Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What every company can learn from customer experience pros

The list ranks the 300 brands that actual consumers (more than 120,000 of them) in the U.S. said they view the most positively in terms of products, services, and treatment of customers. To Goffe, there’s plenty that companies can learn from three of the brands that nabbed top 10 rankings: Buc-ee’s (ranked first), In-N-Out Burger (fifth), and Chewy (eighth).

[Courtesty of Gretchen Goffe]

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

Which company offers the best customer experience in the United States? According to Forbes’ debut list, “Customer Experience All-Stars,” created in partnership with data analytics company HundredX and published in February 2023, it’s Buc-ee’s, a convenience store chain headquartered in Texas with less than 100 locations in the southern United States.

Surprised? According to Gretchen Goffe, CEO and founder of DTLiveLAB, a consultancy that helps C-suite leaders engage their organizations to deliver on customer experience (CX) strategies, Buc-ee’s number-one spot wasn’t an aberration—other regionals won top rankings against national, better-funded competitors. 

“In the experience economy, the kind of love customers have for these regional companies is something every business should aspire to,” says Goffe. 

The list ranks the 300 brands that actual consumers (more than 120,000 of them) in the U.S. said they view the most positively in terms of products, services, and treatment of customers.

To Goffe, there’s plenty that companies can learn from three of the brands that nabbed top 10 rankings: Buc-ee’s (ranked first), In-N-Out Burger (fifth), and Chewy (eighth). 

“They each delight customers with distinct strategies that play to their strengths, instead of adopting an ‘everything, everywhere all at once’ strategy,” she explains. “Much of the CX conversation has been centered on digital transformation, but these ‘all-stars’ show how differentiating on something that matters to their customers beyond the digital experience can win loyalty and preference.” 

These three companies, she notes, go beyond what’s expected in their category to delight customers in one area. 

“They each put a stake in the ground and said, ‘this would delight our customers,’ versus ‘this would sell more,’” says Goffe. “Interestingly, the loyalty and love these ‘people over profits’ moves generate translates into revenue, so everyone wins.”

BUC-EE’S: DELIGHTING WHERE IT’S LEAST EXPECTED

Forbes contributor Rachel Rabkin Peachman explained that while Buc-ee’s is “praised for its friendly employees, massive layouts, wide variety of merchandise, and food,” it’s the chain’s “clean and spacious bathrooms” that won it the number one spot on the list. In fact, consider what one survey respondent said, as quoted in the Forbes article: “‘I’ve never seen a convenience store associated with shopping for gas that has artwork for sale in the entrance to the bathrooms—it’s like walking through an art gallery just to use the toilet.’” 

According to Goffe, what Buc-ee’s understands about its customers is that when they choose where to stop on a road trip, restrooms are a big factor, along with food and convenience. Clearly, their customers agree.

“If your business has physical channels, ask what experience would create not just a good experience, say a 7/10, but push it off the charts to a 10/10—the kind of fantastic experience customers would cite or tell others about,” says Goffe. “Rethink assumptions about the way things are to see the way they could be; think about things that would delight customers and set you apart in your category. Then, take that answer and turn it into a fabulous differentiator. That kind of intimate understanding of your customers feels like a gift given by someone who knows them.”

She notes, however, that this type of strategy relies on flawless execution. 

“If a business has multiple locations, each location must understand and implement the strategy 100% of the time,” says Goffe. “Ensure everyone at the organization feels what your customers feel and is committed to delivering great service, and you’ll create a hallmark for your brand in consumers’ minds.” 

CHEWY: EMPATHY FOR PET PARENTS

According to Packaged Facts’ U.S. Pet Market Outlook 2021-2022 report, Amazon led online sales of pet products at 59%, and e-commerce pet supply company Chewy came in at 41%. 

Goffe explains that the digital shopping experience is a table stakes for Chewy. But given Amazon’s financial resources, Chewy likely won’t “out digital” the online retail giant. So how does a digital firm win against a better-funded competitor?

“Chewy has chosen to win their one-to-one customer interactions with extreme empathy,” says Goffe. “Combining that empathy with action secured them the eighth spot on the list. The stories of Chewy’s legendary care for pet parents who have lost a pet have gone viral for good reason.” 

She notes that to win this type of strategy, corporate leaders can do two things. 

“First, instead of letting each person figure out how to turn friction into something fabulous on their own, use training to expand ‘available freedoms,’ crowdsource ideas, and build playbooks to operationalize this way of working,” says Goffe. “Second, trust employees to deliver delight in the moments that matter most.”  

IN-N-OUT BURGER: SERVING UP A BETTER BURGER EXPERIENCE

Walk into an In-N-Out Burger, and you’ll get tasty burgers and great service. The fast-food chain doesn’t offer many items on its menu, but its team members know how to cook and serve the items it does offer in a way that delights customers. 

While many companies are product-centric, In-N-Out is known for how well it treats its employees and customers alike. A 2022 consumer study showed that the company beat its competitors on quality, service, and cleanliness (QSC). It received “82 percent for food quality, 88 percent for staff friendliness, and 85 percent for cleanliness.” A clue as to what contributes? The company pays its employees well, with store managers receiving an average annual salary of over $160,000.

“It’s no surprise that In-N-Out ranked fifth on the Forbes list,” says Goffe. “They have instilled a feeling of ownership in their employees; their employees understand that they are delivering a burger experience, not just a burger, to each customer. Their ranking shows that their customers feel it, too.”

To Goffe, In-N-Out is a prime example of how the employee experience is connected to the customer experience. Simply put, employees who receive good treatment from their employers are more likely to provide good treatment to customers. Gallup found that business units with high engagement levels “achieve a 10% difference in customer ratings and an 18% difference in sales.” Plus, consumers value brands that treat their employees well. Per Jobcase’s Retail Worker Appreciation study, six out of 10 consumers “said they are more likely to shop with a company that treats its employees well.” 

“When expecting employees to go the extra mile and continually offer empathy for customers, business leaders should make sure their employees are receiving the same from them,” says Goffe.