Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Reputation is a data asset

Why traditional reputation management needs an upgrade.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Geri Johnson

COO & Head of Al Innovation · Next PR

As a “soft” asset, brand reputation is something companies measure subjectively through anecdotal feedback, survey data, or a general sense of how the market feels about your brand.

But in the era of user-generated content and AI, reputation is a vital key performance indicator (KPI). It’s a quantifiable and dynamic data asset that directly influences growth and profitability.

It can also shift extremely quickly across media, social platforms, reviews, and increasingly, AI summaries. Much like a cybersecurity function actively monitors for threats, elevates risks, and helps teams respond quickly and appropriately, a modern reputation approach becomes the heartbeat of an organization’s brand security and optimization.

This fundamentally changes how PR functions in every organization. Adopting a more data-driven, always-on approach to reputation management is a more modern way to treat reputation as the true business KPI it is and a vital component of business strategy.

Why traditional PR approaches fall behind

Less than a decade ago, PR played a more centralized role in shaping the narrative through company news and announcements. But between the deluge of user-generated content and AI now nearly replacing Google as the preferred search tool, reputation is moving increasingly out of brands’ direct control.

An always-on, data-driven reputation model helps solve this problem. Similar to how companies manage cybersecurity, this approach relies on continuously collecting, analyzing, and elevating real-time signals.

These signals can include spikes in negative product reviews, sudden shifts in sentiment tied to a news story, or changes in how a brand appears in AI-generated summaries. By identifying these patterns early, teams can determine whether and how to act.

In practice, this approach combines listening and measurement tools with an expert strategy to provide monitoring so you know what’s happening and when, and filtering and context to know why, what, or whether it matters. Finally, there’s decision-making support to figure out what to do about it, if anything.

Use AI to your reputational advantage

An AI-enabled approach turns PR into a dynamic, real-time strategy that keeps pace with evolving reputation. PR becomes two-way and data-driven, allowing teams to act on incoming data and optimize output based on sentiment, audience response and channel context.

This capability powers predictive PR. The ability to refine messaging and narratives based on signals and get ahead of trends is critical. You have the insights to justify shifts in messaging or strategy, and can quickly see the results of adjustments, allowing you to test and refine messaging in real time.

For example, as consumers increasingly ask AI direct purchase questions, traditional product reviews are less likely to surface. For a client that sells stair lifts, we shifted our media strategy to prioritize educational articles, using headlines like “What is a stair lift?” and “Stair lift pros and cons.” Aligning content with how people query AI made those placements more likely to be cited and surfaced in AI-generated responses.

In addition, AI can bring up and amplify negative inputs faster, making speed and visibility essential. Whether it’s a viral TikTok video, unfavorable media mention, or Glassdoor review, the ability to identify and respond quickly becomes a key advantage in heading off larger reputational issues.

AI accelerates reputation urgency

Nearly half of consumers already use AI to research before they buy, and among B2B buyers, the trend is even stronger, as  93% use AI summaries and vendor comparisons to evaluate purchase decisions.

As a result, you must influence how AI platforms summarize, surface, and prioritize your brand. This depends heavily on the quantity, quality, and authenticity of third-party content, which is why earned media (coverage you earn rather than pay for) plays a critical role in optimizing for AI engines.

A data-driven reputation approach gives organizations the visibility to understand how they appear in AI-driven results, identify opportunities to influence positioning and track how those efforts evolve over time.

Why you need a data-driven reputation approach now

Any company that has experienced a crisis will tell you that reputation can move in the blink of an eye, and even the best crisis plans can only do damage control. They can’t predict or help you head off a crisis before it erupts.

While organizations can access more reputation data than ever before, “more data” often means more disparate data and noise, particularly when a large portion of reputation data is external and influenced by user-generated content, platforms, and algorithms.

When every mention, comment, headline, or review is a data point, inaccuracy risks increase alongside the urgency of corrections. Brands risk taking damage before they even realize what’s happening.

One healthcare client experienced this directly. After a year of negative headlines, media coverage began to taper off, initially suggesting the issue was losing momentum.

But the underlying data told a different story. Sentiment remained negative, and patient reviews continued to skew heavily critical. Visibility had changed, but perception had not.

The team shifted to a more proactive approach, increasing expert-contributed content, maintaining consistent thought leadership, and encouraging patients to share their experiences. Over time, positive reviews increased, and credibility began to recover across media and social channels.

It reinforced a simple point. Reputation moves across signals, and those signals are only visible when tracked in real time.

Build your reputation based on data

Managing reputation in the AI era requires a real-time strategy. But with so many moving parts, success depends less on a single tool or system and more on having the right combination of data, tools, and internal processes to interpret and act on it.

With the right approach, PR can provide actionable intelligence that offers a clear competitive advantage. The ability to audit your current standing, optimize content and placement, and continuously refine your strategy shifts reputation management from reactive to proactive. It also provides meaningful business insights to inform broader decision-making.

When grounded in data, reputation management moves beyond hunches and vanity metrics, operating with the same level of rigor and accountability as every other core business function.

Geri Johnson is chief operating officer at Next PR.