned the value of hiring senior roles first. Experienced leadership helps serve the organization’s end goals more immediately and can help identify and nurture that pipeline of high performers.
Author, educator, and leadership development expert Dr. Ruth Gotian has noted that high performers aren’t born—they’re made. Yet we focus considerable energy on those performing below average. My experience at Netflix, however, showed me that investing in strong existing talent reaps incredible dividends.
That doesn’t mean the pendulum should swing fully either way. If high performers are a matter of nurture over nature, you should accommodate the will to grow as a contributor with the appropriate opportunities. And work to not only build up but also protect your investment in your contributors. That means not equating output with capacity. To prevent burnout, I constantly check on the status of my teammates and encourage them to be honest about their capabilities.
No one goes into team leadership thinking, “I’d like to be terrible at this.” But if you’re closed off or operating from a place of doubt or fear, it can have a domino effect. Transparency is key. I want my team to know about my uncertainty or discomfort in case it impacts my behavior. I want them to share their thoughts and fears, too, so we can work through it together.
Most importantly, I want to create a culture that empowers my colleagues to do the same with their high-performing teams. That’s an incredible legacy for leadership. And a much more positive example of the ultimate power of the domino effect on your organization’s success.
Peter Sloterdyk is CMO of Athena, the mission-based service firm pairing Philippines-based EAs with C-Suite leaders across four continents.