Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How and when to know to close a business

Understanding which of these challenges you’re facing may help to navigate the situation so that the outcome is something other than turning off the lights.

"Sorry, we're closed" sign

[Images: Adobe Stock / supamotion]

Profile photo of Nathaniel Heller

Vice President and Managing Director · Geneva Global

Recently, a non-profit organization I co-founded 18 years ago and led for nearly a decade announced it was shutting its doors at the end of 2023. The decision to close was not one the organization preferred; rather, a lack of philanthropic funding had forced its hand, and there was insufficient time to pull off a strategic pivot.

Underlying the board of directors’ decision to shutter was the reality that the core services the organization offered were no longer “in demand” from the private foundations and other donors that historically supported the organization financially. It was sad news all around, and something I personally regretted.

Digesting the news forced me to think more deeply about the reasons organizations and businesses choose (or are forced) to shut down. So much of organizational and business leadership theory and practice tacitly center on the notions of indefinite growth and success. It’s less common to read case studies of when and how leaders decided to intentionally plateau or even sunset a business unit, never mind an entire company or organization.

We need more of that “real talk” to help boards and leadership teams navigate challenging existential moments. In the real world, growth is never a given and hard times ultimately confront nearly every business, regardless of size or historical success.

While the following list isn’t exhaustive, there are at least three categories of triggers that often force businesses and organizations to wind down. Understanding which of these challenges you’re facing may help to navigate the situation so that the outcome is something other than turning off the lights.

PRODUCT-MARKET MISALIGNMENT

Put simply, if no one wants to buy what you’re selling, you’re likely in a bad place regardless of whether you’re running a business or nonprofit organization. In the commercial world, any number of basic metrics tell business leaders and managers when things are going wrong: declining revenue, poor customer satisfaction numbers, and dropping sales figures.

In the social impact and nonprofit world, it’s surprisingly harder and not nearly as automatic to diagnose a product-market failure. This is due to the disconnect between the “consumers” of social impact work (e.g. target communities and individuals) and the payors of the work (usually, philanthropists and everyday donors like you and me).

Sometimes payors keep paying even if the consumers don’t need or want the organization’s products or services, and vice versa. Despite that real dysfunction in social impact feedback loops, eventually, reality does catch up with most organizations, like my previous nonprofit.

The typical remedy for product-market misalignment is the classic strategic pivot: abandoning low-demand products and services for something the market is willing to buy more readily and/or at higher margins. Time, cost, and know-how remain major barriers to successfully pulling off a strategic pivot, but it’s possible, and there are myriad examples to learn from.

FAILURES OF LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT

Sometimes, the product is great, but the business or organization is being run so poorly that even the tightest product-market fit can’t overcome internal dysfunction. I suspect most of us have been around an organization that simply can’t get out of its own way.

If left unchecked, that dysfunction can ultimately run businesses into the ground. Margins evaporate and staff morale erodes to a point that triggers a talent exodus, forcing a wind-down in the most severe cases. This vicious cycle can be challenging to overcome short of a leadership overhaul; it’s the role of boards (or business owners) to ultimately take the tough decision to implement a leadership change, no matter the optics.

Besides the obvious cure of a change in leadership, the other path many boards ultimately embrace is a merger or acquisition. If the product-market fit is still there but held back by poor leadership, an acquiring organization will find value in the company knowing they can run the place better.   

COMPETITIVE PRESSURES

Apart from product challenges and leadership dysfunction, a third common trigger for business shutdowns is traditional competitive pressures. These can be especially acute in commodity-like industries or sectors where product or service differentiation is challenging. If you’re selling widgets and the place next door can sell the same widget for less, you have a problem.

In these industries, smart marketing, supply chain creativity, cost management efforts, and investing in customer loyalty are ways to combat competitive pressures, but none are a panacea (and all require investments of capital that may be in short supply).

For organizations and businesses facing severe competitive pressures, there are additional structural ways to avoid a race to the bottom on price (which can often serve as a death knell for the company). Diversification efforts are one way out of the conundrum by bolstering balance sheets with new products or services that aren’t as susceptible to price wars and fierce competition. Like strategic pivots, product or service diversification requires significant time and capital, but it can help businesses rescue themselves before needing to call it quits.

For organizations and businesses facing an uncertain economic climate in 2024, being mindful of these shutdown triggers may help to proactively avoid the worst of the pain points. At a minimum, understanding which solutions are fit for purpose for the different types of pressures can give leaders and their boards the ability to control their own destinies, rather than feel they are at the mercy of larger, uncontrollable market forces.


Nathaniel Heller is Vice President & Managing Director at Geneva Global overseeing the firm’s support to philanthropists and foundations.