It’s the end of the year and time for the annual performance review. Or is it? Performance reviews are no longer relegated to year-end, stress-inducing, top-down discussions. When it’s time to let team members know how they’re doing on the job, leaders have switched things up.
We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members what their approach is to performance reviews. Here, 24 of those members weigh in on how they measure performance.
1. KEEP IT SIMPLE
They need to be three things: Simple. Actionable. Accountable. Simple: Big feedback presented in a confusing way sets both the leader and their team member in a worse spot. Actionable: Whether it’s steppingstones or making big leaps, everyone needs to understand how to get to the end goal. Accountable: Walk away understanding who does what; I can’t emphasize how often this is missed and it shakes the foundations of even the strongest teams. — Stephen Vallera, Force of Nature
2. FEEDBACK AS PART OF DAILY WORK
Performance reviews should not be treated as a once-a-year event. Our approach is based on continuous feedback, regular day-to-day guidance, and real project contribution over time. We believe people grow best when expectations are clear in the work itself, not saved for a formal review cycle. Performance is viewed through responsibility, consistency, quality of contribution, collaboration, initiative, and how someone develops in relation to the needs of the role. The goal is not to surprise people with feedback. The goal is to create an environment where feedback is part of how the work gets better every day. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
3. TAKE A HUMAN-FIRST APPROACH
I loathe performance reviews that stick to strict one-size-fits-all methodologies. We lead with human-first; tailored and qualitative approaches. A previous boss of mine used to say that how you did the work mattered as much as the output. Our small team contributes to our successes in ways that are sometimes outside of standard metrics. How their colleagues, clients, and partners view how they do the work and how they are to work with carries significant weight. — Mack McKelvey, SalientMG & The Credentialed
4. REVIEW FOR IMPACT, GROWTH, AND OWNERSHIP
I never think about performance reviews as something you do once a year. The best feedback occurs in the moment so there are no surprises when it comes time to have an annual formal discussion. My philosophy centers around three things: impact, growth, and ownership. Is this person creating valuable impact? Are they getting better? Do they take ownership of their work? You can teach someone to code or be more technical, but you can’t teach someone to be accountable, curious, and always willing to learn. Those are the traits that set your “A” players apart from the rest. A review should be a discussion about how someone can continue to grow. — Omar Hafez, Think Big Technology
5. FEEDBACK ALL YEAR AND NARRATIVE SUMMARY
The performance review should be the period at the end of a year-long sentence. If someone is surprised by what they read, you’ve already failed them. The review isn’t the feedback. It’s the summary of every conversation, every coaching moment, and every course correction you’ve had across the previous 12 months. The document is just the receipt. I block two full days before reviews. No meetings, no interruptions. I go back through my notes, the data, the conversations. Then I write. Not bullet points. A narrative. Because the people on your team deserve more than a scorecard. — Trent Cotton, ICIMS
6. FOCUS ON CELEBRATING ACHIEVEMENTS
A performance review is a celebration of the achievements of a designated period of work. It’s an opportunity for a leader to acknowledge the effort and growth of the team member so that they can feel seen and truly appreciated. If there are serious performance deficits, they should have been addressed in real-time rather than saved up for a review. A well-done review is one in which there are no surprises. — Shani Harmon, Stop Meeting Like This
7. INDIVIDUAL AND BUSINESS-FOCUSED GOAL SETTING
I used to dread annual reviews in my previous roles. We approach feedback differently with two distinct review types: SMART goals where you want to grow as an individual and 12-week goals that are business-focused on what’s shifting in the industry and what we need to master as an agency. They’re complementary. Your growth serves the business, and business priorities create growth opportunities. Team members identify issues and solve them quickly to see real, tangible growth that matters. Feedback is constant and tied to the work, not a year-end surprise. That’s how you build skills and culture simultaneously. — Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw, First and Last PR
8. NO SURPRISES
Performance reviews should never be a surprise. If someone is hearing about a major issue for the first time in a formal review, the manager has waited too long. I believe in regular, candid feedback throughout the year so people know where they stand, what is expected, and how they can keep improving. The review should confirm the conversation, not start it. — Evan Nierman, Red Banyan
9. QUARTERLY REVIEWS
We run them quarterly, not annually, because in cybersecurity and crisis communications the landscape shifts too fast for a once-a-year check in to mean anything. Each review ties directly to three things: client outcomes delivered, response time during incidents, and peer feedback on collaboration under pressure. I also ask every team member one question that most reviews skip: “What did you stop doing this quarter that made you better?” — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX
10. CONVERSATIONS ON CLARITY
Performance reviews for me are conversations, not scorecards. It is about helping someone get clarity on where they are, where they have room to grow, and how I can help them. I look for trends, progress, outcomes, and not individual mistakes. Honest, specific, and future-oriented is the most useful review conversation. If they walk away with more clarity and a clear plan to get it, then we have been successful. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand, Blushush Technologies
11. SHORT, MONTHLY CHECK INS
Nothing in a review should be a surprise. If someone finds out in their annual that they’ve been underperforming for six months, that’s a management failure, not a performance one. I run short monthly check-ins focused on one or two specific things. The formal review is just a summary of conversations we’ve already had. It also makes the hard calls easier, because the record is already there. — Daniel Haiem, AppMakers USA
12. TWO-WAY CONVERSATION
A leader should approach performance reviews as a two-way conversation rather than a one-way judgment, creating space for employees to share their own perspective on their work and goals. Focus on specific examples of performance, discuss development areas constructively, and work together on actionable steps for improvement. This collaborative approach helps build trust and increases the likelihood that employees will act on the feedback. — Joe Faruqui, ASAP semiconductor
13. EMPLOYEES GRADE THEMSELVES
We do them quarterly and it’s on the employee to set it up. They grade themselves on how they lived our core values, what they learned, something they’re proud of, and what skill they want to develop in the coming quarter. We pair that with the metrics and key performance indicators every role has. I also ask three questions: Do you understand the job? Do you want the job? Do you have the capacity for it? Then we look ahead and plan together. — Kim Bode, 8THIRTYFOUR
14. SHOW, DON’T TELL
By review time, nothing should be a surprise. My biggest lesson: People can’t fix what they don’t know is broken, and your bar and theirs are often in different places, someone delivering 50% can genuinely think they’re killing it. So, I stopped just telling people to “improve it.” I show them: I’ll rewrite the work myself and walk through every change, so the standard is concrete. And praise has to be as specific and timely as criticism. “Good job” alone is useless. — Kayode Faturoti, Stack Directory
15. FOCUS ON EVIDENCE, IMPACT, AND CONSEQUENCE
My approach to performance reviews is to make them about evidence, impact, and consequence. A review should not be ceremonial. And it should not be the first time someone hears important feedback. I look at whether the person created measurable business value, clarified ambiguity, improved execution across teams, and left behind a stronger operating motion than they inherited. Effort matters, but it is not the same as impact. The best reviews make the next level concrete by showing what was delivered, what pattern that reveals, and what must change to carry larger responsibility. — Rishi Katdare, Amazon Web Services
16. GRADE THE CONDITIONS FIRST
In my experience, we score people like performance is a fixed trait they carry, when most of it is the situation that we dropped them into—the manager, the handoff that breaks every quarter, the impossible number. Rate the person without rating the conditions and you’ve blamed the runner for the track. So, before I review anyone, I write down what they were working with and grade that first. Half of what looks like a performance problem turns out to be a design problem wearing someone’s name. — Natanya Wachtel, New Solutions Network
17. SET CLEAR EXPECTATIONS
My approach to performance reviews begins long before performance review season. I believe that guidance, coaching, and expectation-setting should be embedded into day-to-day work and team meetings. Providing timely, direct feedback should be a regular component of one-on-ones with direct reports. Setting an expectation helps provide a clear goal post so that your team knows what success looks like and what skills and behaviors you’re looking for. When it’s time for an annual performance review, nothing should be a surprise to your team. They deserve to learn and develop quicker, and the opportunity to improve more than just once a year. — Kevin Wong, The Trevor Project
18. KEEP A GROUP SCOREBOARD
We never built an annual review, because evaluation here never stops. We score work as it ships, in the open, all year. Anyone can look at the scoreboard and see what a teammate delivered and what it changed. And we hire for candor, so people speak plainly to each other in the moment. A December ritual would have nothing left to reveal. — Michael Quoc, Product.ai
19. GIVE ONGOING REVIEWS
I’m always perplexed when I read corporate messaging about performance reviews, mostly because every conversation I have is an element of a performance review. I’m always coaching, supporting, constructively challenging thinking because when my team is sharp and shows up the way I know they can, we all win. The idea that it’s one point in time is not my approach. —Jeffrey Whitford, MilliporeSigma, the U.S. and Canada Life Science Business of Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany
20. SUMMARY OF ONGOING CONVERSATIONS
Performance reviews should never contain surprises. If an employee is hearing critical, or even positive, feedback for the first time in a formal review, the real failure happened weeks or months earlier. I coach leaders to treat reviews as a summary of ongoing conversations, not an annual event. I also encourage highlighting what someone does exceptionally well, backed by specific, concrete examples. Vague praise and vague critique both invite generalizations, and generalizations are where bias often creeps in. — Dr. Kyle Elliott, CaffeinatedKyle.com
21. EVALUATE FOR “NICE”
I challenge the traditional metrics that focus solely on urgency and reductionist definitions of productivity and instead believe we should evaluate for “nice” as a core skill. Being kind is often dismissed as subjective or couched under vague terms like “collaborative,” but it takes high EQ, empathy, and intentional execution. A healthy, kind workforce performs at its fullest. So, measuring how people treat one another would likely be far more consistent and impactful for business results than many other normalized performance metrics. — Stephanie Trunzo, MERGE
22. MAKE IT CINEMATIC
Most performance reviews feel like a corporate autopsy—painfully analyzing the dead past. We treat reviews as a cinematic preview. We look back only to harvest data, then immediately pivot to mapping the employee’s next big professional arc. If a review doesn’t leave someone deeply curious about their own future potential, it’s just empty administrative theater. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
23. REAL-TIME DIALOGUE
I like to think of performance reviews as a dialogue. Feedback is most helpful when it can occur in real time. Ongoing discussions about performance mean there are no big surprises when a review happens. I value transparent workplace communication and believe feedback in both formal and informal settings is necessary to frame success and areas where there still can be improvement. For me, the purpose of a performance review is not only to assess the past. I think recognition is a great starting place, but a look to the future is equally if not more important. — Baruch Labunski, Rank Secure
24. KPI ACROSS PERFORMANCE AREAS
I establish measurable key performance indicators across all performance areas, even for soft skills like communication, emotional intelligence, and interpersonal dynamics. By setting those KPIs, I can review and rate better. — Al Sefati, Clarity Digital