ChatGPT and other generative AI (GenAI) tools have become integral aspects of many business operations, from sales and marketing to corporate communications. While GenAI offers efficiency and valuable insights, leaning too heavily on this technology can ultimately stifle creativity and innovation.
Leaders and teams that use these tools need to strike a balance between technology and human ingenuity. To help, 20 Fast Company Executive Board members discuss how organizations can avoid overreliance on ChatGPT and similar AI tools. Here’s how to find a middle ground and encourage efficiency with a healthy dose of critical thinking and original ideas.
1. TREAT CHATGPT AS AN EAGER INTERN.
Think of relying on ChatGPT the same way you would rely on a very smart, very eager, very new intern. You can count on them to generate a few great ideas, research, and reference points—and quickly. But you can also count on a few bad ideas that miss the mark. As you would with the eager intern, check the work and always ensure it aligns with the greater organizational strategy. – Nisha Anand, Dream.Org
2. TREAT AI IT AS A PARTNERSHIP.
In partnership with GenAI, I firmly believe in the philosophy of placing humans at the center. The power of data-driven AI must be met with the dynamic force of human critical thinking, curiosity, and challenge to deliver better outcomes. It’s not a choice between AI “or” human insight—it’s the harmonious “and” that will drive innovation, new ways of working, and transformative change. – Nadine Mirchandani, EY
3. ENCOURAGE SELF-EXPRESSION AND PERSONAL CONCLUSIONS.
It’s an empty existence not to feel seen. Every time you’re asked for your opinion, your answer is an act of self-expression. It’s an opportunity for others to know you uniquely, for bonds to form, or for reflection to result. Research and stimulus are great, but don’t delegate your personal conclusions. Those come only from your original perspective. To truly be in a community, means to share. – Britton Upham, McGarrah Jessee
4. ESTABLISH CLEAR GUIDELINES FOR AI USE.
Establish clear guardrails and use cases for when AI tools like ChatGPT are encouraged and when they are prohibited. Emphasize with your team that, while AI is useful as a creative spark, you cannot rely on AI outputs alone for content or strategy. Only humans have the power of strategic thinking, and even the best AI-generated content will still lack an authentic voice and human touch. – Geri Johnson, Next PR
5. TAKE THE 20-60-20 APPROACH.
Follow the 20-60-20 rule. People do the first 20 percent of a project. The LLM generates the next 60 percent. Then, the final 20 percent goes back to humans to incorporate the emotion and soul that an LLM lacks. LLMs are tools; like any tool, they need to be used properly. – Steve Anderson, Catalyit LLC
6. SHOWCASE THE LIMITATIONS OF AI.
I heard of a professor who assigned students to use an LLM to write their term papers and grade them themselves. They were surprised by their mistakes and fabrications. This exercise became a lesson in critical thinking and the risks of blind trust in AI. To understand AI’s limitations, one must push its boundaries and critically analyze the outcomes. Do this and encourage others to do the same. – Philip Rathle, Neo4j
7. LEVERAGE THE ‘SCAMPER’ METHOD FOR IDEA GENERATION.
Develop a structured process for idea generation, like the “SCAMPER” method, which prompts you to systematically explore ways to “Substitute, Combine, Adapt, Modify, Put to another use, Eliminate, or Reverse” existing concepts. By training your brain to approach creative thinking in a methodical way, you’ll be less likely to default to ChatGPT and more likely to generate ideas on your own. – Frederik Bussler, Bussler & Co
8. ENCOURAGE TEAM COLLABORATION.
True innovation thrives on diverse teams and ideas. Prioritize group brainstorming and team collaboration. Remember, the best ideas often come from the most unexpected places in the organization. – Alex Goryachev, The Robots Are Coming
9. USE AI AS A TOOL FOR ELEVATION, NOT CREATIVITY.
Leadership should encourage their team to view ChatGPT as a tool that elevates ideas when used properly. Leaders should establish clear guidelines that encourage their teams to prioritize their own creativity while utilizing AI. This ensures that innovation remains rooted in human insight while benefiting from the capabilities of AI. – Chalmers Brown, Due
10. ENGRAIN AUTHENTICITY AND IMPROVEMENT IN COMPANY VALUES.
To avoid overreliance on ChatGPT, companies should foster a culture of continuous improvement by ingraining it into company values. This involves welcoming new ideas, nurturing collaboration, and providing opportunities for innovation and learning. We must encourage brainstorming, reward creativity, and facilitate cross-functional projects to ensure diverse perspectives and sustain innovation. – Mike Field, The Raymond Corporation
11. BRAINSTORM WITH TECHNIQUES OTHER THAN AI.
Regularly conduct brainstorming sessions without the use of AI tools. Encourage team members to generate ideas and solutions on their own. Use techniques like mind mapping, SWOT analysis, or the SCAMPER method (Substitute, Combine, Adapt, Modify, Put to another use, Eliminate, and Reverse) to stimulate creative thinking. – Britton Bloch, Navy Federal
12. USE CHATGPT AS A STARTING POINT.
ChatGPT is forcing us to think in new ways and reimagine how ideation begins. Often I begin solving a problem by asking ChatGPT, but the first answer is never the right answer. But it leads to more iteration and considerations. Using ChatGPT, the solutions become more varied, but I still need to decide the best option. – Barry Lowenthal, Inuvo, Inc.
13. DON’T USE AI UNTIL YOU’VE COME UP WITH YOUR OWN IDEA.
Keep the laptops closed until you’ve got ideas of your own. Generative AI is an accelerator and amplifier, but not the source of inspiration—that’s your job. Pundits once worried that Google would make us stupid; now the concern is whether or not AI will make us lazy. The answer is up to you. – Tim Maleeny, Havas North America
14. CREATE PROMPTS THAT ENCOURAGE ORIGINAL THINKING.
To avoid overreliance on ChatGPT, leaders should use prompt engineering that encourages critical thinking. Design prompts with parameters that require users to input their own ideas. For example, “Based on your understanding, what are potential solutions for [x problem]? List three ideas and explain your reasoning.” This approach combines AI insights with human creativity, fostering innovation. – Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric
15. ENCOURAGE CROSS-DEPARTMENTAL COLLABORATION.
Innovation, like creativity, is a muscle that all businesses have to flex. In my experience, the best innovations come from a company coming together across departments to solve a singular problem. Sometimes, the best ideas sprout from an intern or your customer service team. Leaders should involve the whole company as often as they can! – Nina Ojeda, Good Creative
16. USE THE TIME SAVED WITH AI FOR ‘FLOW TIME.’
AI tools like ChatGPT can be a welcome respite from day-to-day drudgery. However, as we become more efficient through these tools, we also create space in our lives for value-added work, such as deep thinking, creative brainstorming, or rich, human connection. Start by quantifying the time saved and then begin scheduling it in blocks on your calendar as “Flow Time” for more meaningful thinking. – Rachel Truair, Simpro Group
17. ARRANGE TECH-FREE INNOVATION AND PROBLEM-SOLVING SESSIONS.
ChatGPT has taken the world by storm, and rightly so; it is revolutionary. However, there is a need for balance to counteract overreliance on it. Leadership can set parameters and policies to guide how and when it will be used in the workplace. In addition, leadership could arrange tech-free innovation and problem-solving sessions to practice critical thinking and exercise pure brainpower. – Keera Godfrey, Naris Communications LLC
18. ENCOURAGE CONTINUAL LEARNING TO FOSTER CREATIVITY.
Since ChatGPT is based on existing data, relying on it would hinder creativity and innovation. Leaders should encourage their teams to learn continually, attend workshops, and do research. This fuels their creativity and problem-solving abilities. However, the power of ChatGPT cannot be overlooked because it can help solve technical problems, like quickly identifying a bug in a code. – Christena Garduno, Media Culture
19. EMBRACE AI, BUT DON’T RELY ON IT EXCLUSIVELY.
Both leadership and teams should use tools like ChatGPT as an assistant when needed, to enhance what they write or research, or to help save time. However, they should also scrutinize and enhance the outputs of AI with their own human creativity and individual thinking. Generative AI is about increased productivity. Support your humans. Embrace AI as a member of your team. – Deborah Collier, Digital Skills Authority
20. ALLOW AI TO DIRECT YOU, THEN USE YOUR CREATIVITY.
Revise how your people see their relationship with AI. Redirect their thinking from “ChatGPT will do it for me,” to “ChatGPT will act as a director” to have AI provide me 80 percent of what I need to produce personal creative quality. This way, your AI model delivers a desired draft before contributors complete their 20 percent to get to the final product version. This 80 to 20 revision brings the AI/people integration you want. – Jay Steven Levin, WinThinking