Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why brand communities are the future of social strategy

The future of social strategy prioritizes retention, identity, and shared experiences rather than virality.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Monica Hickey

VP of Growth, The Evoke Agency · The Evoke Agency

One of the biggest things changing in social media marketing is the shift from virality to building brand communities. For many years, brands decided their social media strategy based on engagement and algorithms. It is now clear that virality does not build loyalty, trust, or meaningful relationships, even if it generates short-term attention.

Consumers are overwhelmed by the volume of content competing for their attention, and brands are seeing lower returns on performance-driven campaigns. This is especially true for Gen Z, a demographic that is more skeptical of traditional advertising and overly polished or promotional content. They are looking for spaces where they can share their identities without engaging with brands transactionally. In this environment, a post might perform well for a while, but this attention is not long-lasting. That is why community-building is emerging as a response.

WHAT IS BRAND COMMUNITY?

A brand community goes beyond a large audience, an active comment section, or encouraging user-generated content. It is a group of people who interact with one another around a shared identity and who maintain relationships with a brand through participation in special places, rather than passive content consumption. These spaces engage people over time by combining social media, private or semi-private groups, and even offline events. By offering different ways for people to connect, brands do not have to depend only on social media or short bursts of attention.

The difference between virality and community is the difference between being seen and being remembered. Viral content spreads quickly and reaches many people without context or follow-up. On the contrary, communities rely on shared norms and a sense of belonging, giving people a reason to return and participate. It is a different type of relationship, one that lasts, which, in turn, changes how brands measure success. This difference is important because it separates community from metrics that do not generate a real connection.

NEW METRICS FOR SUCCESS

A common concern with this approach is that community-focused content delivers lower numbers than viral posts. But key performance indicators (KPIs) solely based on volume will miss key metrics, such as loyalty. Community-building strategies focus on retention, ongoing participation, deeper interactions, and brand advocacy. These metrics are harder to see, but they are better indicators of a strong brand community than impressions or likes. Since this strategy is about long-term results, its value shows up over time.

ASOS is a good example of what this looks like. Through its loyalty program, the brand has moved away from only offering discounts or tracking how often people buy. Instead, they focus on giving members early access to products, event invitations, and chances to give feedback, which helps build a sense of closeness. As the brand has explained, the goal is not simply to keep customers buying, but to create a relationship that grows over time.

e.l.f. Cosmetics is a different but complementary technique. The brand is building community on social media, particularly on TikTok. They are using repeatable cultural moments, such as original sounds, challenges, creator storylines, and interactive shopping experiences, to drive affinity-based engagement. From there, they identify active participants and invite them into deeper, more intimate spaces where relationships can develop over time. This strategy allows e.l.f. to continue using the platforms Gen Z already uses without over relying on visibility.

What connects both strategies is that both brands treat community as infrastructure, rather than a campaign. In ASOS’s case, the ecosystem centers on membership and access. In e.l.f.’s case, it centers on cultural participation and shared creativity. In both cases, the emphasis is on creating repeated touchpoints and shared experiences instead of chasing isolated moments of attention.

Community building has its challenges. Results are less immediately visible and require ongoing investment in moderation, content, and relationship management. Communities also reduce brand control, as members can question decisions, offer criticism, or disengage publicly. Most importantly, communities require consistency. A brand cannot operate in ways that contradict its values, making authenticity a requirement. But the fact that it is difficult to be consistent is what makes community-building more credible.

LOOKING AHEAD

In this way, focusing on communities instead of viral moments is not just about changing tactics; it is about a broader shift in how brands build trust, identity, and value online. Social media should be an entry point into deeper brand spaces rather than one-off posts.

Once brands find their most engaged fans, they must guide them into spaces where deeper interaction can take place through repeatable formats and rituals, such as loyalty programs, private groups, live events, or other semi-private spaces.

Community does not replace social media, but it does mean social media becomes a gateway, not the end goal. As social platforms continue to evolve, the community provides brands with a steadier base for marketing in 2026 and beyond.

Monica Hickey is the senior vice president at The Evoke Agency and cofounder of TheTease Media.