Not every business idea yields positive results. Some are real clunkers, worth forgetting and not worth repeating. But even bad ideas can teach something that provides real benefit.
We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members what was the worst idea they ever had in business and what did they learn from it. Not surprisingly, many members responded that, when building their business, saying “yes” to every new opportunity caused them to lose focus and slowed business growth. Below, 36 members, including a few who said “yes” too often, share their worst business idea and the takeaway that’s informed their business going forward.
1. THE IDEA THAT THE BEST TECHNOLOGY WINS
Believing that the best technology would naturally win. I learned that innovation without execution, commercial relevance, and customer trust is just an expensive science experiment. — Arun Narayanan, Stem Inc.
2. THE $100 BITCOIN I DIDN’T BUY
Sitting on Bitcoin is my worst business idea. In 2013 a friend showed me how to buy it at around $100, and I passed because I didn’t understand it. My mistake was treating unfamiliar as fake. Now when something new looks weird to me, I take a small position: small enough that being wrong doesn’t hurt, big enough that I pay attention. — Rotem Gal, Insights Beyond
3. A “YES” TO EVERY OPPORTUNITY
One of the worst ideas was believing that growth meant saying “yes” to every interesting opportunity. A cool new client, new industry, shiny new technology, sure, why wouldn’t we do it? However, after 20-plus years, I’ve learned that every yes costs time and focus, so knowing what to say “no” to is just as important as having a great vision. The lesson for me was learning to protect our focus. A good opportunity can still be the wrong opportunity for us if it doesn’t align with the vision and mission of the company. — Jarrod Lopiccolo, Noble Studios
4. LUNCH WITH MY DIRECT REPORTS
When I first became a manager, I would take my direct reports out to lunch every week. The goal was to build camaraderie among them and between them and me. Bad idea. All the junior staff thought we were talking about them behind their backs (we weren’t) and it created divisions. I learned the value of treating everyone equally from direct reports to interns, and that has served me well. — Tim Johnson, UPRAISE Marketing + Public Relations
5. SUPPORT IS NOT SUBSTITUTION
I’ve tried this experiment more times than a behavioral scientist probably should admit. Someone isn’t quite right for the role, partnership or moment, and instead of accepting the data, I compensate. More meetings. More context. More coaching. More of me. Sometimes people absolutely need room to grow. But I’ve learned—slowly—that support and substitution aren’t the same thing. When I’m doing someone else’s job to preserve the idea that they’re doing it, I’m not actually helping either of us. I’m getting better at noticing the difference. — Natanya Wachtel, New Solutions Network
6. WHEN I TOOK ON A TERRIBLE CLIENT FOR THE MONEY
Any time I’ve been on a call with a prospect where I KNEW they’d be a terrible client, but I saw the dollar signs and said yes anyway. In consulting, a bad client doesn’t just affect the person managing the account. It turns into escalations, unhappy employees, billing headaches, and time you could have spent on good clients. I’ve learned to trust that initial read. The revenue is almost never worth it. — Andrea Lechner-Becker, GNW Consulting
7. NEVER BORROW OR RAISE OUTSIDE CAPITAL
My worst idea was making it a principle never to borrow from a bank or raise outside capital. I wanted to avoid owing anyone money. After all, I set up my own company to be my own boss. After a decade I realized that fear had also limited my ambition. I now believe I could have scaled faster and reached my business goals sooner with funding. The lesson for me was to not give in to the fear of the unknown. If you believe in yourself and work hard, things work out in the end. — Amit Sadhwani, Digital Advisory
8. CONVICTION THAT TURNS INTO ASSUMPTION
I can’t narrow it to one, but the lesson behind most of them is the same: Conviction quietly turns into assumption. You get so close to an idea you think you know what the customer wants. Then you launch it and find out you were wrong. Now I get curious earlier and test before I build. Being wrong in week one is cheap. Being wrong six months in is expensive. It’s the same gap we help brands close every day. — Joshua Nu’u-Steele, Ideally
9. WHEN EVERY YES COSTS FOCUS
Early on, I said yes to every client who could pay, across every industry. We were busy but forgettable, and the work got thinner as we stretched. The lesson: Positioning is a decision to say no. Today we choose clients we can actually make famous. — Kevin Leyes, Leyes Media
10. A GREAT PRODUCT ISN’T ENOUGH
My worst idea was assuming that the businesses I’d be building for ran on systems the way big companies do. Once we started working with commercial contractors, we saw there wasn’t really a standard system. Everyone does something a little different, and two contractors that look almost identical on paper can run completely different workflows. That’s why we built our company to be flexible instead of forcing one process on everyone, and it’s what let us expand from service into construction and sales without rebuilding the product. The lesson I took from it is to spend time inside a customer’s business before deciding how it works. — Steve Chew, BuildOps
11. THE WRONG PEOPLE AT THE TABLE
Probably believing, at some point in my career, that a great idea and enough energy could compensate for having the wrong people around the table. They can’t. I’ve learned that timing, market, and capital all matter, but people matter more. The right team can challenge your idea, adapt when reality proves you wrong, and turn something good into something exceptional. Today, whether I’m building or investing, I spend much more time asking “Who?” before “What?” — Marc Menase, Founders Future
12. THE TRADITIONAL AGENCY MODEL
My worst business idea was copying the traditional agency model. Early on, I staffed my company in levels the way agencies always have, and it never felt right. It worked against the firm I wanted to build. When I was on the client side, I wanted senior people paying attention to my business. So I spent two days with an executive coach who usually works with B2B technology companies, and he helped me rebuild the business and staffing around what I wanted to deliver. That structure still stands. The lesson: Build the agency you’d want to hire. There’s no B team or C team at my company. Clients get the A team every day. — Kathleen Lucente, Red Fan Communications
13. THE IDEA THAT EVERY OPPORTUNITY HAS VALUE
One of my major lessons has been to understand that not every opportunity has value. When I was new to the industry, I would agree to opportunities simply because I thought they had potential, regardless of whether the opportunity was consistent with what we did well, who our customers were, and/or what direction we wanted to move the organization. As a result, I have come to realize that growing as a business takes self-control. Now, prior to saying yes to an opportunity, I consider whether the opportunity supports our overall plan, helps serve our customers better, and advances our company towards its goals. — Jennifer Schaefer, JS Benefits Group
14. NOT TRUSTING MY GUT
The worst idea for me was not trusting my intuition and continuing on a critical initiative well past when the game should have been called. Making tough calls is most certainly part of any CEO’s job. That trust is not just built on data and facts but also experience. I took a risk when I made the decision to proceed and did so because I thought the issue could be resolved to an acceptable outcome. It was not, or at least not on the path we were on, and it was a costly set back. — Rhonda Levene, Ziosk
15. THE AI SYSTEM THAT ROUTED EVERY DECISION TO ME
The worst idea I had recently was the way I designed my company’s AI-powered collaboration system, which inadvertently routed every decision to me. We designed it around a constitution meant to establish who is responsible for what, but our AI model interpreted it more rigidly than a human would and encouraged employees to get decisions ratified by senior staff, especially me. This resulted in bottlenecks and a pile of paperwork on my desk. The solution involved both culture and engineering. The team and I reaffirmed our commitment to decentralized decision making, and we adjusted the documents our model uses to understand our organization. — Michael Quoc, Product.ai
16. THE BUSINESS BOTTLENECK WAS ME
Thinking I could do everything myself because it would be faster than explaining it to someone else was one of my worst ideas. For an individual task, that was sometimes true. As a way to run a business, it was a terrible idea. I became the person everyone had to wait for, and then wondered why I was constantly stretched. I learned that delegating takes patience upfront. Doing something yourself saves time today. Teaching someone to own it saves you from doing it forever. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Bhavik Sarkhedi & Co.
17. WHEN I ABANDONED MY NATURAL COMPASS
Early in my career, I was told my natural leadership style was “brash and ineffective” simply because I was a woman. The worst mistake any of us can make is abandoning our natural compass to play the role of a traditional, authoritative leader. Real leadership happens when you stop performing and start showing up as a whole human. Kindness isn’t the opposite of ambition. You can run a tight ship, set high standards, and still lead with deep empathy and respect. — Stephanie Trunzo, MERGE
18. THE BIGGER ROLE AS THE RIGHT NEXT STEP
Believing that a bigger role at a bigger company was automatically the right next step. I’ve worked in startups, large companies, and everything in between. I’ve learned that being capable of doing a job doesn’t mean it’s the right environment for you. I’m most energized when I’m close to the work, can build, and can see the impact of a decision. The lesson was to stop using title and scale as substitutes for fit. Ambition becomes more useful when you’re honest about what you want. — Dennis Richter, Fullscript
19. THE 40% OF FEATURES CUSTOMERS DIDN’T NEED
Initially, I believed that implementing numerous niche customization options in our resume builder would lead us to appeal to all buyer personas. The outcome? A complicated user interface that was hard to operate for our target users and reduced the overall efficiency of the solution. We misinterpreted the mass of options as value. The lesson that we have learned is significant yet straightforward: Complexity is the main obstacle when it comes to adoption. We eliminated almost 40% of surplus features and concentrated on providing a functional and rapid core product. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
20. WHEN I FOCUSED ON EXPERIENTIAL YEARS INSTEAD OF SKILLS
My worst idea was staffing a brand-new region by chasing years of experience instead of real skills. I pulled people from competitors with big local footprints, and assumed tenure meant they had the hunter-entrepreneur instincts I needed. Wrong. They had history, not hustle. Lesson: Years of experience is not a leading indicator. Now I start with the outcome I need to drive, then work backward to the skills that get me there. — Trent Cotton, ICIMS
21. WHEN I PULLED STAFF FROM A PAYING CLIENT FOR A PROMISED ONE
I was close to signing a deal to provide a mobile game day experience for a major sports brand. We needed to develop a prototype under a tight deadline. So I pulled engineers from our paying client (with notice and completed our milestone). Suddenly, my phone calls went unanswered by the sports brand. Two weeks later, my contact gave me the news: Big reorganization, only signed projects would continue. We didn’t make the cut. The lesson is simple: Nothing is done until the signature is in my inbox and the check is in my account. I would take different risks over time but would never turn off a paying client in favor of a promised one. — Everett Harper, Everett Harper
22. WORK SPENT ON THINGS PEOPLE DON’T CARE ABOUT
OMG, so many! But the one lesson that comes to mind is don’t work on things that people don’t care about. In the beginning of our business, I would spend days and weeks crafting reports for our clients where our little mascot would explain what all the metrics meant and walk them through every little detail of what happened in their account that month. Over time I learned that literally no one even read any of the reports. They only cared about the end result. It took a long time and lots of fighting back from me, but we eventually largely automated reporting and no one batted an eye. — Anthony Higman, ADSQUIRE
23. WHEN I MADE EXCUSES FOR NOT STARTING A COMPANY
I’m wrong all the time, and I don’t mind that at all. It’s just part of the process. My worst idea was making excuses to myself as to why I should not start a company. I wanted to start a company long before I did, but didn’t, partly because I talked myself out of it so many times. Talking myself out of it wasn’t the worst idea. I wasn’t ready. My gut was right. The worst idea was making the excuses to myself. Excuses didn’t allow me to move forward. Excuses are all negative. What I learned was I needed to swap my excuses for specifics. “Where did I need to focus so I would be ready” is very different from “You’re just not ready.” — Mitch Spolan, Payorology
24. THE OVERBUILD
Some of my worst ideas weren’t obviously bad ideas. They were good ideas that I allowed us to overbuild. Engineers, including technical founders, can become fascinated by making something flexible enough to handle every imaginable future requirement. Then six months later you discover that customers really needed 20% of it, and they needed that 20% three months ago. I’ve learned to ask a much less exciting question: What is the smallest thing we can ship that completely solves the customer’s actual problem? — Philipp Schloter, ABUKAI, Inc.
25. THE DOOR-TO-DOOR SALES APPROACH
Selling lease buyouts door-to-door is my worst business idea. Our logic was that lots of people have a car lease, so why not knock on doors and pitch them? It was a terrible idea. What we learned was that a lease buyout is a big financial decision people want to make on their own terms when they’re ready, not when a stranger shows up on their porch. That pushed us to focus on meeting customers online, at the moment they’re actually thinking about their lease. — Zander Cook, Lease End
26. IF WE BUILD IT, THEY WILL FIND IT
One of my worst ideas was believing that if we built a great product, the market would naturally find it. It doesn’t. I learned that distribution, timing, positioning, and listening to customers matter just as much as what you build. A brilliant solution to a problem that people aren’t ready to prioritize is still a bad business. That lesson changed how I think about building companies: Start with the pain, not the product. — Ashish Fernando, EDMO
27. THE IDEA OF DOING EVERYTHING MYSELF
When I first started out in my career, I assumed being a high performer meant doing everything myself and pushing my way through. My manager loved it, but my peers saw me as a “one-man show.” It was a terrible approach that isolated me. I learned that business is a team sport. Nurturing peer relationships and listening to hear, not just reply, is vital to long-term success. — Kristi Melani, Reputation
28. RELIANCE ON ELEGANT TECH
Assuming the technically elegant answer was automatically the right business decision. Early on, I underestimated the massive operational lift required—retraining teams, rewiring workflows, and driving adoption. I learned that elegant tech fails if the business isn’t operationally mature enough to run it. Always evaluate the whole operating environment before committing to major transformations. — Chris Brown, Sngular
29. WHEN I LOVED THE SOLUTION BEFORE UNDERSTANDING THE PROBLEM
I’ve had plenty of ideas that looked much better on a whiteboard than they did in the real world. The common mistake was falling in love with the solution before spending enough time understanding the problem. Thirty years in technology has taught me that customers, employees, and markets are very good at exposing assumptions. Build, listen, adjust. Being willing to change your mind quickly is far more valuable than being determined to prove you were right. — Nick Gonios, Epignosis Learning
30. CREDIT CARD USE TO START
The worst idea I ever had was using credit cards to start our business. It got us started, but the interest made every month harder than it needed to be. What I learned is to start smaller and grow with the money you make, not the money you borrow. — Bryan Kramer, PureMatter Inc.
31. EVERY PROBLEM NEEDS A NEW PROCESS
One of my worst ideas was thinking every problem needed a new process. Earlier in my leadership career, when something went wrong, my instinct was to add another checklist, approval, or procedure to prevent it from happening again. I learned that too much process can slow down great people and discourage independent thinking. Now, I focus on clear guardrails, the right context, and trusting people to make good decisions rather than trying to create a process for every scenario. — Nandish Dave, BitGo Inc.
32. THAT GROWTH PROVED A STRONG FOUNDATION
Believing growth was enough evidence that the decisions underneath it were right. Something can be growing while important signals inside the business are moving in the opposite direction. Growth can amplify what is working, but it can also amplify what has been overlooked. Experience taught me to pay closer attention to what the numbers surrounding growth were not telling me. — Paul L Gunn Jr., Signal & Anomaly
33. THE IDEA OF COMPETING ON PRICE
Early on, I wanted to compete on price. Then I realized the industry was full of companies reselling the same units from China, each trying to undercut the next. I changed course pretty quickly. I learned that lowering your price can become a substitute for figuring out why someone should buy from you in the first place. — Christopher Kiggins, SaunaCloud
34. MISMATCHED MEDIUMS
One of my worst early ideas was designing an entire newsletter by hand for a digital affiliate program. My manager looked at it and asked, “This is great, but how do we email it?” It taught me to clarify the medium before developing the message, and to treat an imperfect first attempt as something to iterate on, not hide. — Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric
35. FIGHT FOR THE WORK
“You have to fight for the work.” In the advertising industry, you get bombarded with a lot of us-vs-them mentality when you’re first starting out. That couldn’t be further from the truth. I now live by a different rule: “If you’re fighting, you have already lost.” — John Verrochi, Masters of Science, Inc
36. TOO MANY IDEAS
Early in my career, I tried to do too many things at once. I didn’t know how to say no and focus on what mattered. That taught me that choosing what not to do is as important as choosing what to pursue. — Arad Levertov, Sunbit