In mid-June 2024, Tesla shareholders approved a significant compensation package for CEO Elon Musk, granting him around 303 million stock options potentially worth several billion dollars. This came after a Delaware court rejected a previous compensation agreement, prompting Tesla to propose reincorporating in Texas, where it operates. Shareholders approved both the new compensation package and the move to Texas during the same meeting.
Musk had previously agreed to a deal with Tesla’s board and shareholders promising him a 5% commission if Tesla’s market cap reached $1 trillion, with no compensation otherwise. Tesla achieved this milestone in October 2021, but the Delaware Court of Chancery revoked Musk’s compensation in January 2024 due to claims of fiduciary breaches and corporate waste. In June 2024, Tesla sought shareholder approval again, with Board Chair Robyn Denholm emphasizing Musk’s crucial role in transforming Tesla into a global leader in sustainability and innovation, urging respect for the original agreement.
THE PACT BETWEEN SHAREHOLDERS AND FOUNDERS
As a tech startup founder myself whose mobile ad company, Vungle, was acquired by private equity firm Blackstone in 2019, this is really about the pact between shareholders and a founder. When Tesla started, it was really just a vision, and the shares were worth little to almost nothing.
When entrepreneurs seeking startup and expansion funding like me deal with outside investors and venture capitalists, the terms of our compensation as founders/CEOs are spelled out clearly. Investors, VCs, and angels are looking for return on capital. It is the job of the management they hire, whether they retain founders like me or hire new experienced hands to lead, to fulfill their financial return expectations on their capital.
If I promise the moon and stars to potential investors, they either can laugh me out of their boardrooms or believe in me. So for my mobile ad startup, I kept the expectations reasonable and the board agreed with me—and we agreed on my compensation and deliverables because of that.
THE IMPORTANCE OF LEADERSHIP
There is probably nothing more important than selecting an organization’s leader. They’re the one who runs the show. Selecting this person can really make or break an organization, as recent experiences with companies that have been mismanaged show. For example, at Boeing, the lack of emphasis on engineering and quality versus their emphasis on cost savings was a management decision that came from their CEO.
One can go with a step-by-step plan and checklist to select a leader, but at the end of the day, the hunch of the board and everyone who will have a part in selecting this person will matter greatly.
THE BOND OF TRUST
The bond of trust between the investor shareholders and the management team is everything. If there is a time to say, “What you are asking for in return is unreasonable,” it is when a contract is being drafted and before signing. Not after the ink has dried and the audacious goals have been delivered.
If a board will sign up an executive to a compensation package, they should see if the goals are plausible or almost impossible. In Musk’s case, they believed his audacious goals and signed up for them. He delivered. Without him, Tesla would just be another footnote in the EV sector, and like the Tesla shareholders, I agree he deserves the compensation package.
A one-of-a-kind person who can actually deliver on an audacious preagreed promise deserves a one-of-a-kind compensation contract. Corporate America will not achieve the kinds of success it used to if it keeps insisting that visionary leaders be boxed into the compensation plans that work for ordinary executive leaders.