Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Forget the generation gap, here’s what divides your workforce

Why birth year may be one of the least useful things leaders know about their employees.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Alison Myers

President, Venbrook Insurance Services

For years, we’ve been taught to understand workplace differences through generations. Baby boomers value loyalty. Millennials want feedback. Gen Z wants purpose and flexibility. Entire leadership strategies have been built around understanding what supposedly motivates each generation and how one cohort differs from the next.

But are we diagnosing the wrong thing?

Last year, two employees sat through the same AI rollout and walked out in opposite directions. One, who had been with the company for 30 years, volunteered to pilot the new tools. The other, two years into her career, went quiet because the tool did the tasks she was known for.

The generational explanation would have predicted almost the opposite reaction. Birth year can tell us something about the world a person grew up in, but it tells us much less about what that person needs right now from their leaders to be successful.

Developmental psychology offers a more useful lens. Psychologist Erik Erikson’s theory on human development proposes that development continues throughout our lives as we navigate fundamental tensions and changes around trust, autonomy, competence, identity, intimacy, generativity, and integrity.

Leaders should know that those needs don’t sort neatly by age or career level—and AI is making developmental differences in our workforce harder to ignore.Experienced experts can suddenly find themselves beginners again in the age of AI.

As AI takes on more structured and repetitive work, it can create more room for judgment, creativity, collaboration, problem-solving, and relationships. But making that transition successfully requires understanding the human needs underneath how people respond to change.

4 ways to turn developmental needs into leadership practices

The goal of looking at leadership through a developmental lens is not to turn leaders into amateur psychologists or create another way to categorize employees. But if we give leaders a way to think more carefully about what is underneath an employee’s response to a situation, we can create the conditions to help that person navigate it successfully.

Someone who appears resistant to AI, for example, may not simply be “resistant to change”; the change could threaten a sense of competence, identity, autonomy, or trust—each of which changes the leadership response. A threat to competency may require creating space to learn, while a lack of trust calls for greater transparency.

As leaders, we must learn to identify what change is disrupting for employees and respond accordingly. Here’s what that can look like in practice.

1. Create stability without pretending to have certainty

      Leaders cannot credibly promise exactly what every role will look like years from now, but they can be clear about what is known, honest about what isn’t, and consistent about following through. Employees also need agency within change.

      A common example now is in the development of AI workflows. While leadership may know the business outcome the technology needs to accomplish, the teams doing the work know the day-to-day better. Instead of designing the entire workflow and telling employees to adopt it, leaders should involve them in shaping it.

      2. Help people redefine what it means to be good at their jobs

      Careers traditionally reward people for accumulating experience. AI can disrupt that progression, turning someone who has spent 20 years becoming an expert into a beginner again.

      Leaders need to make that safe. Ask questions publicly. Let junior employees teach senior colleagues. Give teams room to experiment without expecting immediate mastery. When leaders demonstrate that learning is part of competence, others have permission to do the same.

      We can also help employees separate the tasks they perform from the capabilities they’ve built through them. AI might be able to review a complex document, but experience brings judgment about what matters, along with relationships, institutional knowledge, creativity, and context.

      3. Use the time technology gives back to deepen relationships.

      Connection is a developmental need, and technology can either erode or create more space for it. As AI takes on more transactional work, leaders can reinvest some of that time in the relationships that help employees feel known and connected to their teams.

      A 15-minute Friday meeting, for example, can move beyond status updates to what employees are looking forward to that weekend. Remembering those details—or recognizing that someone has had a difficult week — helps turn coworkers into relationships.

      4. Give experience a role in the future

      Transformation is inherently forward-looking, which can leave experienced employees wondering whether what they’ve learned still matters. How can they still contribute to what comes next?

      As information becomes easier to access, that contribution may shift from transferring knowledge to transferring discernment: what to trust, what to question, and when experience suggests something is wrong.

      Leaders can reinforce the value of experience by showing where institutional knowledge, judgment, relationships, and perspective fit into the future and inviting experienced employees to help shape it.

      It’s time to flip the org chart

      The traditional organizational chart puts leaders at the top, with their teams underneath. But developmental leadership calls for a different posture, where leaders stand alongside their teams, close enough to understand what people need, guide them through change, and catch them when they stumble.

      As work continues to evolve, people will not necessarily experience that change by birth year. Leadership needs to become just as dynamic, responding not to assumptions about where someone should be but to what that person needs to keep developing.

      Alison Myers is president of corporate benefits and specialty health at Venbrook.