Today, managers are expected to support employees navigating anxiety, burnout and personal crises, often without any formal training.
According to a new 2026 report, nearly 7 in 10 benefits leaders say mental health challenges are significantly affecting employees’ ability to do their jobs, yet almost 9 in 10 say their managers are expected to respond to those challenges sans adequate training.
This gap is a wellness and workforce performance problem. Why? Because you can’t manage results without managing the whole person. The whole person includes their ambitions, anxieties, and arguments they had before logging off or the aging parent they’re worried about.
At Venbrook, we’re closing that gap by mandating mental health first aid training for every manager.
With five generations now working side by side, understanding how to competently lead and support the whole person has never been more critical. Baby boomers, Gen Xers, millennials, and Gen Zers bring different expectations about what it means to show up at work. When those worldviews collide without the right leadership skills, friction manifests as disengagement, turnover, and eroded team performance.
Although May’s Mental Health Awareness Month has passed, it’s always an opportune time for leaders to upskill and foster a culture where both performance and wellness can thrive.
4 WAYS TO PRACTICE WHOLE-PERSON LEADERSHIP
This leadership builds psychological safety across your organization. When your team feels supported, heard and safe to bring their full selves to work, everything else follows. It starts with these four practices.
1. MANAGE YOUR EMOTIONS
When one of my teammates announced she was leaving, I was so upset. But in the moment, I had to show up for my team in a calm, collected, and positive way. That’s not an easy thing to do.
Too many leaders let negative emotions spill into the room without realizing the cost. When leaders can’t regulate their emotional state, teams pick up on it and absorb it. Your team can feel your energy before you say a word.
An unsettled leader unsettles the room, erodes trust, and undermines the psychological safety people need to do their best work. No wellness program or engagement survey can compensate for a leader who hasn’t learned to manage themselves first.
2. ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR BIASES
Every leader carries blind spots shaped by their personal life experiences.
When a male teammate asked for eight weeks of paternity leave, my experience shaped my first thoughts. I barely saw my father growing up, and honestly, I was thrown off by the idea that a man wanted to take eight weeks off to bond with his baby.
That was my stuff, though, not his. Recognizing that was step one. Step two was backing his choice. It’s exactly the kind of blind spot that, left unchecked, gets in the way of supporting the person.
Your job is to create space for teammates to show up as their whole selves, even when it challenges your own frame of reference.
3. TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR YOUR WORDS
Communication is a strategic asset, and there’s a big difference between your intention and your impact. A leader may have the best intentions. But if someone walks away from a conversation feeling unheard or unsupported, the message didn’t land, and that’s on you.
Younger generations intuitively understand impact over intention. Older generations tend to lead with intent: I meant well, so I did well. But if it didn’t land the way you meant it, they didn’t actually hear it. And that gap—between what you said and what they received—is exactly where trust erodes, and disengagement begins.
4. GIVE HONEST FEEDBACK
Criticism, when rooted in genuine care, is one of the most valuable gifts a leader can offer. Withholding honest feedback is a quiet cruelty because it allows someone to repeat the same mistakes.
The magic happens when directness and warmth coexist. Real growth happens when an employee knows that naming a misstep won’t cost them their safety, and that their leader will meet them with curiosity rather than judgment.
And when mistakes do happen, the most important response is an apology and a repair. Real repair means slowing down long enough to ask the right questions: Was this a capacity issue? A knowledge gap? A misaligned expectation?
In a world where we move faster than ever, skipping that reflection is how small mistakes become habits. Taking the time to repair, together, is how you build the kind of psychological safety where people stop hiding their mistakes and start learning from them.
WELLNESS AND PERFORMANCE WORK TOGETHER
Whole-person leadership demands both accountability and compassion, not one or the other. The best leaders know that what’s running in the background of their employees’ lives directly affects what shows up at work. When you lead with that awareness—across generations, differences, and everything people carry through the door—performance and wellness stop being competing priorities and start reinforcing each other.
Alison Myers is the president of employee benefits for Venbrook Insurance Services.