During performance review season, I understand the importance of embracing a holistic strategy that not only values individual contributions but also prioritizes fairness, open communication, and continuous improvement.
To cultivate this for our organization, we refactored our system of growth from being a linear promotion process to one that allowed for more divergent growth paths. Having an “up or out” model didn’t work for our company culture. Having a lattice-based (rather than a ladder-based) approach gave people more autonomy in the course of their careers. And we made our promotion logic more equitable by transparently naming the conditions for growth.
To help other leaders, I asked members of the Company Culture Group of Fast Company Executive Board, a community I lead, how they improve equity and transparency in their review process. Here are important steps that they take and the impact they’ve seen from doing so.
1. AIM TO HIRE FOR DIVERSITY AT THE LEADERSHIP LEVEL.
This sounds like a simple approach, although easier said than done. It works because diverse leaders have faced equity and transparency challenges in some way — directly or indirectly. So, they are deeply aware and actively engage in improving systems and processes to address the issue. – Alok Ojha
2. KEEP COMMUNICATION CONSISTENT LONG BEFORE THE REVIEW.
Although it can be uncomfortable at times, consistent communication long before the review helps ensure that there are no surprises. This is a manager’s responsibility: to help nurture and help grow the team. The first step as managers is challenging ourselves to do what’s not easy, earlier. In many cases, it’s not the performance review — it’s the avoidance or lack of clarity. – Loren Greiff, Portfoliorocket
3. DESIGN A CORE COMPETENCIES MATRIX FOR EVERY ROLE.
We’ve designed a core competencies matrix for each position that details pay ranges for every level in the company. This way, team members have full insight into what compensation to expect as they progress upward. New job postings also include salary ranges as well as our full list of benefits so that, from the start, all new and current team members know what the compensation range is for every role. – Anna Madill, Avenue
4. EQUITABLY DISTRIBUTE OPPORTUNITIES TO DEVELOP CORE ROLES.
If a team member needs to be proficient in a particular area of the business to get promoted, your company should develop a culture and practice of equitably distributing opportunities to develop those skills — and to acquire those opportunities in high-value functions in the business. You also need to spot bias and correct bias in the criteria set. For that, try the Equity Sequence. – Anna Dewar Gully, Tidal Equality
5. USE DEPARTMENT-WIDE CALIBRATION PROCESSES.
Companies that I see improve equity and transparency in reviews use department-wide calibration processes with colleagues in the same room and same time to talk through their team’s results and performance together. In that way, after some practice, leaders work as a team to lead and calibrate all members of the organization together, united in using common measurements. It’s a powerful approach. – Rich DePencier, Chief Outsiders
6. MAKE SURE FEEDBACK IS IN REAL-TIME, BEHAVIORIAL, AND SPECIFIC.
Developing your team is a 365-day responsibility for any people manager. Waiting for the memo from HR saying it’s time to write performance reviews will automatically undermine employees’ sense of fairness and transparency, so remember that the best feedback is in real-time, behavioral, and specific. It includes recognition and constructive opportunities. – Amy Radin, Pragmatic Innovation Partners LLC
7. LISTEN TO EMPLOYEE FEEDBACK.
This year, our Employee Success team introduced our PEAK Career Framework, in response to employee feedback seeking more clearly defined career paths. This provides consistent and clear career paths, job levels, and competencies across the globe. As part of our commitment to stay competitive, we will continue to evolve and adapt the framework to market trends on an annual basis. – Godard Abel, G2
8. USE A ‘CONNECTED MANAGER’ APPROACH.
We put the “connected manager” approach into practice to foster authentic relationships between managers and their team members. It encourages open, casual dialogue throughout the year, which makes performance reviews feel less intimidating and more of an extension of the conversations that are already happening regularly. – Misty Dykema, Simantel
9. BE MINDFUL OF THE HISTORICALLY AND STATISTICALLY LESS-SUPPORTED DEMOGRAPHICS.
Great performance does not occur without support. Most firms in the U.S. have policies and practices designed to support the success of straight, Christian white males with stay-at-home wives. Everyone else is less supported. Making these support structures visible and adding support for the less-supported employees will produce greater overall team performance, benefiting the entire organization. – Joseph Santana, Joseph Santana LLC
10. USE THE 360-DEGREE METHOD TO COLLECT FEEDBACK.
A 360-degree method collects feedback from an employee’s subordinates, peers and superiors, offering a holistic view of their performance. By incorporating multiple perspectives, you minimize biases and deliver fairer evaluations. This comprehensive approach promotes a more equitable environment, fostering trust and growth within teams. – Leigh Burgess, Bold Industries Group, Inc.
11. CONSIDER REMOVING ANY RATING SCALE.
Company-wide metrics overshadow critical aspects of individual contribution, and a numeric value promotes a culture of comparison. Instead, focus on qualitative feedback to foster clearer, transparent, and equitable conversations that encourage the individuality of potential. – Gergo Vari, Lensa
12. AIM FOR YES-NO QUESTIONS.
Improving equity and transparency in performance reviews yields better employee morale. The basis for making these judgments should be measurable. Ideally, the questions need to be answerable by a “yes” or “no.” For example, the question “Has the employee achieved the sales goals for this quarter?” can be easily answered this way. – Zain Jaffer, Zain Ventures
13. MAKE SURE MANAGERS ARE ALSO REVIEWED BY TEAM MEMBERS.
We allow our employees to rate their manager in different areas. It has allowed us to create managerial training programs based on employees’ feedback in areas where they’ve identified a need for improvement. – Kelley Higney, Bug Bite Thing
14. EMPHASIZE A CULTURE OF THOROUGH DOCUMENTATION.
We have a strong policy on documentation in our business. We verbally and repeatedly ask everyone to document their work, their results, and team processes in easy-to-access files and systems. As a result, there are multiple sources to verify the work being done. And the result is that we have accurate information and therefore, fair performance reviews. – Syed Balkhi, WPBeginner
Mark Rickmeier is the Chief Executive Officer of TXI, a product innovation firm that delivers engaging experiences and custom software.