In one minute and 10 seconds, the video “A Prompt for Ukraine” highlights the limitations of AI to call attention to the impact of the devastating war in Ukraine, marking one year since the invasion began. Developed by the award-winning, data-driven creative agency Performance Art, in partnership with their client, the non-profit Humanitarian Coalition, the video prompts people to donate funds to help Ukrainians—but not in the way you might think.
The provocative video centers on a conversation with an AI not unlike ChatGPT, asking it about the ongoing war in Ukraine. In a surprising reveal, the AI chat demonstrates that the algorithm’s language model was trained on a data set that ends September 2021—before the war began. It has no knowledge, understanding or ability to ingest this new information about the war. The conversation on the video continues with prompts that ask about places like Kyiv and Mariupol, as well as what the daily life of Ukrainians is like. The chatbot’s responses underscore that, with two-year-old training data, the world’s most popular chatbot knows nothing about the war. The video ends with a final prompt: a call to action to donate to the Humanitarian Coalition.
USING THE ABSENCE OF INFORMATION TO INSPIRE MEANINGFUL ACTION
To capitalize on ChatGPT’s firm position in the zeitgeist of the moment, the team at Performance Art decided to use the technology’s data gap to bring attention back to Ukraine.
“The fact that the world’s most popular AI chatbot is essentially unaware that there’s even a war happening in Ukraine is pretty mind-blowing,” says Performance Art founder and CEO Andrea Cook. “We’re all excited about the possibilities that AI unlocks, but we also must recognize the pitfalls.”
The AI chatbot’s responses—or more accurately, the lack thereof—are a case study in how what’s not there in data can be more telling than what is.
“We are trained as a species, and certainly as an industry, to look for consistencies and commonalities in data,” explains Cook. “And sometimes, you need to look for the absence of things or the lack of correlation between things to find the real insights or meaning. The problem for Ukraine is the absence of something, and we’re using the absence of information to create something—in this case, a call to action to donate.”
LIVING (AND LEARNING) AT THE INTERSECTION OF DATA, AI AND CREATIVITY
“A Prompt for Ukraine” is Performance Art’s latest social impact campaign, but not its first. The agency has a track record of driving social change via the intersection of data, AI, and creativity.
One of the most famous examples in the agency’s portfolio is the data-driven travel platform, “The Black Elevation Map,” created for Black & Abroad, a travel and lifestyle company focused on Black travelers. The interactive map pulls from more than 330 million points of cultural data to create an immersive digital experience that reimagines the American landscape by visualizing the heights of Black culture on a dynamic elevation map. The greater the density of that data, the higher the elevation on the map. The Black Elevation Map highlights thousands of places that showcase Black culture. Notably, in its 12 city guides and 10 national guides, people can explore Black-owned wineries (“Melanin Vines”), influential startup companies (“Black Silicon Valley”) and restaurants that were at the center of civil rights (“Civil Bites”).
“We work with data in all forms and formats all day, every day,” Cook notes. “But the fact is that all data has biases, so you have to dig in and look for and understand those biases—and then establish more deliberate and inclusive biases. In the case of The Black Elevation Map, we recognized that maps are not unbiased location guides; they are influenced by what mapmakers choose to include and exclude. This work is transparent and purposeful in how we biased the data to tell the story in favor of Black culture. In a way, the bias is the story.”
The Black Elevation Map was one of the most awarded campaigns on the global stage in the past year, winning gold at the Cannes Lions awards, being named “2022 Campaign of the Year” at the Campaign US BIG Awards and winning the highest honor at the Drum Awards, the “Grand Prix of Grand Prix.”
When asked about the responsibility of brands and organizations to do work that supports social good, Cook explains, “Everyone has a role to play in making the world a better place. I think the special gift of our industry is to use creativity to solve not just business problems but, whenever possible, broader world problems. While we work hard on our clients’ businesses, we also very purposefully carve out time to devote some of our energy and our gifts toward ideas that have the power to impact the greater good.”
HOW AI FITS INTO THE FUTURE OF MARKETING
Cook says that at Performance Art, “Virtually everything we do relies on some form of AI, whether that’s for basic versioning or something incredibly complex.” She notes that even the fundamentals of individualization and automation—such as the technology that powers the CRM systems many marketing departments use—rely on a relatively simple form of AI.
As for the friction between people and AI?
“To us, it’s not a question of human versus machine or whether humanity is involved or not,” says Cook. “Humanity has to be involved because AI, at least for now, is limited. It’s only as useful as the abilities of the person using it and the data set within.”
She credits her creative partner and Performance Art’s Chief Creative Officer, Ian Mackenzie, with coining the idea of “high prompt fidelity”—which is where her agency is focused right now. AI outcomes, she explains, are only as good as the questions people ask.
“Our team is spending a lot of time honing our prompt skills and solving for data limitations and biases,” she says. “We are having a lot of fun and success playing in generative creativity and understanding how we might use tools like Midjourney or DALL-E to get to the new and perhaps uncharted places we want to go.”
Cook emphasizes that these new technologies are game-changing.
“It’s a once- or twice-in-a-generation sea change we’re experiencing,” she says. “As a team, we’re working hard to learn it as it emerges, putting it into fast and powerful use for our clients.”