The confluence of artificial intelligence, the attention economy, and zero-click shopping has compelled brands to look beyond traditional advertising to focus on building earned customer loyalty. While customer loyalty is as old as commerce itself, driving loyalty demands an entirely new playbook.
Brands are faced with a paradox: They are investing billions in loyalty programs and yet 40% of consumers continue to abandon them. The primary reason for consumers’ rejection: rewards take too long to earn.
A recent survey of loyalty program users, conducted by Fetch, a reward app, and published by Digitas, looks at what drives sustained engagement and causes churn. The results challenge conventional wisdom about gamification, personalization, and generational targeting.
Speed, simplicity, and trust are non-negotiable
Modern loyalty isn’t built on points and perks alone. Loyalty rests on a set of principles that reflect a more personal, intimate relationship between a brand and its most valued patrons. That closeness is built on satisfying these consumers’ unique needs today, tomorrow, and well into the future, especially as brands are better equipped with the data to anticipate and refine desired services that evolve with its audience’s changing mindsets. Our research reveals three fundamental requirements that transcend demographics and program types.
1. Speed matters more than ever
Ninety percent of consumers expect rewards to accumulate quickly—and for Gen Z that urgency is even sharper with 79% naming speed to reward as a top priority. Brands that can’t keep pace risk losing customers before they’ve even gotten started.
When rewards take too long to earn, consumers jump ship. In fact, slow rewards are the number one driver of churn at 40%.
2. Simplicity is essential
Eighty-seven percent of patrons demand programs that are simple to understand and use. When a consumer is in a checkout line or shopping online, their patience is already being tested. They aren’t in a mood to calculate point conversions. They want to know: What do I get? How fast can I get it?
3. Trust is table stakes
While trust has always been important, it appears that brands take engendering credibility for granted too often. For instance, 87% say data protection is critical when joining a loyalty program. This concern increases as customers age with 94% of Baby Boomers saying data protection is extremely important. This means brands need to clearly show what customer data is used, why it’s being used, and what value it delivers back to the consumer.
The gamification myth
For years, loyalty advocates have preached gamification is the secret sauce. Leaderboards, badges, streaks, challenges—the theory was that adding game-like elements would drive engagement. Our research shows that isn’t the case.
Just 2% of consumers identify as “competitors” who love streaks, leaderboards, and challenges. The loyalty personalities we uncovered are all value-driven, not game-driven:
- Minimalists, who love simplicity and obvious value with no clutter, at 19%
- Loyalists, who enjoy sticking with a few trusted favorite brands or programs, at 18%
- Strategists, who thrive on maximizing and stacking rewards across platforms, at 15%
The emotional connection driving loyalty is tied to rewards, not gamification. While 63% of respondents cite “excitement when earning rewards,” as their emotional connection, it’s the reward itself that matters, not the game mechanics around it. Fifty-seven percent connect emotionally through surprise bonuses and 76% love finding creative ways to save money. These are functional motivators, not playful ones.
This doesn’t mean programs should be sterile or boring. There’s still a role for what I call “guiding progress.” By providing information, you can elicit satisfaction and reduce frustrations simply by managing expectations. Features like a progress bar showing time to the next reward, micro-celebrations for hitting a milestone, and stack-and-swap feedback clarifying value by allowing users to see how mixing and matching rewards across programs adds up, making the value of their choices immediately visible.
These elements help users understand their progress and accelerate their path to rewards. Users don’t want games for games’ sake. They want in-app tools that make earning feel achievable.
Personalization requires permission
While there’s healthy skepticism about AI in consumer experiences, the picture is less dire than feared. Fifty-five percent of consumers are open to AI personalization; just 18% are uncomfortable with it.
Again, it comes down to trust. Fifty-six percent are willing to share additional personal details such as age, family status, interests, and general shopping preferences to earn better rewards. However, only 30% will share basic identifying attributes such as email address and birth date.
To ease this problem, brands should default to basics-only data collection and offer a clear value exchange for any additional sharing. Consider implementing what we call a Privacy Ledger—a running account of what data is being used, why, and what value it’s yielding for the consumer. AI needs to feel like helpful anticipation, not surveillance. The formula is simple: Know me just enough to impress me.
The generational convergence
Conventional wisdom suggests brands use different approaches for different generations. Gen Z wants speed and seamless digital. Millennials prefer to stack and optimize. Gen X and Boomers want clarity and obvious value. There’s some truth to those generalizations. But the differences are smaller than the commonalities.
Across all generations, more than 75% say “free to join” is extremely important. All generations prize ease of use and automatic savings, with 77% motivated by this. Weekly usage is remarkably consistent: 75% use loyalty programs weekly regardless of age.
When value is clear and the interface is intuitive, adoption follows. Therefore, the smartest approach isn’t to segment by age, but by loyalty-type and behavior patterns.
Closing thoughts
Based on our research, here are four ways to develop your 2026 loyalty playbook.
1. Onboard with one-tap joining and instant value demonstration.
2. Provide faster rewards through partner stacks and boosters while simplifying redemption.
3. Replace badges with progress indicators by providing visible balances, estimating time to earn rewards, and labeling effort versus return.
4. Practice visible privacy with transparent data usage explanations and obvious upsides for additional sharing.
Loyalty can’t be considered a retention tactic anymore. It has to be a business model.
The programs that will capture customer lifetime value are those that deliver on the new loyalty equation: speed, simplicity, and trust. Everything else is just a game.
Amy Lanzi is CEO of Digitas NA.