Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Don’t squirrel away your AI savings

Reinvest in human touch.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Britton Upham

CEO · McGarrah Jessee

Across almost every industry, companies are finding moments in the customer experience where AI can replace human labor. In a lot of cases, they should. AI has gotten remarkably good at quick, transactional tasks.

Airports come to mind. Airlines were automating human interactions long before our current push toward AI; they’re a useful preview of the choices brands are about to face.

If I walk into an airport needing a boarding pass and bag tag, I’m content to handle it myself at a kiosk. The abundance of kiosk availability outweighs the value of waiting for a human. Boom, done. I don’t need a person in that moment.

I’m also generally fine with scanning and bagging my own groceries. 

All in, these kinds of automations work for me and they save their companies money.

AI is about to reach far more touchpoints in the customer experience.

THE IRRESISTIBLE TEMPTATION OF FUNDING EFFICIENCY

Here’s where the warning kicks in. We’ve seen this play before.

Companies spent much of the 2010s obsessed with performance marketing. By 2016, digital ad spend had overtaken TV for the first time in U.S. history. It was easy to program, easy to measure, predictable to model, and it opened the gateways to funding. Brand building asked us to believe; performance marketing gave us a dashboard. Everyone was in.

That was, until brands realized what all that measurable efficiency had masked: You can’t retarget your way to a new customer. Performance marketing is great at capturing demand; brand helps create it. By 2021, Airbnb’s Brian Chesky was one of the more visible executives to publicly about-face and reinvest in brand.

I worry we’re about to see this again. Only this time, the seduction isn’t media efficiency. It’s labor savings.

LET EFFICIENCY FUND NEW LEVELS OF HUMANITY

The great temptation of AI will be to take every dollar it removes from operating costs and drop it straight to the bottom line. That’s a mistake. Instead, companies should think about AI savings as a new kind of budget: a humanity fund.

Automate the interactions where people value speed, simplicity, and accuracy. Then reinvest some of those savings into the interactions where people value empathy, reassurance, or feeling seen. Don’t just use AI to become cheaper. Use it to earn the ability to become more human.

Back to the airlines. Now it’s six hours later and my connecting flight has been canceled. I’m stranded somewhere I didn’t intend to visit, the system rebooked me, and because thunderstorms did this to 10,000 other people, I can’t reach an agent to problem-solve imaginatively.

Now I want a person. I want to spitball. I want to feel heard. Humans are irrational that way and that’s precisely why brands should care.

What if, in the grocery store, some portion of those labor savings was redeployed instead? Someone who inspires you with recipes at the fish counter. A nutritionist helping parents navigate food allergies in original ways. Guest chefs making something incredible at 5:30 p.m. on a Wednesday.

These may have been luxuries brand teams couldn’t afford before. Now AI can fund them, if the savings get reinvested instead of banked.

THE EMOTIONAL ADVANTAGE

Fewer humans performing transactions. More humans creating relationships. That’s the trade I’d make.

Restaurateur Will Guidara’s Unreasonable Hospitality makes the case for thoughtful, personal acts of service—gestures often wildly disproportionate to what the transaction technically requires. It’s economically irrational. Which is the point.

The most powerful brand relationships aren’t purely rational. People are drawn to brands that are trustworthy, inspiring, flexible, committed, and charismatic. They are brands they buy into, not just buy. People get in line for them, recruit others to them, co-create with them, even intertwine their identities with them.

These are the rewards of investing in irrational touch.

THE DIVIDING LINE FOR BRAND LEADERS

As companies redesign customer experiences around AI, I’d separate the touchpoints simply:

  1. Which brand moments are economically transactional?
    Let AI schedule the appointment, find the order, change the reservation, process the return, or answer the simple question at 2 a.m. Be aggressive about making transactions easier.
  2. Which brand moments could be elevated relationally?
    Look for moments involving anxiety, confusion, vulnerability, or high stakes: the stranded traveler, the frightened patient, the first-time homebuyer. Human irrationality becomes most valuable there.

The irony of the AI revolution may be that machines give companies the financial freedom to become more human than they could ever afford to be before. But only if we trade routine transactional interactions for a real increase in human ingenuity at the moments that matter most.

AI is going to become astonishingly good at giving us what we ask for. Brands should redeploy their humans for the moments when we didn’t know what we needed.

Britton Upham is CEO of McGarrah Jessee.