A vice president I coached joined a rapidly growing startup as an external hire. She had the resume and the mandate, but she also had a team full of people who had never worked a day with her.
Maybe you were hired from outside, promoted into expanded scope, or handed a new team through a merger or reorganization. Over the last 10 years coaching tech leaders, I’ve found you face the same early test in each of these situations, and it has little to do with strategy.
As a leader, your output relies on other people’s output. Your job is to influence, and influence runs on trust. Without it, your people filter what they tell you and give you compliance instead of effort. Building trust will determine whether you succeed in the role. Your team decides early how much to give you, and those early decisions stick.
3 ways to build trust when you lead a new team
1. Conduct a structured listening tour
I encouraged the vice president to start with a listening tour and to bring the same set of questions to every conversation. Over her first 90 days, she held dozens of one-on-ones with team members, peers, and senior stakeholders.
I recommend three questions to leaders starting a listening tour:
- In an ideal world, how would you like my role to interact with yours?
- How can I make you look better?
- What other questions should I ask?
The third question compounds. Every conversation improves the following one, and people notice when their input shapes what you ask the next person.
The tour also surfaced something a briefing document wouldn’t have shown her. The CEO believed his organization was aligned on the company’s goal. The conversations showed otherwise. The executive team, board, and investors were driving toward profit, while the leaders and employees below them understood the goal as gross sales.
Without the tour, the vice president would’ve operated under the same assumption the CEO held, and the gap between the top and the bottom of the company would’ve taken her years to notice. She knew it within months.
She raised it with the executive team and clarified the goal with her own direct reports. Most of our coaching went into how to bring the disconnect to the CEO. Telling a founder his organization is less aligned than he believes is difficult feedback to deliver, especially a few months into the job.
She held her observations until the tour was complete, then walked the CEO through what she had found. Across dozens of conversations, she heard data, and data is easier to receive than one person’s read.
2. Adapt to individual preferences
Earlier in my career, I led a team of 23 direct reports in higher education. My natural style is a detailed agenda and straight to business, so I ran every one-on-one that way. A colleague—who’d previously developed rapport with the reports as their manager—confided that my approach wasn’t working well.
The team told her what they weren’t telling me. Many reports felt I didn’t have a flexible leadership style, but didn’t feel comfortable coming to me with that feedback—after all, I was their new boss. I asked my colleague for help on how to work better with her former team.
Based on my colleague’s feedback, I asked each direct report how they wanted to work with me, then kept a checklist next to my computer with notes on each person. Some preferred public praise in our staff meeting, while others wanted it privately in our one-on-one. Some wanted deadline reminders by email, while others wanted me to raise them when we met. Some wanted 10 minutes and done, while others wanted a full hour to talk through work, life, and feelings on a walk to get coffee.
My team also submitted a short weekly report, and I reviewed it for wins, themes, and concerns before each one-on-one. People trust leaders who work with them the way they need. Ask each person what that looks like.
3. Collect feedback in real time
One of my clients, a newly promoted director, needed to build trust with cross-functional partners while presenting a new external brand across her company. I coached her to collect evidence that her message worked.
We settled on a mini survey at the end of every session, completed live in the room. It asked two questions: What was the main point of this presentation, and what is one thing you would change?
The answers surfaced new ideas for the brand and showed her where she was less clear than she thought. The rollout improved, and so did her communication and leadership skills. Asking for feedback signals to a new team that you intend to listen for as long as you lead them, and acting on it proves the point.
Trust is never finished
My director client was months into her role when she ran those surveys. Building trust starts on day one and continues for as long as you hold the seat. Keep inviting feedback from your team, your boss, and your coaches and mentors, and keep adjusting to what you hear. You’ve got this.
Kyle Elliott is a tech career and executive coach at CaffeinatedKyle.com